Free food or earned food? A review and fuzzy model of contrafreeloading

Animal Behaviour

Volumn 53, Issue 6, 1997, Pages 1171-1191

  Inglis, I R ^a   Forkman, Bjorn ^b   Lazarus, John ^c  

^a CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENT   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH   (United Kingdom)

^c NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANIMALIA;

EID: 0031172244     PISSN: 00033472     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1006/anbe.1996.0320     Document Type: Article

References (144)

1. Alferink, L. A., Crossman, E. K. & Cheney, C. D. 1973. Control of responding by a conditioned reinforcer in the presence of free food. Anim. Learn. Behav., 1, 38-40.
2. Anderson, J. R. & Chamove, A. S. 1984. Allowing captive primates to forage. In: Standards in Laboratory Animals Management (Part 2), pp. 253-256. Potters Bar, UK: Universities Federation of Animal Welfare.
3. Atnip, G. & Hothersall, D. 1973. The preference of albino rats for free or response-produced food. Bull. Psychonom. Sci., 2, 153-154.
4. Baenninger, R. & Mattleman, R. A. 1973. Visual reinforcement: operant acquisition in the presence of a free mirror. Anim. Learn. Behav., 1, 302-306.
5. Barnes, G. W. & Baron, A. 1961. Stimulus complexity and sensory reinforcement. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 54, 466-469.
6. Barnet, S. A. 1958. Experiments on 'neophobia' in wild and laboratory rats. Er. J. Psychol., 4, 195-201.
7. Barnett, S. A. & Cowan, P. E. 1976. Activity, exploration, curiosity and fear: an ethological study. Interdiscip. Sci. Rev., 1, 43-62.
8. Barnett, S. A., Dickson, R. G., Marples, T. G. & Radha, E. 1978. Sequences of feeding, sampling and exploration by wild and laboratory rats. Behav. Proc., 3, 29-43.
9. Berlyne, D. E. 1960. Conflict, Arousal and Curiosity. New York: McGraw-Hill.
10. Bilbrey, J. L., Patterson, D. D. & Winokur, S. 1973. Maintenance and autoshaping of key pecking in undeprived pigeons. Bull Psychonom. Sci, 2, 394-396.
11. Black, M. 1937. Vagueness. Philosophy Sci., 4, 427-455.
12. Carder, B. & Beckman, G. C. 1975. Limitations of 'container neophobia' as an explanation of rats responding for food in the presence of free food. Behav. Biol., 14, 109-113.
13. Carder, B. & Berkowitz, K. I. 1970. Rats preference for earned in comparison with free food. Science, 167, 1273-1274.
14. Carlson, C. W. & Riccio, D. C. 1976. Experience with the reinforcer and the preference for earned rather than free reinforcers in rats. Anim. Learn. Behav., 4, 269-272.
15. Coburn, J. F. & Tarte, R. D. 1976. The effect of rearing environment on the contrafreeloading phenomenon in rats. J. exp. Analysis Behav., 26, 289-294.
16. Cowan, P. E. 1976. The new object reaction of Rattus rattus: the relative importance of various cues. Behav. Biol., 16, 31-44.
17. Cowan, P. E. 1977. Systematic patrolling and orderly behaviour of rats during recovery from deprivation. Anim. Behav., 25, 171-184.
18. Davidson, A. G. 1971. Factors affecting keypress responding by rats in the presence of free food. Psychonom. Sci., 24, 135-137.
19. Davis, S. F., Beighley, B. G., Libretto, J. S., Mollenhour, M. J. & Prytula, R. E. 1975. Contrafreeloading as a function of early environmental conditions. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 65, 95-97.
20. Dember, W. N. 1956. Response by the rat to environmental change. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 49, 93-95.
21. De Valois, R. L. 1954. The relation of different levels and kinds of motivation to variability of behaviour. J. exp. Psychol., 47, 392-398.
22. Duncan, I. J. & Hughes, B. O. 1972. Free and operant feeding in domestic fowls. Anim. Behav., 20, 775-777.
23. Egger, M. D. & Miller, N. E. 1962. Secondary reinforcement in rats as a function of the stimulus. J. exp. Psychol., 64, 97-104.
24. Eisenberger, R. 1972. Explanations of rewards that do not reduce tissue needs. Psychol. Bull, 77, 319-339.
25. Feild, C. L., Kasper, S. & Mitchell, D. 1984. Effort and contrafreeloading. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 22, 147-150.
26. Ferster, C. B. & Skinner, B. F. 1957. Schedules of Reinforcement. New York: Appleton-Century-Croft.
27. Fitzgerald, R. E., Isler, R., Rosenberg, E., Oettinger, R. & Battig, K. 1985. Maze patrolling by rats with and without food reward. Anim. Learn. Behav., 13, 451-462.
28. Forkman, B. 1991. Some problems with current patch-choice theory: a study on the Mongolian gerbil. Behaviour, 117, 243-254.
29. Forkman, B. 1993a. Self-reinforced behaviour does not explain contra-freeloading in the Mongolian gerbil. Ethology, 94, 109-112.
30. Forkman, B. 1993b. The effect of uncertainty on the food intake of the Mongolian gerbil. Behaviour, 124, 197-206.
31. Forkman, B. 1996. The foraging behaviour of Mongolian gerbils : a behavioural need or a need to know? Behaviour, 133, 129-143.
32. Fowler, H. 1965. Curiosity and Exploratory Behavior. New York: Macmillan.
33. Gaines, B. R. 1976. Foundations of fuzzy reasoning. Int. J. Man-Machine Studies, 8, 623-668.
34. Gardner, R. A. & Gardner, B. T. 1988. Feed forward versus feed backwards : an ethological alternative to the law of effect. Behav. Brain. Sci., 11, 429-493.
35. Glanzer, M. 1953. Stimulus satiation: an explanation of spontaneous alternation and related phenomena. Psychol. Rev., 60, 257-268.
36. Harth, E. & Tzanakou, E. 1974. Alopex: a stochastic method for determining visual receptive fields. Vision Res., 14, 1475.
37. Havelka, J. 1956. Problem-seeking behaviour in rats. Can. J. Psychol., 10, 91-97.
38. Hebb, D. O. & Mahut, H. 1955. Motivation et recherche du chargement perceptif chez le rat et chez l'homme. J. Psychol. norm. path., 48, 209-221.
39. Hendrick, I. 1943. The discussion of the 'instinct to master'. Psychoanal. Q., 11, 243-266.
40. Hinton, G. E. & Sejnowski, T. J. 1986. Parallel Distributed Processing. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.
41. Hogan, J. A. 1967. Fighting and reinforcement in the Siamese fighting fish (Betta splendens). J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 64, 356-359.
42. Holland, J. H., Holyoak, K. J., Nisbett, R. E. & Thagard, P. R. 1987. Induction. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.
43. Hothersall, D., Huey, D. & Thatcher, K. 1973. The preference of rats for free or response-produced food. Anim. Learn. Behav., 1, 241-243.
44. Houston, A., Kacelnik, A. & McNamara, J. 1982. Some learning rules for acquiring information. In: Functional Ontogeny (Ed. D. McFarland), pp. 140-191. London: Pitman.
45. Hughes, B. O. & Duncan, I. J. H. 1988. The notion of ethological need, models of motivation and animal welfare. Anim. Behav., 36, 1696-1707.
46. Hull, C. L. 1943. Principals of Behavior. New York: Appleton-Century-Croft.
47. HyperLogic 1993. CubiCalc. California: HyperLogic Corporation.
48. Inglis, I. R. 1975. Enriched sensory experience in adulthood increases subsequent exploratory behaviour in the rat. Anim. Behav., 23, 932-940.
49. Inglis, I. R. 1983. Towards a cognitive theory of exploratory behaviour. In: Exploration in Animals and Humans (Eds. J. Archer & L. Burke), pp. 72-116. London: Van Nostrand Reinhold.
50. Inglis, I. R. 1987. The information-primacy approach: a reply to Kacelnik. Anim Behav., 35, 926-927.
51. Inglis, I. R. & Ferguson, N. J. K. 1986. Starlings search for food rather than eat freely available, identical food. Anim. Behav., 34, 614-617.
52. Inglis, I. R. & Freeman, N. H. 1976. Reversible effects of ambient housing stimulation upon stimulation-seeking in rats. Q. Jl exp. Psychol., 28, 409-417.
53. Inglis, I. R. & Shepherd, D. S. 1994. Rats work for food they then reject: support for the information-primacy approach to learned industriousness. Ethology, 98, 154-164.
54. Jensen, E. D. 1963. Preference for bar pressing over free-loading as a function of number of unrewarded presses. J. exp. Psychol., 65, 451-454.
55. Jensen, G. D., Leung, C. M. & Hess, D. T. 1970. 'Freeloading' in the skinner box contrasted with freeloading in the runway. Psychol. Rep., 27, 67-73.
56. Kacelnik, A. 1987. Information primacy or preference for familiar foraging techniques? A critique of Inglis & Ferguson. Anim. Behav., 35, 925-926.
57. Kavanau, J. L. 1967. Behavior of captive white-footed mice. Science, 155, 1623-1639.
58. Kish, G. B. 1966. Studies of sensory reinforcement. In: Operant Behavior (Ed. W. K. Honig), pp. 57-83. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
59. Kleinman, K. M., McLaughlin, R. J., Gerard, I. V., Boxza, D. A. & Clipper, R. C. 1976. Rats' preference for the more effortful of two responses as a function of prior training. Psychol. Rep., 38, 931-937.
60. Knutson, J. R. & Carlson, C. W. 1973. Operant responding with free access to the reinforcer: a replication and extension. Anim. Learn. Behav., 2, 133-136.
61. Koffer, K. & Coulson, G. 1971. Feline indolence: cats prefer free to response-produced food. Psychonom. Sci., 24, 41-42.
62. Konrad, K. & Bagshaw, M. 1970. The effect of novel stimuli on cats reared in a restricted environment. J. comp. physiol Psychol., 70, 157-164.
63. Kopp, J., Bourland, G., Tarte, R. D. & Vernon, C. R. 1976. Acquisition of bar pressing in non-deprived rats. Psychol. Rec., 26, 49-54.
64. Kosko, B. 1994. Fuzzy Thinking. London: Flamingo.
65. Krebs, J. R. & Kacelnik, A. 1991. Decision making. In: Behavioural Ecology: An Evolutionary Approach. 3rd. edn. (Ed. by J. R. Krebs & N. B. Davies), pp. 105-136. Oxford: Blackwell.
66. Krebs, J. R. & McCleery, R. H. 1984. Optimization in behavioural ecology. In: Behavioural Ecology, An Evolutionary Approach. 2nd. edn. (Ed. by J. R. Krebs & N. B. Davies), pp. 91-122. Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications.
67. Krebs, J. R., Kacelnik, A. & Taylor, P. 1978. Test of optimal sampling by foraging great tits. Nature, Lond., 275, 27-31.
68. Lamal, P. A. 1978. Reinforcement schedule and children's preference for working versus freeloading. Psychol. Rep., 42, 143-149.
69. Larson, L. D. & Tarte, R. D. 1976. The effects of training and effortfulness on rats' choice behaviour in a modified T-maze. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 7, 506-508.
70. Lentz, B. E. & Cohen, S. L. 1980. The effect of prior training on the contrafreeloading phenomenon. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 15, 48-50.
71. Leung, C. M., Jensen, G. D. & Tapley, R. P. 1968. Freeloading in a runway as a function of amount of training and type of reinforcement schedule. Psychol. Rep., 22, 211-214.
72. Lima, S. L. 1984. Downy woodpecker foraging behaviour: efficient sampling in simple stochastic environments. Ecology, 65, 166-174.
73. Mackintosh, N. J. 1974. The Psychology of Animal Learning. London: Academic Press.
74. McLaughlin, R. J., Kleinman, K. M. & Vaugh, L. G. 1973. Effects of prior training at lever pressing on rats' subsequent responding for food or water in the presence of free rewards. Proc. 81st Ann. Convent. A.P.A., 8, 845-846.
75. McNamara, J. & Houston, A. 1980. The application of statistical decision theory to animal behaviour. J. theor. Biol., 85, 673-690.
76. Melcer, T. & Timberlake, W. 1985. Poison avoidance and patch (location) selection in rats. Anim. Learn. Behav., 13, 60-68.
77. Menzel, E. W. 1962. The effects of stimulus size and proximity upon avoidance of complex objects in rhesus monkeys. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 55, 1044-1046.
78. Menzel, E. W. 1991. Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) problem seeking versus bird-in-hand, least effort strategy. Primates, 32, 497-508.
79. Mitchell, D. 1976. Experiments on neophobia in wild and laboratory rats: a reevaluation. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 90, 190-197.
80. Mitchell, P. & White, K. G. 1977. Responding in the presence of free food: differential exposure to the reinforcement source. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 10, 121-124.
81. Mitchell, D., Scott, D. W. & Williams, K. D. 1973. Container neophobia and the rat's preference for earned food. Behavl. Biol., 9, 613-624.
82. Mitchell, D., Williams, K. D. & Sutter, J. 1974. Container neophobia as a prediction of preference for earned food by rats. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 4, 182-184.
83. Mitchell, D., Becnel, J. R. & Blue, T. 1981. The neophobia-optimality explanation of contra-freeloading in rats: a reassessment. Behavl Neural Biol., 32, 454-462.
84. Mitchell, D., Fish, R. C. & Calica, D. R. 1982. Rats respond for food in the presence of free food: how free is the 'free' food? Learn. Motiv., 13, 257-263.
85. Montgomery, K. C. 1955. The relation between fear induced by novel stimulation and exploratory behaviour. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 48, 254-260.
86. Morgan, M. J. 1974. Do rats like to work for their food? Learn. Motiv, 5, 352-368.
87. Morgan, M. J., Einon, D. F. & Nicholas, D. 1975. The effects of isolation rearing on behaviour inhibition in the rat. Q. Jl exp. Psychol., 27, 625-634.
88. Nau, K. L., Elias, J. W. & Bell, R. W. 1981. Arousal and bar pressing versus freeloading in Fischer 344 rats. J. Gen. Psychol., 104, 125-132.
89. Neuringer, A. J. 1969. Animals respond for food in the presence of free food. Science, 16, 399-40.
90. Neuringer, A. J. 1970. Many responses for food reward with free food present. Science, 169, 503-504.
91. Osborne, S. R. 1977. The free food (contrafreeloading) phenomenon: a review and analysis. Anim. Learn. Behav., 5, 221-235.
92. Osborne, S. R. & Shelby, M. 1975. Stimulus change as a factor in response maintenance with free food available. J. exp. Analysis Behav., 24, 17-21.
93. Pallaud, B. 1971. Contribution a l'étude d'une situation de choix la souris. Rev. Comporte. Anim., 5, 293-297.
94. Plowright, C. M. S. & Plowright, R. C. 1987. Oversampling by great tits? A critique of Krebs, Kacelnik, and Taylor's (1978) Test of optimal sampling by great tits'. Can. J. Zool., 65, 1282-1283.
95. Powell, R. L. 1974. Comparative studies of the preference for free vs response-produced reinforcers. Anim. Learn. Behav., 2, 185-188.
96. Rachlin, H. & Baum, W. M. 1972. Effects of alternative reinforcement: does the source matter? J. exp. Analysis Behav., 18, 231-241.
97. Rechten, C., Avery, M. & Stevens, A. 1983. Optimal prey selection: why do great tits show partial preferences? Anim. Behav., 31, 576-584.
98. Reinhardt, V. 1994. Caged rhesus macaques voluntarily work for ordinary food. Primates, 35, 95-98.
99. Robertson, L. C. & Anderson, S. C. 1975. The effects of different type and magnitude of reward on the contra-freeloading phenomenon in rats. Anim. Learn. Behav., 3, 325-328.
100. Russell, B. 1923. Vagueness. Austral. J. Phil., 1, 84-92.
101. Russell, P. A. 1983. Psychological studies of exploration in animals: a reappraisal. In: Exploration in Animals and Humans (Ed. J. Archer & L. Birke), pp. 72-116. London: Van Nostrand Rheinhold.
102. Rutter, S. & Nevin, J. A. 1990. Long-term contra-freeloading in rats during continuous sessions. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 28, 556-558.
103. Sawisch, L. P. & Denny, M. R. 1973. Reversing the reinforcement contingencies of eating and keypecking behaviours. Anim. Learn. Behav., 1, 189-199.
104. Shepherdson, D. J., Carlstead, K., Mellen, J. D. & Seidensticker, J. 1993. The influence of food presentation on the behaviour of small cats in confined environments. Zool. Biol., 12, 203-216.
105. Shettleworth, S. A., Krebs, J. R., Stephens, D. W. & Gibbon, J. 1988. Tracking a fluctuating environment: a study of sampling. Anim. Behav., 36, 87-105.
106. Singh, D. 1970. Preference for bar pressing to obtain reward over freeloading in rats and children. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 73, 320-327.
107. Singh, D. 1972. The pied piper vs the Protestant ethic. Psychol. Today, Jan, 53-56.
108. Singh, D. & Query, W. T. 1971. Preference for work over 'freeloading' in children. Psychonom. Sci., 24, 77-79.
109. Smith, J. N. M. & Dawkins, R. 1971. The hunting behaviour of individual great tits in relation to spatial variations in their food density. Anim. Behav., 19, 695-706.
110. Smith, J. N. M. & Sweatman, H. P. A. 1974. Food-searching behaviour of titmice in patch environments. Ecology, 55, 1216-1232.
111. Snygg, D. 1936. Mazes in which the rat takes the longer path to food. J. Psychol., 1, 153-156.
112. Stadden, J. E. R. 1983. Adaptive Behaviour and Learning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
113. Stephens, D. W. 1993. Learning and behavioural ecology: incomplete information and environmental predictability. In: Insect Learning: Ecology and Environmental Perspectives (Ed. by D. R. Papaj & A. C. Lewis), pp. 195-218. New York: Chapman & Hall.
114. Stephens, D. W. & Krebs, J. R. 1986. Foraging Theory. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
115. Stephens, R. M., Metze, L. P. & Craig, J. R. 1975. The Protestant ethic effect in a multichoice environment. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 6, 137-139.
116. Stolz, S. B. & Lott, D. F. 1964. Establishment in rats of a persistent response producing a net loss of reinforcement. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 57, 147-149.
117. Studelska, D. R. & Kemble, E. D. 1979. Effects of briefly experienced environmental complexity on open field behaviour in rats. Behavl Neural Biol., 26, 492-496.
118. Sunquist, F. & Sunquist, M. 1991. Ocelots and servals. In: Great Cats (Ed. by J. Seidensticker & S. Lumpkin), pp 156-161. Emmaus, Pennsylvania: Rodale Press.
119. Tamm, S. 1987. Tracking varying environments: sampling by hummingbirds. Anim. Behav., 35, 1725-1734.
120. Tarte, R. D. 1981. Contra-freeloading in humans. Psychol. Rep., 49, 859-866.
121. Tarte, R. D. & Rasmussen, C. T. 1979. Training effects on contra-freeloading in rats housed in operant chambers. Anim. Learn. Behav., 7, 69-74.
122. Tarte, R. D. & Snyder, R. L. 1972. Barpressing in the presence of free food as a function of food deprivation. Psychonom. Sci., 26, 169-170.
123. Tarte, R. D. & Snyder, R. L. 1973. Some sources of Variation in the bar-pressing versus free-loading phenomenon in rats. J. comp. physiol. Psychol, 84, 128-133.
124. Tarte, R. D. & Vernon, C. R. 1974. Rats barpressing in the presence of free food as a function of fixed-ratio schedules. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 3, 34-36.
125. Tarte, R. D., Townsend, S. G. & Vernon, C. R. 1973. Housing environments and the barpressing vs free-loading phenomenon in rats. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 2, 69-71.
126. Tarte, R. D., Townsend, S. G., Vernon, C. R. & Rovner, L. 1974. An examination of various deprivation-reward combinations in the bar pressing vs freeloading phenomenon in rats. Bull. Psychonom. Soc., 3, 227-229.
127. Taylor, G. T. 1972. A limitation of the contra-freeloading phenomenon. Psychonom. Sci., 29, 173-174.
128. Taylor, G. T. 1975. Discriminability and the contra-freeloading phenomenon. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 88, 104-109.
129. Thistlethwaite, D. L. 1951. A critical review of latent learning and related experiments. Psychol. Rev., 48, 97-129.
130. Tolman, E. C. 1932. Purposive Behavior in Animals and Man. New York: Appleton-Century-Croft.
131. Tolman, E. C. 1948. Cognitive maps in rats and men. Psychol. Rev., 55, 189-208.
132. Tolman, E. C. 1959. Principles of purposive behaviour. In: Psychology: A Study of a Science, Vol 2. (Ed. by S. Koch), pp. 92-157. New York: McGraw-Hill.
133. Tolman, E. C. & Brunswik, E. 1935. The organism and the causal texture of the environment. Psychol. Rev., 42, 43-77.
134. Wallace, R. F., Osborne, S., Norborg, J. & Fantino, E. 1973. Stimulus change contemporaneous with food presentation maintains responding in the presence of free food. Science, 182, 1038-1039.
135. Wallace, R. J. & Barnett, S. A. 1990. Avoidance of new objects by the black rat Rattus rattus after object presentation and change. Int. J. comp. Psychol., 3, 253-265.
136. Welker, W. I. 1956. Some determinants of play and exploration in chimpanzees. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 49, 84-89.
137. Welker, W. I. & King, W. A. 1962. Effects of stimulus novelty on gnawing and eating by rats. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 55, 838-842.
138. White, R. W. 1959. Motivation reconsidered: the concept of competence. Psychol. Rev., 66, 297-333.
139. Wiltz & Bolton 1971. Exploratory behaviour in response to the spatial rearrangements of familiar stimuli. Psychonom. Sci., 24, 117-118.
140. Woods, P. J., Ruckelhaus, S. I. & Bowling, D. M. 1960. Some effects of 'free' and 'restricted' environment rearing conditions upon adult behaviour in the rat. Psychol. Rep., 6, 191-200.
141. Woodworth, R. S. 1958. Dynamics of Behavior. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
142. Zadeh, L. A. 1965. Fuzzy sets. Inf. Contr., 8, 338-353.
143. Zadeh, L. A., Fu, K. S., Tanaka, K. & Shimura, M. 1975. Fuzzy Sets and Their Application to Cognitive and Decision Processes. New York: Academic Press.
144. Zimbardo, P. G. & Montgomery, K. C. 1957. Effects of 'free' environment rearing upon exploratory behaviour. Psychol. Rep., 3, 589-594.