Sex differences in the human corpus callosum: Myth or reality?

Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews

Volumn 21, Issue 5, 1997, Pages 581-601

  Bishop, Katherine M ^a   Wahlsten, Douglas ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Allometry; Brain size; Effect size; Literature review; Meta analysis; Morphometry; Ratio measures; Statistical power

Indexed keywords

ANALYTIC METHOD; ARTICLE; BRAIN CORTEX; BRAIN SIZE; COGNITION; CORPUS CALLOSUM; DATA ANALYSIS; HUMAN; HUMAN TISSUE; METABOLIC RATE; NEUROANATOMY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SEX DIFFERENCE; SEXUAL BEHAVIOR;

CORPUS CALLOSUM; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; SEX CHARACTERISTICS;

EID: 0030703276     PISSN: 01497634     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0149-7634(96)00049-8     Document Type: Article

References (132)

1. Aboitiz F., Scheibel A.B., Fisher R.S., Zaidel E. Fiber composition of the human corpus callosum. Brain Res. 598:1992;143-153.
2. Aboitiz F., Scheibel A.B., Zaidel E. Morphometry of the sylvian fissure and the corpus callosum, with emphasis on sex differences. Brain. 115:1992;1521-1541.
3. Alaton, S. What is he, what is she? The Globe and Mail. 22 August D1, D4; 1992.
4. Allen L.S., Richey M.F., Chai Y.M., Gorski R.A. Sex differences in the corpus callosum of the living human being. J. Neurosci. 11:1991;933-942.
5. Andreasen N.C., Flaum M., Swayze V., O'Leary D.S., Alliger R., Cohen G., Ehrhardt J., Yuh W.T.C. Intelligence and brain structure in normal individuals. Am. J. Psychiatry. 150:1993;130-134.
6. Atchley W.R., Gasksins C.T., Anderson D. Statistical properties of ratios. I. Empirical results Syst. Zool. 25:1976;137-148.
7. Baack J., de Lacoste-Utamsing C., Woodward D.J. Sexual dimorphism in human fetal corpora callosa. Soc. Neurosci. Abstr. 8:1982;213.
8. Bean R.B. Some racial peculiarities of the negro brain. Am. J. Anat. 5:1906;353-415.
9. Bell A.D., Variend S. Failure to demonstrate sexual dimorphism of the corpus callosum in childhood. J. Anat. 143:1985;143-147.
10. Berrebi A.S., Fitch R.H., Ralphe D.L., Denenberg J.O., Friedrich V.L. Jr., Denenberg V.H. Corpus callosum: region-specific effects of sex, early experience and age. Brain Res. 438:1988;216-224.
11. Bigger brain debate continues. Edmonton Journal 15 September E2; 1989.
12. Bishop D.V.M. How to increase your chances of obtaining a significant association between handedness and disorder. J. Clin. Exp. Neuropsychol. 12:1990;812-816.
13. Bleier, R. Sex differences research and the neurosciences: science or belief. Invited address, Society for Neuroscience Annual Meeting. Dallas, Texas; 1985.
14. Blumrich, C. Mapping the neural scene. Newsweek 27 March 51; 1995.
15. Brain nerves larger in women. Edmonton Journal 2 June G6; 1991.
16. Breedlove S.M. Sexual differentiation of the human nervous system. A. Rev. Psychol. 45:1994;389-418.
17. Bryden M.P., McManus I.C., Bulman-Fleming M.B. Evaluating the empirical support for the Geschwind-Behan-Galaburda model of cerebral lateralization. Brain Cogn. 26:1994;103-167.
18. Burke H.L., Yeo R.A. Systematic variations in callosal morphology: the effects of age, gender, hand preference, and anatomic asymmetry. Neuropsychology. 8:1994;563-571.
19. Bushman B.J., Wang M.C. A procedure for combining sample standardized mean differences and vote counts to estimate the population standardized mean difference in fixed effect models. Psychol. Meths. 1:1996;66-80.
20. Buyse M. Interim analyses, stopping rules and data monitoring in clinical trials in Europe. Stat. Med. 12:1993;509-520.
21. Byne W. Science and belief: psychobiological research on sexual orientation. J. Homosex. 28:1995;303-344.
22. Byne W., Bleier R., Houston L. Variations in human corpus callosum do not predict gender: A study using magnetic resonance imaging. Behav. Neurosci. 102:1988;222-227.
23. Cameron J., Pierce W.D. Reinforcement, reward, and intrinsic motivation: a meta- analysis. Rev. Educ. Res. 64:1994;363-423.
24. Cassells B., Collins R.L., Wahlsten D. Path analysis of sex difference, forebrain commissure area and brain size in relation to degree of laterality in selectively bred mice. Brain Res. 529:1990;50-56.
25. Clarke S., Kraftsik R., Van der Loos H., Innocenti G.M. Forms and measures of adult and developing human corpus callosum: Is there sexual dimorphism? J. Comp. Neurol. 280:1989;213-230.
26. Clarke J.M., Zaidel E. Anatomical-behavioural relationships: corpus callosum morphometry and hemispheric specialization. Behav. Brain Res. 64:1994;185-202.
27. Cohen J. A power primer. Psychol. Bull. 112:1992;155-159.
28. Cowell P.E., Allen L.S., Kertesz A., Zalatimo N.S., Denenberg V.H. Human corpus callosum: a stable mathematical model of regional neuroanatomy. Brain Cogn. 25:1994;52-66.
29. Cowell P.E., Allen L.S., Zalatimo N.S., Denenberg V.H. A developmental study of sex and age interactions in the human corpus callosum. Dev. Brain Res. 66:1992;187-192.
30. Cowell P.E., Kertesz A., Denenberg V.H. Multiple dimensions of handedness and the human corpus callosum. Neurology. 43:1993;2353-2357.
31. de Lacoste M.C., Adesanya T., Woodward D.J. Measures of gender differences in the human brain and their relationship to brain weight. Biol. Psychiatry. 28:1990;931-942.
32. de Lacoste M.C., Holloway R.L., Woodward D.J. Sex differences in the fetal human corpus callosum. Human Neurobiol. 5:1986;93-96.
33. de Lacoste M.C., Kirkpatrick J.B., Ross E.D. Topography of the human corpus callosum. J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol. 44:1985;578-591.
34. de Lacoste-Utamsing C., Holloway R.L. Sexual dimorphism in the human corpus callosum. Science. 216:1982;1431-1432.
35. de Lacoste-Utamsing C., Holloway R.L., Kirkpatrick J.B., Ross E.D. Anatomical and quantitative aspects of the human corpus callosum. Soc. Neurosci. Abstr. 7:1981;382.
36. Demeter S., Ringo J.L., Doty R.W. Sexual dimorphism in the human corpus callosum? Soc. Neurosci. Abstr. 11:1985;868.
37. Demeter S., Ringo J., Doty R.W. Morphometric analysis of the human corpus callosum and anterior commissure. Human Neurobiol. 6:1988;219-226.
38. Denenberg V.H., Kertesz A., Cowell P.E. A factor analysis of the human's corpus callosum. Brain Res. 548:1991;126-132.
39. Desimone R. The physiology of memory: recordings of things past. Science. 258:1992;245-246.
40. Dinkel C.A., Wilson L.L., Tuma H.J., Minyard J.A. Ratios and percents as measures of carcass traits. J. Anim. Sci. 24:1965;425-429.
41. Donahue, P. The human animal. New York: Simon and Schuster; 1985.
42. Doraiswamy P.M., Figiel G.S., Husain M.M., McDonald W.M., Shah S.A., Boyko O.B., Ellinwood E.H., Krishnan K.R.R. Aging of the human corpus callosum: magnetic resonance imaging in normal volunteers. J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. Neurosci. 3:1991;392-397.
43. Driesen N.R., Raz N. Sex-, age-, and handedness-related differences in human corpus callosum observed in vivo. Psychobiology. 23:1995;240-247.
44. Elster A.D., DiPersio D.A., Moody D.M. Sexual dimorphism of the human corpus callosum studied by magnetic resonance imaging: fact, fallacy, and statistical confidence. Brain Dev. 12:1990;321-325.
45. Emory L.E., Williams D.H., Cole C.M., Amparo E.G., Meyer W.J. Anatomic variation of the corpus callosum in persons with gender dysphoria. Arch. Sex. Behav. 20:1991;409-417.
46. Fausto-Sterling, A. Myths of gender: biological theories about women and men (2nd edn). New York: Basic Books; 1992.
47. Feingold A. Cognitive gender differences are disappearing. Am. Psychol. 42:1988;95-103.
48. Ferrario V.F., Sforza C., Serrao G., Frattini T., del Favero C. Shape of the human corpus callosum: elliptic fourier analysis on midsagittal magnetic resonance scans. Invest. Radiol. 29:1994;677-681.
49. Fischer S.E. Selective fetal malnutrition: the fetal alcohol syndrome. J. Am. Coll. Nutr. 7:1988;101-106.
50. Going J.J., Dixson A. Morphometry of the adult human corpus callosum: lack of sexual dimorphism. J. Anat. 171:1990;163-167.
51. Goldberger A.S. The nonresolution of IQ inheritance by path analysis. Am. J. Human Genet. 30:1978;442-445.
52. Gorman, C., Sizing up the sexes. Time, 20 January, 36-43 1992.
53. Gould S.J. Allometry and size in ontogeny and phylogeny. Biol. Rev. 41:1966;587-640.
54. Gur R.C., Mozley L.H., Mozley P.D., Resnick S.M., Karp J.S., Alavi A., Arnold S.E., Gur R.E. Sex differences in regional cerebral glucose metabolism during a resting state. Science. 267:1995;528-531.
55. Habib M., Gayraud D., Oliva A., Regis J., Salamon G., Khalil R. Effects of handedness and sex on the morphology of the corpus callosum: A study with brain magnetic resonance imaging. Brain Cogn. 16:1991;41-61.
56. Hauser P., Dauphinais I.D., Berrettini W., DeLisi L.E., Gelernter J., Post R.M. Corpus callosum dimensions measured by magnetic resonance imaging in bipolar effective disorder and schizophrenia. Biol. Psychiatry. 26:1989;659-668.
57. Hayakawa K., Konishi Y., Matsuda T., Kuriyama M., Konishi K., Yamashita K., Okumura R., Hamanaka D. Development and aging of brain midline structures: assessment with MR imaging. Radiology. 172:1989;171-177.
58. Hedges L.V., Nowell A. Sex differences in mental test scores, variability, and numbers of high-scoring individuals. Science. 269:1995;41-45.
59. Hedges, L.V.; Olkin, I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis. Orlando; Academic Press; 1985.
60. Hines M., Chiu L., McAdams L.A., Bentler P.M., Lipcamon J. Cognition and the corpus callosum: verbal fluency, visuospatial ability, and language lateralization related to midsagittal surface areas of callosal subregions. Behav. Neurosci. 106:1992;3-14.
61. Ho K., Roessmann U., Straumfjord J.V., Monroe G. Analysis of brain weight. I. Adult brain weight in relation to sex, race, and age Arch. Pathol. Lab. Med. 104:1980;635-639.
62. Ho K., Roessmann U., Straumfjord J.V., Monroe G. Analysis of brain weight. II. Adult brain weight in relation to body height, weight, and surface area Arch. Pathol. Lab. Med. 104:1980;640-645.
63. Hoff A.L., Neal C., Kushner M., DeLisi L.E. Gender differences in corpus callosum size in first-episode schizophrenics. Biol. Psychiatry. 35:1994;913-919.
64. Hofman M.A., Swaab D.F. The sexually dimorphic nucleus of the preoptic area in the human brain: a comparative morphometric study. J. Anat. 164:1989;55-72.
65. Holloway, R.L. Sexual dimorphism in the human corpus callosum: its evolutionary and clinical implications. In: Sperber, G., ed. From apes to angels: essays in anthropology in honour of Phillip V. Tobias. New York: Wiley-Liss; 1990:221-228.
66. Holloway R.L., Anderson P.J., Defendini R., Harper C. Sexual dimorphism of the human corpus callosum from three independent samples: relative size of the corpus callosum. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 92:1993;481-498.
67. Holloway R.L., de Lacoste M.C. Sexual dimorphism in the human corpus callosum: An extension and replication study. Human Neurobiol. 5:1986;87-91.
68. Hunter, J.E.; Schmidt, F.L. Methods of meta-analysis. Newbury Park: Sage; 1990.
69. 2 and d. Am. Psychol. 36:1981;892-901.
70. Hyde J.S., Fennema E., Lamon S.L. Gender differences in mathematics performance: a meta-analysis. Psychol. Bull. 107:1990;139-155.
71. Innocenti G.M. Some new trends in the study of the corpus callosum. Behav. Brain Res. 64:1994;1-8.
72. Johnson S.C., Farnworth T., Pinkston J.B., Bigler E.D., Blatter D.D. Corpus callosum surface area across the human adult life span: effect of age and gender. Brain Res. Bull. 35:1994;373-377.
73. Juraska J.M., Kopcik J.R. Sex and environmental influences on the size and ultrastructure of the rat corpus callosum. Brain Res. 450:1988;1-8.
74. Kandel, E.R.; Schwartz, J.H.; Jessell, T.M. Principles of neural science (3rd edn). New York: Elsevier; 1991.
75. Kelly, D.D. Sexual differentiation of the nervous system. In: Kandel, E.R.; Schwartz, J.H., eds. Principles of neural science (2nd edn). New York: Elsevier; 1985:771-783.
76. Kertesz A., Polk M., Howell J., Black S.E. Cerebral dominance, sex, and callosal size in MRI. Neurology. 37:1987;1385-1388.
77. Kim J.H.Y., Ellman A., Juraska J.M. A re-examination of sex differences in axon density and number in the splenium of the rat corpus callosum. Brain Res. 740:1996;47-56.
78. Kimura D. Sex differences in the brain. Sci. Am. 267:1992;119-125.
79. Kolb, B.; Whishaw, I.Q. Fundamentals of human neuropsychology. New York: W.H. Freeman; 1990.
80. Kopcik J.R., Seymoure P., Schneider S.K., Kim-Hong J., Juraska J.M. Do callosal projection neurons reflect sex differences in axons number? Brain Res. Bull. 29:1992;493-497.
81. Lai M., Lewis P.D. Effects of undernutrition on myelination in rat corpus callosum. J. Comp. Neurol. 193:1980;973-982.
82. Laissey J.P., Patrux B., Duchateau C., Hannequin D., Hugonet P., Ait-Yahia H., Thiebot J. Midsagittal MR measurements of the corpus callosum in healthy subjects and diseased patients: a prospective survey. Am. J. Neuroradiol. 14:1993;145-154.
83. Lassonde, M.; Jeeves, M.A., eds. Callosal agenesis: a natural split brain? New York: Plenum Press; 1994.
84. LeVay, S. Replication will tell. New York Times 7 October; 1991.
85. Lomber S.G., Payne B.R., Rosenquist A.C. The spatial relationship between the cerebral cortex and fiber trajectory through the corpus callosum of the cat. Behav. Brain Res. 64:1994;25-35.
86. Mack C.M., Fitch R.H., Cowell P.E., Schrott L.M., Denenberg V.H. Ovarian estrogen acts to feminize the female rat's corpus callosum. Dev. Brain Res. 71:1993;115-119.
87. Mall F.P. On several anatomical characters of the human brain, said to vary according to race and sex, with special reference to the weight of the frontal lobe. Am. J. Anat. 9:1909;1-32.
88. Moir, A.; Jessell, D. Brainsex. London: Mandarin; 1991.
89. Morgane P.J., Austin-LaFrance R., Bronzino J., Tonkiss J., Díaz-Cintra S., Cintra L., Kemper T., Galler J.R. Prenatal malnutrition and development of the brain. Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev. 17:1993;91-128.
90. Morrison, D.F. Multivariate statistical methods (3rd edn). New York: McGraw-Hill; 1990.
91. Nasrallah H.A., Andreasen N.C., Coffman J.A., Olson S.C., Dunn V.D., Ehrhardt J.C., Chapman S.M. A controlled magnetic resonance imaging study of corpus callosum thickness in schizophrenia. Biol. Psychiatry. 21:1986;274-282.
92. Nasrallah H.A., Andreasen N.C., Olson S.C., Coffman J.A., Coffman C.E., Dunn V.D., Ehrhardt J.C. Absence of sexual dimorphism of the corpus callosum in schizophrenia: a magnetic resonance imaging study. Soc. Neurosci. Abstr. 11:1985;1308.
93. Okamoto K., Ito J., Tokiguchi S. The MR findings of the corpus callosum in normal young volunteers. Nippon Igaku Hoshasen Gakkai Zasshi. 50:1990;954-963.
94. O'Kusky J., Strauss E., Kosaka B., Wada J., Li D., Druhan M., Petrie J. The corpus callosum is larger with right-hemisphere cerebral speech dominance. Ann. Neurol. 24:1988;379-383.
95. Oliver M.B., Hyde J.S. Gender differences in sexuality: a meta-analysis. Psychol. Bull. 114:1993;29-51.
96. Oppenheim J.S., Lee B.C.P., Nass R., Gazzaniga M.S. No sex-related differences in human corpus callosum based on magnetic resonance imagery. Ann. Neurol. 21:1987;604-606.
97. Packard G.C., Boardman T.J. The misuse of ratios, indices, and percentages in ecophysiological research. Physiol. Zool. 61:1988;1-9.
98. Pandya, D.N.; Seltzer, B. The topography of commissural fibers. In: Leporé, F.; Ptito, M.; Jasper, H.H., eds. Two hemispheres - one brain. Functions of the corpus callosum. New York: Liss; 1986:47-73.
99. Peters M. The size of the corpus callosum in males and females: Implications of a lack of allometry. Can. J. Psychol. 42:1988;313-324.
100. Peters M. Sex differences in human brain size and the general meaning of differences in brain size. Can. J. Psychol. 45:1991;507-522.
101. Pozzilli C., Bastianello S., Bozzao A., Pierallini A., Giubilei F., Argentino C., Bozzao L. No differences in corpus callosum size by sex and aging: a quantitative study using magnetic resonance imaging. J. Neuroimaging. 4:1994;218-221.
102. Prokop V.A., Oehmichen M., Zilles K. Geschlechtsdimorphismus des corpus callosum? Beitr. Gerichtl. Med. 48:1989;263-270.
103. Pujol J., Vendrell P., Junqué C., Martí-Vilalta J.L., Capdevila A. When does human brain development end? Evidence of corpus callosum growth up to adulthood. Ann. Neurol. 34:1993;71-75.
104. Raine A., Harrison G.N., Reynolds G.P., Sheard C., Cooper J.E., Medley I. Structural and functional characteristics of the corpus callosum in schizophrenics, psychiatric controls, and normal controls. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry. 47:1990;1060-1064.
105. Rauch R.A., Jinkins J.R. Analysis of cross-sectional area measurements of the corpus callosum adjusted for brain size in male and female subjects from childhood to adulthood. Behav. Brain Res. 64:1994;65-78.
106. Reinarz S.J., Coffman C.E., Smoker W.R.K., Godersky J.C. MR imaging of the corpus callosum: Normal and pathologic findings and correlation with CT. Am. J. Roentgenol. 151:1988;791-798.
107. Reist J.D. An empirical evaluation of several univariate methods that adjust for size variation in morphometric data. Can. J. Zool. 63:1985;1429-1439.
108. Schmidt F.L. What do data really mean? Am. Psychol. 47:1992;1173-1181.
109. Schmidt-Nielsen, K. Scaling. Why is animal size so important? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1984.
110. Seyfried T.N., Yu R.K. Heterosis for brain myelin content in mice. Biochem. Genet. 18:1980;1229-1238.
111. Simon J.H., Schiffer R.B., Rudick R.A., Herndon R.M. Quantitative determination of MS-induced corpus callosum atrophy in vivo using MR imaging. Am. J. Neuroradiol. 8:1987;599-604.
112. Smith R.J. Allometric scaling in comparative biology: problems of concept and method. Am. J. Physiol. 246:1984;R152-R160.
113. Sperry R.W. Some effects of disconnecting the cerebral hemispheres. Science. 217:1982;1223-1226.
114. Squire L.R. Memory and the hippocampus. Psychol. Rev. 99:1992;195-231.
115. Steinmetz H., Jäncke L., Kleinschmidt A., Schlaug G., Volkmann J., Huang Y. Sex but no hand difference in the isthmus of the corpus callosum. Neurology. 42:1992;749-752.
116. Swaab D.F., Hofman M.A. Sexual differentiation of the human hypothalamus in relation to gender and sexual orientation. Trends Neurosci. 18:1995;264-270.
117. Takeda S., Yamada S., Ono S., Matsuzawa T. Age-related changes in the size of the corpus callosum - magnetic resonance imaging. Nippon Ronen Igakkai Zasshi (Jpn. J. Geriat.). 25:1988;292-295.
118. Voyer D., Voyer S., Bryden M.P. Magnitude of sex differences in spatial abilities: a meta-analysis and consideration of critical variables. Psychol. Bull. 117:1995;250-270.
119. Wahlsten D. Sample size to detect a planned contrast and a one degree-of-freedom interaction effect. Psychol. Bull. 110:1991;587-595.
120. Wahlsten D., Bishop K.M. Sex differences in the human corpus callosum: myth or reality? Can. Soc. Brain Behav. Cog. Sci. Abstr. 4:1994;61.
121. Weber G., Weis S. Morphometric analysis of the human corpus callosum fails to reveal sex-related differences. J. Hirnforsch. 27:1986;237-240.
122. Weis S., Weber G., Wenger E., Kimbacher M. The human corpus callosum and the controversy about a sexual dimorphism. Psychobiology. 16:1988;411-415.
123. Weis S., Weber G., Wenger E., Kimbacher M. The controversy about a sexual dimorphism of the human corpus callosum. Int. J. Neurosci. 47:1989;169-173.
124. Witelson S.F. The corpus callosum is larger in left-handers. Soc. Neurosci. Abstr. 9:1983;917.
125. Witelson S.F. The brain connection: the corpus callosum is larger in left-handers. Science. 229:1985;665-668.
126. Witelson S.F. Hand and sex differences in the isthmus and genu of the human corpus callosum. Brain. 112:1989;799-835.
127. Witelson S.F. Sex differences in neuroanatomical changes with aging. N. Engl. J. Med. 325:1991;211-212.
128. Witelson S.F. Cognitive neuroanatomy: A new era. Neurology. 42:1992;709-713.
129. Woodruff P.W.R., McManus I.C., David A.S. Meta-analysis of corpus callosum size in schizophrenia. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psych. 58:1995;457-461.
130. Woodruff P.W.R., Pearlson G.D., Geer M.J., Barta P.E., Chilcoat H.D. A computerized magnetic resonance imaging study of corpus callosum morphology in schizophrenia. Psychol. Med. 23:1993;45-56.
131. Wu J.C., Buchsbaum M.S., Johnson J.C., Hershey T.G., Wagner E.A., Teng C., Lottenberg S. Magnetic resonance and positron emission tomography imaging of the corpus callosum: size, shape and metabolic rate in unipolar depression. J. Affect. Dis. 28:1993;15-25.
132. Yoshii F., Barker W., Apicella A., Chang J., Sheldon J., Duara R. Measurements of the corpus callosum (CC) on magnetic resonance (MR) scans: effects of age, sex, handedness, and disease. Neurology. 36((suppl.1)):1986;133.