Just des(s)erts? The racial polarization of perceptions of criminal injustice

Law and Society Review

Volumn 31, Issue 4, 1997, Pages 637-676

  Wortley, Scot ^a   Hagan, John ^b   Macmillan, Ross ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

^b NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 0031351129     PISSN: 00239216     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2307/3053983     Document Type: Article

References (166)

1. Alexander, Jeffrey C. (1988a) "Introduction: Durkheimian Sociology and Cultural Studies Today," in Alexander, ed. 1988c.
2. _ (1988b) "Culture and Political Crisis: 'Watergate' and Durkheimian Sociology," in Alexander, ed. 1988c.
3. _, ed. (1988c) Durkheimian Sociology: Cultural Studies. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
4. Alexander, Jeffrey C., & Philip Smith (1993) "The Discourse of American Civil Society: A New Proposal for Cultural Studies," 22 Theory & Society 151-207.
5. Alpert, Geoffrey P., & Roger G. Dunham (1988) Policing Multi-ethnic Neighborhoods: The Miami Study and Findings for Law Enforcement in the United States. New York: Greenwood Press.
6. Anderson, Elijah (1990) Streetwise: Race, Class and Change in an Urban Community. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
7. Apple, Nancy, & David O'Brien (1983) "Neighborhood Racial Composition and Residents' Evaluation of Police Performance," 11 J. of Police Science & Administration 76-84.
8. Armstrong, Lin (1994) "Crime: Let's See the Big Picture," Toronto Sun, 20 April 20, p. 11.
9. Barber, John (1994) "The Threat of Violence Hits Home," Globe & Mail, 8 April, p. A9.
10. Barrile, Leo (1984) "Television and Attitudes about Crime: Do Heavy Viewers Distort Criminality and Support Retributive Justice?" in R. Surette, ed., Justice and the Media: Issues and Research. Springfield, IL: Thomas.
11. Bayley, David H., & Harold Mendelson (1969) Minorities and the Police: Confrontation in America. New York: Free Press.
12. Bellah, Robert N. (1970) "Civil Religion in America," in R. N. Bellah, ed., Beyond Belief: Essays on Religion in a Post-Traditional World. New York: Harper & Row.
13. Berelson, Bernard, Paul F. Lazarsfeld, & William N. McPhee (1954) Voting: A Study of Opinion Formation in a Presidential Campaign. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
14. Black, Donald J. (1980) The Manners and Customs of the Police. New York: Academic Press.
15. Blatchford, Christie (1994a) "Good vs. Evil," Toronto Sun, 7 April, p. 5
16. _ (1994b) "Innocence Lost," Toronto Sun, 7 April, p. 16.
17. _ (1994c) "The Day Toronto Changed," Toronto Sun, 8 April, p. 5.
18. _ (1994d) "What Have We Built?" Toronto Sun, 12 April, p. 5.
19. Blumstein, Alfred, & Jacqueline Cohen (1980) "Sentencing of Convicted Offenders: An Analysis of the Public's View," 14 Law & Society Rev. 223-61.
20. Boggs, Sarah L., & John F. Galliher (1975) "Evaluating the Police: A Comparison of Black Street and Household Respondents," 22 Social Problems 393-406.
21. Brent, Bob (1994a) "Metro Police Services Board Calls for Tougher Gun Laws," Toronto Star, 8 April, p. A6.
22. _ (1994b) "Lymer Rejects Racism Charge," Toronto Star, 21 April, p. A7.
23. Brillon, Yves, Christiane Louis-Guerin, & Marie-Christine Lamarche (1984) Attitudes of the Canadian Public toward Crime Policies. Ottawa: Ministry of the Solicitor General.
24. Broadhurst, Roderic, & David Indermaur (1982) "Crime Seriousness Ratings: The Relationship of Information Accuracy and General Attitudes in Western Australia," 15 Australian & New Zealand J. of Criminology 219-34.
25. Brody, Richard (1991) Assessing the President: The Media, Elite Opinion and Public Support. Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press.
26. Burnett, Thane (1994a) "Quiet Life Shattered: Murder Victim 'Such a Nice, Happy Girl,'" Toronto Sun, 7 April, p. 5.
27. _ (1994b) "She Is among the Saints," Toronto Sun, 12 April, p. 4.
28. California Judicial Council (1994) Fairness in the California State Courts: A Survey of the Public, Attorneys and Court Personnel. Los Angeles: Advisory Committee on Racial and Ethnic Bias in the Courts.
29. Campbell, Dennis (1994) "Young, Black and Male," Toronto Star, 15 May, p. A1.
30. Campion-Smith, Bruce (1994) "Marchi Plans to Get Tough on Criminals," Toronto Star, 1 May, p. A1.
31. Chambliss, William J., & Robert B. Seidman (1971) Law, Order and Power. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
32. Christopoulos, George (1994a) "Mom's Tears: Dreams End at Daughter's Funeral," Toronto Sun, 9 April, p. 4.
33. _ (1994b) "Goodbye: Thousands Moved to Tears at Vivi's Funeral," Toronto Sun, 12 April, p. 14.
34. Cohen, Nathan, ed. (1970) The Los Angeles Riots: A Socio-psychological Study. New York: Praeger.
35. Cohen, Stanley (1972) Folk Devils and Moral Panics: The Creation of the Mods and Rockers. London: MacGibbon & Kee.
36. Cohn, Steven, Steven Barkan, & William Halteman (1991) "Punitive Attitudes towards Criminals: Racial Consensus or Racial Conflict?" 38 Social Problems 287-96.
37. Collins, Erma (1994) "Don't Blame Me; Work with Me," Toronto Star, 19 April, p. A21.
38. Collins, Randall (1988) "The Durkheimian Tradition in Conflict Sociology," in Alexander, ed. 1988c.
39. Conroy, Pat (1994) "Alert for 3 in Cafe Killing," Toronto Star, 10 April, p. A1.
40. Coutts, Jane (1994) "Tonks Sidetracked in Anti-Crime Bid: Focus on Councillor's Gun-Amnesty Move Takes away from Call for Joint Action," Globe & Mail, 19 April, p. A10.
41. Cullen, Francis T., Bruce G. Link, Lawrence Travis, & John Wozniak (1985) "Consensus in Crime Seriousness: Empirical Reality or Methodological Artifact?" 23 Criminology 99-118.
42. Cullen, Francis T., Bruce G. Link, & Craig W. Polanzi (1982) "The Seriousness of Crime Revisited: Have Attitudes toward White-Collar Crime Changed?" 20 Criminology 83-102.
43. Curran, Barbara A. (1977) The Legal Needs of the Public: The Final Report of a National Survey. Chicago: American Bar Foundation.
44. Daly, Rita (1994) "We're All Targets, Black Students Say," Toronto Star, 14 April, p. A3.
45. Darnton, Robert (1975) "Writing News and Telling Stories," 104 Daedalus 175-94.
46. Davis, James F. (1952) "Crime News in Colorado Newspapers," 57 American J. of Sociology 325-30.
47. Desir, Finbar (1994) "It Is Time We Collected Statistics," Toronto Star, 16 April, p. B3.
48. DiManno, Rosie (1994a) "Bishop's Polemic on Crime Wrong at ViVi's Funeral," Toronto Star, 12 April, p. A6.
49. _ (1994b) "Police Union Boss Has Right to Make an Ass out of Himself," Toronto Star, 29 April, p. A7.
50. _ (1994c) "Sharing Guilt 'Appalling,' Blacks Told," Toronto Star, 18 April, p. A6.
51. _ (1994d) "Young Blacks Wear a Stranger's Guilt on Their Faces," Toronto Star, 11 April, p. A7.
52. Doob, Anthony N. (1984) "The Many Realities of Crime," in A. Doob & E. Greenspan, eds., Perspectives in Criminal Law. Aurora, Ont.: Canada Law Books.
53. Douglas, Mary (1966) Purity and Danger: An Analysis of the Concepts of Pollution and Taboo. London: Routledge.
54. Durkan, Sean (1994) "Minister Supports Gun Ban," Toronto Sun, 12 April, p. 15.
55. Durkheim, Emile (1960) The Division of Labour. New York: Free Press.
56. Edwards, Peter (1994) "Group Protesting Crime Wants Tougher Prison Terms," Toronto Star, 25 April, p. A8.
57. Eisenstadt, S. N (1971) Political Sociology. New York: Basic Books.
58. Erikson, Kai (1966) Wayward Puritans: A Study in the Sociology of Deviance. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
59. Foster, Cecil (1994a) "Solution Lies in African Canadian Community," Toronto Star, 10 April, p. A6.
60. _ (1994b) "Black Heroes vs. Black Criminals," Toronto Star, 25 April, p. A11.
61. Friedman, D (1988) "Racism Is Number One Concern," Newsday, 4 April, p. 5.
62. Gangley, Ciaran (1994) "200 Protest Violence," Toronto Sun, 10 April, p. 11.
63. Garfinkle, Harold (1956) "Conditions of Successful Degradation Ceremonies," 61 American J. of Sociology 420-24.
64. Garofalo, James (1981) "Crime and the Mass Media: A Selective Review of Research," 18 J. of Research in Crime & Delinquency 319-50.
65. Georges-Abeyie, Daniel E. (1984) The Criminal Justice System and Blacks. New York: Clark Broardman.
66. Goode, Erich, & Nachman Ben-Yehuda (1994) "Moral Panics: Culture, Politics, and Social Construction," 20 Annual Rev. of Sociology 149-71.
67. Gottfredson, Michael R., & Travis Hirschi (1990) A General Theory of Crime. Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press.
68. Hacker, Andrew (1993) Two Nations: Black and White, Separate, Hostile, Unequal. New York: Ballantine Books.
69. Hagan, John, & Celesta Albonetti (1982) "Race, Class, and the Perception of Criminal Injustice in America," 88 American J. of Sociology 329-55.
70. Hagan, John, & Alberto Palloni (1990) "The Social Reproduction of a Criminal Class in Working-Class London, circa 1950-1980," 96 American J. of Sociology 265-99.
71. Hall, Joseph, & Henry Stancu (1994) "Four Sought after Woman Dies in 'Crash' Robbery," Toronto Star, 7 April, p. A1.
72. Hamilton, V. Lee, & Steven Rytina (1980) "Social Consensus on Norms of Justice: Should Punishment Fit the Crime?" 85 American J. of Sociology 1117-44.
73. Harder, Jeff, & Robert Fife (1994) "United against Guns," Toronto Sun, 14 April, p. 7.
74. Harvey, Edward B., & N. Scot Wortley (1993) Patterns of Socioeconomic Disadvantage for Selected Ethno-cultural Groups: Canada, 1986. Ottawa: Statistics Canada, Interdepartmental Working Group on Employment Equity Data.
75. Hood, Roger (1992) Race and Sentencing: A Study in the Crown Court. A Report for the Commission for Racial Equality. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
76. Isaac, Larry, & Larry Griffin (1989) "Ahistoricism in Time Series Analyses of Historical Process: Critique, Redirection and Illustrations from U.S. Labour History," 54 American Sociological Rev. 873-90.
77. Iyengar, Shanto (1991) Is Anyone Responsible? How Television Frames Political Issues. Chicago: Univ of Chicago Press.
78. Iyengar, Shanto, & Donald R. Kinder (1987) News That Matters: Television and American Opinion. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
79. Jacobs, Ronald (1996) "Civil Society and Crisis: Culture, Discourse, and the Rodney King Beating," 101 American J. of Sociology 1238-72.
80. Johns, Christina J. (1992) Power, Ideology, and the War on Drugs. New York: Praeger.
81. Kaplan, David (1988) "Brawley Charges Fictitious? Law Journal Poll in City on Criminal Justice System," New York Law J., pp. 1-4 (May 24).
82. Katz, Elihu, & Paul Felix Lazarsfeld (1964) Personal, Influence: The Part Played by People in the Flow of Mass Communications. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
83. Keller, Suzanne (1963) Beyond the Ruling Class: Strategic Elites in Modern Society. New York: Random House.
84. Klapper, Joseph T. (1960) The Effects of Mass Communications. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
85. Knowles, Jeffrey J. (1982) Ohio Citizen Attitudes Concerning Crime and Criminal Justice. Columbus: Ohio Department of Economic & Community Development.
86. Lamberti, Rob (1994) "Lowest of the Low: Chief McCormick Blasts New Criminal Attitude," Toronto Sun, 7 April, p. 18.
87. Lem, Sharon (1994a) "Loving Memory: Community Offers Bouquets of Tears for Slain Woman," Toronto Sun, 18 April, p. 18.
88. _ (1994b) "Gun Laws Targeted," Toronto Sun, 25 April, p. 5.
89. Liska, Allen, & William Baccaglini (1990) "Feeling Safe by Comparison: Crime in the Newspapers," 37 Social Problems 360-74.
90. Luyk, Joe (1994) "Bring Back the Death Penalty," Toronto Star, 12 April, p. A16.
91. Lynch, Michael J. (1991) Race and Criminal Justice. New York: Harrow & Heston.
92. MacDonald, Bob (1994) "Turf out Crooked Allens," Toronto Sun, 1 May, p. 14.
93. Maharaj, Raynier (1994) "Crime Crosses All Barriers," Toronto Sun, 15 April, p. 13.
94. Makin, Kirk (1994) "Young Blacks Brace for Crime's Aftermath," Globe & Mail, 9 April, p. A6.
95. Mann, Coramae Richey (1993) Unequal Justice: A Question of Color. Bloomington: Indiana Univ. Press.
96. Mann, Cormarae Richey, & William Wilbanks (1996) "Racism in the Criminal Justice System: Two Sides of a Controversy," in C. Eskridge, ed., Criminal Justice: Concepts and Issues. Los Angeles: Roxbury.
97. Mascoll, Philip (1994a) "More Brutality in Crimes, Chief Says," Toronto Star, 7 April, p. A6.
98. _ (1994b) "Cafe Killers Linked to Another Robbery: Wallet and Shell Found as Tips Flood in to Police," Toronto Star, 8 April, p. A1.
99. McCarthy, Shawn (1994) "Rock Promises Tougher Sentences for Young Offenders," Toronto Star, 9 April, p. A4.
100. McCleary, Richard, Micheal J. O'Neill, Thomas Epperlein, Constance Jones, & Ronald M. Gray (1981) "Effects of Legal Education and Work Experience on Perceptions of Crime Seriousness," 28 Social Problems 276-89.
101. Mead, George Herbert (1918) "The Psychology of Punitive Justice," 23 American J. of Sociology 577-602.
102. Meislin, J. (1988) "New Yorkers Say Race Relations Have Worsened in the Last Year," New York Times, 19 Jan., p. A1.
103. Moodie, Andrew (1994) "Forget about Colour of Criminals," Toronto Star, 16 April, p. B3.
104. Moon, Peter (1994) "Clamour over Legislation Called an Overreaction," Globe & Mail, 12 April, p. A5.
105. Moore, Robert (1985) "Reflections of Canadians on the Law and Legal System: Legal Research Institute Survey of Respondents in Montreal, Toronto, and Winnipeg," in D. Gibson & J. K. Baldwin, eds., Law in a Cyncical Society? Opinion and Law in the 1980s. Calgary: Carswell Legal Publications.
106. Morin, Richard (1995) "A Distorted Image of Minorities: Poll Suggests That What Whites Think They See May Affect Beliefs," Washington Post, 8 Oct., p. A1.
107. Murphy, Raymond J., & James W. Watson (1970) "The Structure of Discontent: The Relationship between Social Structure, Grievance and Riot Support," in Cohen, ed. 1970.
108. New York State Judicial Commission (1991) Report of the NY State Judicial Commission on Minorities: The Public and the Courts, vol. 2. New York: New York State Judicial Commission on Minorities.
109. Northrup, David (1994) Public Opinion Survey: Commission on Systemic Racism in the Criminal Justice System, Technical Documentation. Toronto: Institute for Social Research, York Univ.
110. Odetoyinbo, Deji (1994) "To a Lynch Mob This Black Man Is All Suspects," Toronto Star, 16 April, p. B3.
111. Orum, Anthony M. . & Roberta S. Cohen (1973) "The Development of Political Orientations among Black and White Children," 38 American Sociological Rev. 62-73.
112. Page, Benjamin I., Robert Y. Shapiro, & Glenn R. Dempsey (1987) "What Moves Public Opinion?" 81 American Political Science Rev. 23-44.
113. Parisi, Nicholette, Michael R. Gottfredson, Michael J. Hindelang, & Timothy J. Flanagan (1979) Sourcebook of Criminal Justice Statistics - 1978. Washington, DC: GPO.
114. Parker, Keith D., Anne B. Onyekwuluje, & Komanduri S. Murty (1995) "African Americans' Attitudes toward the Local Police: A Multivariate Analysis," 25 J. of Black Studies 396-409.
115. Peek, Charles W., George D. Lowe, & Jon P. Alston (1981) "Race and Attitudes toward Local Police: Another Look," 11 J. of Black Studies 361-74.
116. Peek, Charles W., Jon P. Alston, & George D. Lowe (1978) "Comparative Evaluation of the Local Police," 42 Public Opinion Q. 370-79.
117. Price, Vincent (1992) Public Opinion. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
118. Price, Vincent, & John Zaller (1990) "Measuring Individual Differences in the Likelihood of News Reception." Presented at American Political Science Association annual meeting, San Francisco.
119. Pron, Nick, & John Duncanson (1994) "ViVi Probe Sparked Internal Police Clash," Toronto Star, 27 April, p. A1.
120. Quamina, Odida (1994) "We, Too, Are Concerned," Share, 14 April, p. 7.
121. Quinney, Richard (1970) The Social Reality of Crime. Boston: Little, Brown.
122. Raines, Walter J. (1970) "The Perception of Police Brutality in South Central Los Angeles," in Cohen, ed. 1970.
123. Rickards, Colin (1994) "Blaming Young Black Males," Share, 14 April, p. 7.
124. Roberts, Julian V. (1988) Public Opinion and Sentencing: The Surveys of the Canadian Sentencing Commission. Ottawa: Department of Justice Canada.
125. _ (1992) "Public Opinion, Crime, and Criminal Justice," in M. Tonry, ed., Crime and Justice: A Review of Research. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
126. Roberts, Julian V., & Anthony N. Doob (1990) "News Media Influences on Public Views of Sentencing," 14 Law & Human Behavior 451-68.
127. Roberts, Julian V., & Thomas Gabor (1990) "Lombrosian Wine in a New Bottle: Research on Race and Crime," 32 Canadian J. of Criminology 291-313.
128. Roberts, Kim (1994) "Bishop's Call for Statistics Is Appalling and Offensive," Toronto Star, 16 April, p. B3.
129. Robertson, Ian (1994) "Remand for Brown: Accused Killer in Court Smirking and Smiling," Toronto Sun, 15 April, p. 4.
130. Sarick, Lila (1994) "System Failed Us, Marchi Concludes," Globe & Mail, 28 April, p. A1.
131. Schrager, Laura, & James F. Short, Jr. (1980) "How Serious a Crime? Perceptions of Organizational and Common Crimes," in G. Geis & E. Shetland, eds., White-Collar Crime: Theory and Research. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
132. Schudson, Micheal (1982) "The Politics of Narrative Form: The Emergence of News Conventions in Print and Television," 111 Daedalus 97-112.
133. Schur, Edwin (1980) The Politics of Deviance: Stigma Contests and the Uses of Power. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
134. Scaglion, Richard, & Richard G. Condon (1980) "Determinants of Attitudes toward City Police," 17 Criminology 485-94.
135. Sheley, Joseph F., & Cindy D. Ashkins (1981) "Crime, Crime News, and Crime Views," 44 Public Opinion Q. 492-506.
136. Skolnick, Jerome H. (1966) Justice without Trial: Law Enforcement in a Democratic Society. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
137. Small, Peter (1994) "'Please Give Yourself Up' Says Brother of the Victim," Toronto Star, 8 April, p. A1.
138. Smyth, Julie (1994) "Search for Shooting Suspect Widens: OPP Given Descriptions, Names as Protesters Call for Action," Globe & Mail, 11 April, p. A2.
139. Statistics Canada (1993) Dimensions: Profile of Ethnic Groups, 1991. Cat. No. 94-311. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
140. Stewart, Mark (1994a) "No Mercy: Crooks Getting More Vicious," Toronto Sun, 7 April, p. 4.
141. _ (1994b) "Dragnet: Cops Pull out All Stops to Catch Killers," Toronto Sun, 8 April, p. 4.
142. _ (1994c) "Cops Sift Tips: Police Optimistic They'll Nail Just Desserts Killers," Toronto Sun, 10 April, p. 5.
143. Stewart, Mark, & Kevin Hann (1994) "Arrest: Suspect Surrenders in Just Desserts Murder," Toronto Sun, 14 April, p. 4.
144. Stinchcombe, Arthur L., Rebecca Adams, Carol A. Heimer, Kim Lane Schepple, Tom W. Smith, & D. Garth Taylor (1980) Crime and Punishment: Changing Attitudes in America. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
145. Tannenbaum, Frank (1938) Crime and the Community. New York: Columbia Univ. Press.
146. Taylor, Ian R., Paul Walton, & Jock Young (1973) The New Criminology: For a Social Theory of Deviance. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
147. Thompson, Allan (1994) "Allowing Suspect to Stay Was Mistake, Marchi Says," Toronto Star, 28 April, p. A4.
148. Toronto Star (1994a) "Urban Terrorism Blamed in Cafe Killing," Toronto Star, 7 April, p. A1.
149. _ (1994b) "Color Classification for Crime Statistics," Toronto Star, 16 April, p. B2.
150. Toronto Sun (1994a) "In Cold Blood: Has It Come to This in Metro?" Toronto Sun, 7 April, p. 1.
151. _ (1994b) "Readers Demand Death Penalty," Toronto Sun, 8 April, p. 18.
152. Turk, Austin (1977) "Class, Conflict and Criminalization," 10 Sociological Focus 209-20.
153. Turner, Victor W. (1969) The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. Chicago: Aldine.
154. Tyler, Tom (1990) Why People Obey the Law. New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press.
155. Tyler, Tracey (1994) "Suspects Arrested in ViVi Slaying: Man Sought by Police Surrenders," Toronto Star, 14 April, p. A1.
156. Walker, Nigel, & J. M. Hough (1988) Public Attitudes to Sentencing: Surveys from Five Countries. Brookfield, VT: Gower.
157. Warr, Mark, Jack Meier, & Maynard Erickson (1983) "Norms, Theories of Punishment and Publicly Preferred Penalties for Crimes," 24 Sociological Q. 75-91.
158. Whitaker, Mark (1995) "The Reaction: Whites vs. Blacks," Newsweek, 16 Oct., pp. 28-35.
159. Wilbanks, William (1987) The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System. Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.
160. Wiley, Mary G., & Terry L. Hudik (1974) "Police-Citizen Encounters: A Field Test of Exchange Theory," 22 Social Problems 119-27.
161. Wilkes, Jim (1994) "Lawrence Brown Smiles at Crowd," Toronto Star, 15 April, p. A1.
162. Wilkes, Jim, & Peter Small (1994) "3,500 Mourn Woman Killed at Cafe," Toronto Star, 12 April, p. A6.
163. Wilkins, Roy (1985) "Stop and Frisk," in A. Niederhoffer & A. S. Blumberg, eds., The Ambivalent Force: Perspectives on the Police. New York. Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
164. Wolfgang, E. Marvin, Robert M. Figlio, Paul E. Tracey, & Simon I. Singer (1985) The National Survey of Crime Severity. Washington, DC: GPO.
165. Zaller, John (1992) The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
166. Zerbisias, Antonia (1994) "Let's Not Bury Our City with ViVi," Toronto Star, 8 April, p. A21.