The analysis of development control decisions: A position statement and some new insights from recent research in south-west England

Town Planning Review

Volumn 67, Issue 2, 1996, Pages 203-228

  Gilg, Andrew ^a   Kelly, Mike ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   (United Kingdom)

^b North Devon District Council   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

DATA COLLECTION; DEVELOPMENT CONTROL; METHODOLOGICAL EVALUATION; PLANNING PRACTICE; RESEARCH REVIEW;

UK, ENGLAND, (SOUTHWEST);

EID: 0030478422     PISSN: 00410020     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3828/tpr.67.2.m302683w61gk1025     Document Type: Review

References (63)

1. ANDERSON, M. (1981), 'Planning policies and development control in the Sussex Downs AONB', Town Planning Review, 52, 5-25.
2. ANFIELD, J. and CURRY, N. (1989), 'Development control in National Parks 40 years on', The Planner, 75, 18-20.
3. AUDIT COMMISSION (1992), Building in Quality: A Study of Development Control, London, HMSO.
4. BARLOW, J. (1986), 'Landowners, property ownership and the rural locality', International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 10, 309-29.
5. BARRETT, S. M. and FUDGE, C. (1981), Policy and Action: Essays on the Implementation of Public Policy, London, Methuen.
6. BARRETT, S. M. and HILL, M. (1984), 'Policy, bargaining and structure in implementation theory: towards an integrated perspective', Policy and Politics, 12, 219-40.
7. BIBBY, P. and SHEPHERD, J. (1993), Housing Land Availability: the Analysis of PS3 Statistics on Land with Outstanding Planning Permission, London, Department of the Environment.
8. BIERCE, A. (1963), 'A lacking factor' in G. Barkin (ed.), The Sardonic Humour of Ambrose Bierce, Selected from the Works of Ambrose Bierce Published 1909-1912, New York, Dover.
9. BIRD, J. (1989), The Changing Worlds of Geography: A Critical Guide to Concepts and Methods, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
10. BLACKSELL, M. and GILG, A. (1981), The Countryside: Planning and Change, London, George Allen & Unwin.
11. BRACKEN, I. (1981), Urban Planning Methods: Research and Policy Analysis, London and New York, Methuen.
12. BROTHERTON, I. (1982), 'Development pressures and control in the National Parks', Town Planning Review, 53, 439-59.
13. BROTHERTON, I. (1984), 'A response to McNamara and Healey', Town Planning Review, 55, 97-101.
14. BROTHERTON, I. (1992a), 'Towards a theory of planning control', Sheffield, Department of Landscape Architecture, University of Sheffield.
15. BROTHERTON, I. (1992b), 'On the quantity and quality of planning applications', Environment and Planning B, 19, 337-57.
16. BROTHERTON, I. (1992c), 'On the control of development by planning authorities, Environment and Planning B, 19, 465-78.
17. BROTHERTON, I. (1993), 'The interpretation of refusal and appeal rates', The Planner, 78, 24-25.
18. BULLER, H. and HOGGART, K. (1986), 'Non-decision making and community power: residential development control in rural areas', Progress in Planning, 25, 135-203.
19. BUNNELL, G. (1995), 'Planning gain in theory and practice - negotiation of agreements in Cambridgeshire', Progress in Planning, 44, 1-113.
20. CLOKE, P. J. (1987), Rural Planning: Policy into Action?, London, Harper and Row.
21. COUNTRYSIDE COMMISSION (1990), Development pressures in National Parks: 1983-1988, Cheltenham, The Countryside Commission.
22. CPRE (1994), Public Access to Planning Documents, London, The Council for the Protection of Rural England.
23. CURRY, N. (1992), 'Controlling development in the national parks of England and Wales', Town Planning Review, 63, 107-21.
24. CURRY, N. and MCNAB, A. (1986), 'Development control and landscape protection', Countryside Planning Yearbook, 7, 89-110.
25. DAVIES, H. W. E., EDWARDS, D. and ROWLEY, A. R. (1986), 'The relationship between development plans, development control and appeals', The Planner, October, 11-15.
26. DIAMOND, D. (1992), Evaluating the Effectiveness of Land Use Planning: a Study for the Department of the Environment, London, HMSO.
27. DOE (1978), Land Availability: a Study of Land with Residential Planning Permission, London, Department of the Environment.
28. EYLES, J. and SMITH, D. M. (eds) (1988), Qualitative Methods in Human Geography, London, Polity Press.
29. FLEMING, S. C. and SHORT, J. R. (1984), 'Committee rules OK? An examination of planning committee action on officer recommendation', Environment and Planning A, 16, 965-73.
30. GILG, A. W. and KELLY, M. P. (forthcoming), 'Farmers, planners and councillors: an insider's view of their interaction' in N. Curry (ed.), New Directions for Rural Land Use, Cheltenham, Countryside and Community Foundation.
31. GREGORY, D. (1971), 'Green belts and development control: a case study of the West Midlands', Birmingham, Centre for Urban and Regional Studies, University of Birmingham.
32. HARVEY, D. (1969), Explanation in Geography, London, Edward Arnold.
33. HEALEY, P., MCNAMARA, P., ELSON, M. and DOAK, A. (1988), Land Use Planning and the Mediation of Urban Change, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
34. HEALEY, P. (1991), 'Researching planning practice', Town Planning Review, 62, 447-59.
35. HOME, R., (1987), 'Measuring trends in town planning control through decision statistics', Local Government Studies, 13, 51-62.
36. HOOPER, A., PINCH, P. and ROGERS, S. (1988), 'Housing land availability: circular advice, circular arguments and circular methods', Journal of Planning and Environment Law, April, 225-39.
37. JURUE (1977), 'Planning and land availability', Birmingham, Joint Unit for Research on the Urban Environment, University of Aston.
38. KELLY, M. P. (1993), 'The implementation of planning policy: decision making in practice - an examination of agricultural workers' dwellings in North Devon' (unpublished PhD thesis) Exeter, University of Exeter.
39. KELLY, M. P. and GILG, A. W. (forthcoming), 'The implementation of planning policies in practice: a study of agricultural dwellings by an academic and a planning practitioner', Progress in Planning.
40. KEYES, J. (1986), 'Controlling residential development in the Green Belt: a case study', The Planner, 72, 18-20.
41. LARKHAM, P. J. (1990a), 'Development control information and planning research', Local Government Studies, 16, 1-7.
42. LARKHAM, P. J. (1990b), 'The use and measurement of development pressure', Town Planning Review, 61, 171-83.
43. LAURIA, M. (1982), 'Selective urban redevelopment: a political economy perspective', Urban Geography, 3, 224-39.
44. LEWIS, J. and FLYNN, R. (1979), 'The implementation of urban and regional planning policies', Policy and Politics, 7, 123-42.
45. MCAUSLAN, P. (1980), The Ideologies of Planning Law, Oxford, Pergamon Press.
46. MCDONALD, G. T. (1989), 'Rural land use planning decisions by bargaining', Journal of Rural Studies, 5, 325-35.
47. MCGREW, A. G. and WILSON, M. J. (eds) (1987), Decision Making. Approaches and Analysis, Manchester, Manchester University Press.
48. MCNAMARA, P. F. and HEALEY, P. (1984), 'The limitations of development control data in planning research', Town Planning Review, 55, 91-97.
49. MILROY, B. M. (1991), 'Into post-modern weightlessness', Journal of Planning Educational Research, 10, 181-88.
50. MURDOCH, J. and MARSDEN, T. (1994), Reconstituting Rurality, London, UCL Press.
51. PACIONE, M. (1990), 'Private profit and public interest in the residential development process: a case study of conflict in the urban fringe', Journal of Rural Studies, 6, 103-16.
52. PACIONE, M. (1991), 'Development pressure and the production of the built environment in the urban fringe', Scottish Geographical Magazine, 107, 162-69.
53. PEARCE, B. (1992), The effectiveness of the British land use planning system', Town Planning Review, 63, 13-28.
54. PICKERING, M. (1987), 'Development control topics', The Planner, 73, 94-98.
55. POPPER, K. R. (1963), Conjectures and Refutations, London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
56. POUNTNEY, M. T. and KINGSBURY, P. W. (1983), 'Aspects of development control: Part 1: the relationship with local plans', Town Planning Review, 54, 139-54.
57. PREECE, R. (1990), 'Development control studies: scientific method and policy analysis', Town Planning Review, 61, 59-73.
58. RYDIN, Y. (1985), 'Residential development and the planning system: a study of the housing land system at the local level', Progress in Planning, 24, 1-69.
59. SELLGREN, J. (1990), 'Development control data for planning research: the use of aggregated development control records', Environment and Planning B, 17, 23-37.
60. SHORT, J. R., FLEMING, S. and WITT, S. (1986), Housebuilding, Planning and Community Action, London, Routledge & Kegan Paul.
61. SHORT, J. R., WITT, S. and FLEMING, S. (1987), 'Conflict and compromise in the built environment: housebuilding in central Berkshire', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers: New Series, 12, 29-42.
62. TEWDWR-JONES, M. (1995), 'Development control and the legitimacy of planning decisions', Town Planning Review, 66, 163-81.
63. WARF, B. (1990), 'Can the region survive post-modernism?', Urban Geography, 11, 586-93.