A comparison of productivity and learning outcome in individual and cooperative physical therapy clinical education models

Physical Therapy

Volumn 78, Issue 12, 1998, Pages 1288-1301

  Ladyshewsky, Richard K ^a   Barrie, Simon C ^a   Drake, Vaile M ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

Cooperative learning; Education: physical therapist, clinical education; Learning

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CLINICAL EDUCATION; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CONTROLLED STUDY; COOPERATION; LEARNING; PHYSIOTHERAPY; PRODUCTIVITY; STUDENT; TEACHER;

EID: 0031702499     PISSN: 00319023     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/ptj/78.12.1288     Document Type: Article

References (58)

1. DeClute J, Ladyshewsky RK. Enhancing clinical competence using a collaborative clinical education model. Phys Ther. 1993;73:683-689.
2. Emery MJ, Nallette E. Student staffed clinics and creative clinical education during the times of constraint. Clinical Management in Physical Therapy. 1986;6(2):9.
3. Gerace L, Sibilano H. Preparing students for peer collaboration: a clinical teaching model. J Nurs Educ. 1984;23:206-209.
4. Iwasiw C, Goldenberg D. Peer teaching among nursing students in the clinical area: effects on student learning. J Adv Nurs. 1993;18: 659-668.
5. Ladyshewsky RW. Clinical teaching and the 2:1 student-to-clinical instructor ratio. Journal of Physical Therapy Education. 1993;7(1):31-35.
6. Lincoln M, McAllister L. Peer learning in clinical education. Med Teach. 1993;15:17-25.
7. Lynch B. Cooperative learning in interdisciplinary education for the allied health professions, J Allied Health. 1984;13:83-93.
8. Johnson D, Johnson R. Cooperative, competitive, and individualistic learning. Journal of Research and Development in Education. 1978;12(1): 3-15.
9. Topping K. Cooperative learning and peer tutoring: an overview. The Psychologist. 1992;5:151-161.
10. Johnson D, Johnson R. Research shows the benefits of adult cooperation. Educational leadership. 1987;45:27-30.
11. Johnson D, Maruyama G, Johnson R, et al. Effects of cooperative, competitive, and individualistic goal structures on achievement: a meta-analysis. Psychol Bull. 1981;89:47-62.
12. Bruffee K. Collaborative Learning: Higher Education, Interdependence, and the Authority of Knowledge. Baltimore, Md: The Johns Hopkins University Press; 1993.
13. Bandura A. Self-efficacy: The Exercise of Control. New York, NY: WH Freeman and Co; 1997.
14. Bandura A. Social Learning Theory. New York, NY: General Learning Press; 1971.
15. Slavin R. When does cooperative learning increase student achievement? Psychol Bull. 1983;94:429-445.
16. Slavin R. Developmental and motivational perspectives on cooperative learning: a reconciliation. Child Dev. 1987;58:1161-1167.
17. McLaughlin T, Mecham M, Montagne P. Peer tutoring: history, effectiveness, and lack of widespread implementation. Journal of Corrective and Social Psychiatry. 1995;41(4):71-78.
18. Costello J. Learning from each other: peer teaching and learning in student nurse training. Nurse Educ Today. 1989;9:203-206.
19. Tinning R, Fitzclarence L. Students supervising students: an alternative approach to practicum supervision. Australian Journal of Teaching Practice. 1982;2(2):91-100.
20. Hall R, Rocklin T, Dansereau D, et al. The role of individual differences in the cooperative learning of technical material. J Educ Psychol. 1988;80:172-178.
21. Riggio R, Whatley M, Neale P. Effects of student academic ability on cognitive gains using reciprocal peer tutoring. Journal of Social Behaviour and Psychology. 1994;9:529-542.
22. Tiberius R, Gaiptman B. The supervisor-student ratio: 1:1 versus 1:2. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy. 1985;52:179-183.
23. Triggs Nemshick M, Shepard KF. Physical therapy clinical education in a 2:1 student-instructor education model. Phys Ther. 1996;76: 968-981.
24. Williams L. Modified teaching clinic: peer group supervision in clinical training and professional development. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology. 1995;4(3):29-38.
25. Teny W, Higgs J. Educational programmes to develop clinical reasoning skills. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy. 1993;39:47-51.
26. Higgs J. Developing clinical reasoning competencies. Physiotherapy. 1992;78:575-581.
27. Carrier C, Sales G. Pair versus individual work on the acquisition of concepts in a computer-based instructional lesson. Journal of Computer-Based Instruction. 1987;14(1):11-17.
28. Cotton J, Cook M. Meta-analyses and the effects of various systems: some different conclusions from Johnson et al. Psychol Bull. 1982;92: 176-183.
29. Miller L, Hamblin R. Interdependence, differential rewarding, and productivity. American Sociological Review. 1963;28:768-778.
30. Ladyshewsky RK. Enhancing service productivity in acute care inpatient settings using a collaborative clinical education model. Phys Ther. 1995;75:503-510.
31. Ladyshewsky RK, Bird N, Finney J. The impact on departmental productivity during physical therapy student placements: an investigation of outpatient physical therapy services. Physiotherapy Canada. 1994;46:89-93.
32. Bristow B, Hagler P. Impact of physical therapy students on patient service delivery and professional staff time. Physiotherapy Canada. 1994;46:275-280.
33. Kaplow M. Cost Benefit of Physiotherapy Internship in Quebec. Montreal, Quebec, Canada: McGill University; 1980. MSc thesis.
34. MacKinnon JR, Page GG. An analysis and comparison of the educational costs of clinical placements for occupational therapy, physical therapy, speech pathology, and audiology students. J Allied Health. 1986;15:225-238.
35. Page GG, MacKinnon JR. Costs of clinical instructors' time in clinical education: physical therapy students. Phys Ther. 1987;67: 238-243.
36. Bristow D, Hagler P. Comparison of individual physical therapists' productivity to that of combined physical therapist-student pairs. Physiotherapy Canada. 1997;49:16-23.
37. Coulson E, Woeckel D, Copenhaver R, et al. Effects of clinical education on the productivity of private practices. Journal of Physical Therapy Education. 1991;5(1):29-32.
38. Dupont L, Gauthier-Gagnon C, Roch R, Lamoureux M. Group supervision and productivity: from myth to reality. Journal of Physical Therapy Education. 1997;11(2):31-37.
39. Graham C, Catlin P, Morgan J, Martin E. Comparison of 1-day-per-week, 1-week, and 5-week clinical education experiences. Journal of Physical Therapy Education. 1991;5(1):18-23.
40. Leiken A, Stern S, Baines R. The effect of clinical education programs on hospital production. Inquiry. 1983;20:88-92,
41. Leiken AM. Method to determine the effect of clinical education on production in a health care facility. Phys Ther. 1983;63:56-59.
42. Lopopolo RB. Financial model to determine the effect of clinical education programs on physical therapy departments. Phys Ther. 1984;64:1396-1402.
43. Ballinger P, Diesen M. The cost-effectiveness of clinical education. Radial Technol. 1994;66:41-45.
44. Ladyshewsky RK, Barrie SC. An audit tool to measure the costs, henefits, and teaching and learning practices of a clinical education program. Bulletin of the Australian-New Zealand Association of Medical Education. 1996;23(3):14-21.
45. Physiotherapy Workload Measurement System National Hospital Productivity Improvement Program. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Health and Welfare Canada, Statistics Canada Health Division; 1988.
46. Barrows HS. The scope of clinical education. J Med Educ. 1986;61: 23-33.
47. Best D. Physiotherapy clinical supervision: effectiveness and the use of model. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy. 1988;34:209-213.
48. Dunlevy CL, Wolf KN. Perceived differences in the importance and frequency of practice of clinical teaching behaviors. J Allied Health. 1992;21:175-183.
49. Emery MJ. Effectiveness of the clinical instructor: students' perspec-tive. Phys Ther. 1984;64:1079-1083.
50. Freeman E. The importance of feedback in clinical supervision: implications for direct practice. The Clinical Supervisor. 1985;3(1):5-25.
51. Henry JN. Using feedback and evaluation effectively in clinical supervision: model for interaction characteristics and strategies. Phys Ther. 1985;65:354-357.
52. Jarski RW, Kulig K, Olson RE. Allied health perception of effective clinical instruction. J Allied Health. 1989;18:469-478.
53. Onvioha ARA. Effective clinical teaching behaviours from the perspective of students, supervisors, and teachers. Physiotherapy. 1994; 80:208-214.
54. Pratt D, Magill MK. Educational contracts: a basis for effective clinical teaching. J Med Educ. 1983;58:462-467.
55. Watts NT. Handbook of Clinical Teaching. London, England: Churchill Livingstone; 1990.
56. Ash E, Quarry S. The New Supervisor [videorecording]. Melbourne, Victoria, Australia: Seven Dimensions; 1990.
57. Hekelman F, Flynn S, Glover P, et al. Peer coaching in clinical teaching. Evaluation and the Health ftofessions. 1994;17:366-381.
58. Wagstaff M. The team concept in supervised practice: benefits for students and preceptors. J Am Diet Assoc. 1989;89:78-81.