Administrative fairness and forest land decision-making: Restructuring land use governance in British Columbia, Canada

Environmental Politics

Volumn 5, Issue 4, 1996, Pages 654-686

  Mason, Michael R ^a  

^a LONDON METROPOLITAN UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ADMINISTRATIVE FAIRNESS; DECISION MAKING; FOREST MANAGEMENT; LAND USE PLANNING;

CANADA, BRITISH COLUMBIA;

EID: 0030421104     PISSN: 09644016     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/09644019608414297     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. Anahim Round Table (1994), Anahim Round Table Resource Management Plan, Anahim Lake, British Columbia: Anahim Round Table.
2. Andrews, William J. (1993), Comments on the Schwindt Report, Vancouver: West Coast Environmental Law Association.
3. Bankes, Nigel (1993), 'Ethics and resource takings: the Schwindt Report', Resources, No.41, pp.1-7.
4. Baumann, R.J. (1994), 'Exotic Expropriations: Government Action and Compensation', The Advocate, Vol.52, No.4, pp.561-79.
5. Beehler, Rodger (1983), 'The Concept of Fairness', in Case et al. [1993: 1-14].
6. Benhabib, Seyla (1994), 'Deliberative Rationality and Models of Democratic Legitimacy', Constellations, Vol.1, No.1, pp.26-52.
7. Bohman, James F. (1990), 'Communication, Ideology, and Democratic Theory', American Political Science Review, Vol.84, No.1, pp.93-109.
8. Brenneis, Kim (1991), 'An Evaluation of Public Participation in the British Columbia Ministry of Forests', Forest Resources Commission Background Papers, Vol.1, Victoria: British Columbia Forest Resources Commission.
9. Brunet, Robin (1994), 'Their Jobs, Their Homes, Their Lives', British Columbia Report, Vol.5, No.27, pp.18-23.
10. Buckle, Leonard G. and Suzanne, R. Thomas-Buckle (1986), 'Placing Environmental Mediation in Context: Lessons from "Failed" Mediations', Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Vol.6, No.1, pp.55-70.
11. Cabinet Planning Secretariat (1993), 'Proposed Forest Sector Strategy Action Plan', Forest Planning Canada, Vol.9, No.3, pp.12-16.
12. Case, Evangeline S. et al. (eds.) (1983), Fairness in Environmental and Social Impact Processes, Calgary: Faculty of Law, University of Calgary.
13. Chambers, Simone (1996), Reasonable Democracy, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
14. Cobb, William (1994), Mayor, Williams Lake; Personal communication, Vancouver, 24 Aug.
15. Commission of Inquiry into Compensation for the Taking of Resource Interests (1992), Final Report, Victoria: Queen's Printer.
16. Commission on Resources and Environment (CORE) (1993a), Tatshenshini/Alsek Land Use, Victoria: CORE.
17. Commission on Resources and Environment (1993b), 1992/93 Annual Report, Victoria: CORE.
18. Commission on Resources and Environment (1993c), Aboriginal Participation in Regional Planning Processes, Victoria: CORE.
19. Commission on Resources and Environment (1994a), Vancouver Island Land Use Plan, Victoria: CORE.
20. Commission on Resources and Environment (1994b), Cariboo-Chilcotin Land Use Plan, Victoria: CORE.
21. Commission on Resources and Environment (1994c), 1993/94 Annual Report, Victoria: CORE.
22. Commission on Resources and Environment (1994d), Provincial Land Use Strategy, Volume 1: A Sustainability Act for British Columbia, Victoria: CORE.
23. Commission on Resources and Environment (1994e), Provincial Land Use Strategy, Volume 2: Planning for Sustainability, Victoria: CORE.
24. Commission on Resources and Environment (1995a), Provincial Land Use Strategy, Volume 3: Public Participation, Victoria: CORE.
25. Commission on Resources and Environment (1995b), Provincial Land Use Strategy, Volume 4: Dispute Resolution, Victoria: CORE.
26. Commission on Resources and Environment (1995c), British Columbia 's Sustainability Strategy, Report to the Legislative Assembly, 1994-95, Victoria: CORE.
27. Cormick, Gerald (1989), 'Strategic Issues in Structuring Multi-party Public Policy Negotiations', Negotiation Journal, Vol.5, No.2, pp.125-32.
28. Dorcey, Anthony H.J. and Christine L. Riek (1987). Negotiated Settlement of Environmental Disputes: An Analysis of Canadian Experience. A report prepared for the Canadian Environmental Assessment Research Council.
29. Dryzek, John S. (1990), Discursive Democracy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
30. Dryzek, John S. (1995), 'Political and Ecological Communication', Environmental Politics, Vol.4, No.4, pp.13-30.
31. Environment and Land Use Committee (1976), Report of the Secretariat, Victoria: Queen's Printer.
32. Finkle, Peter (1983), 'New Approaches to Fairness: The Bureaucracy Responds', in Case et al, [1983: 29-38].
33. Forest Resources Commission (1991), The Future of Our Forests, Victoria: British Columbia Forest Resources Commission.
34. George, Paul (1994), Founder/Director, Western Canada Wilderness Committee; Personal interview, Vancouver, 16 Sept.
35. Gilfillan, Brian (1994), Vice-President (Forestry), Council of Forest Industries; Personal interview, Vancouver, 14 Sept.
36. Greater Ecosystem Alliance (1994), The Big Picture: Protecting Biodiversity in B.C., Nelson, British Columbia: The Greater Ecosystem Alliance.
37. Gunton, Thomas (1993), 'Crown-land Planning in British Columbia: Managing for Multiple Use', in M.A. Fenger et al. (eds.), Our Living Legacy: Proceedings of a Symposium on Biological Diversity, Victoria: Royal British Columbia Museum, pp.275-93.
38. Habermas, Jurgen (1987), The Theory of Communicative Action. Volume 2: A Critique of Functionalist Reason, Cambridge: Polity.
39. Haddock, Mark (1995), Forests on the Line, Vancouver: Sierra Legal Defence Fund.
40. Hatch, Ron B. (ed.) (1994), Clayoquot and Dissent, Vancouver: Ronsdale Press.
41. Hirst, Paul (1994), Associative Democracy, Cambridge: Polity.
42. Hoberg, G. (1993), 'Regulating Forestry: A Comparison of Institutions and Policies in British Columbia and the US Pacific Northwest', Forest Economics and Policy Analysis Research Unit Working Paper No.185, Vancouver: FEPA Research Unit, University of British Columbia.
43. Howlett, Michael and Keith Brownsey (1988), 'The Old Reality and the New Reality: Party Politics and Public Policy in British Columbia 1941-1987', Studies in Political Economy, Vol.25, No.1. pp.141-76.
44. Ingram, Attracta (1994), A Political Theory of Rights, Oxford: Clarendon.
45. Integrated Resource Planning Committee (1993), Land and Resource Management: A Statement of Principles and Processes, Victoria: Province of British Columbia.
46. Law Reform Commission of Canada (1985), Report on Independent Administrative Agencies: A Framework for Decision-Making, Ottawa: Law Reform Commission of Canada.
47. Lewis, Kaaren (1994), Senior Policy Analyst, Land Use Coordination Office; Personal interview. Victoria, 19 Sept. 1994.
48. Lidstone, Allan (1994), Land Use Planning Supervisor, Ministry of Forests; Personal interview, Victoria, 20 Sept. 1994.
49. Low Intensity Area Review Committee (1995), Low Intensity Areas for the Vancouver Island Region: Exploring a New Resource Management Vision, Victoria, LIARC.
50. Lucas, Alistair R. (1987), 'Natural Resources and Environmental Management: A Jurisdictional Primer', in Donna Tingley (ed.), Environmental Protection and the Canadian Constitution, Edmonton, Alberta: Environmental Law Centre, pp.31-43.
51. Macdonald, R.A. (1980a), 'Judicial Review and Procedural Fairness in Administrative Law: I', McGill Law Journal, Vol.25, No.4, pp.520-64.
52. Macdonald, R.A. (1980b), 'Judicial Review and Procedural Fairness in Administrative Law: II', McGill Law Journal, Vol.26, No.1, pp.1-44.
53. MacIsaac, Ron and Anne Champagne (eds.) (1994), Clayoquot Mass Trials: Defending the Rainforest, Gabriola Island, British Columbia: New Society Publishers.
54. McDade, Gregory J. (1993), Report on Compensation Issues Concerning Protected Areas, Vancouver: Sierra Legal Defence Fund.
55. McDaniels, Timothy L. (1992), 'Structuring Alternatives for Forest Land Management Planning', in Marvin Shaffer and Associates, pp.1-10.
56. Magee, Scan (1994), Communications Manager, Forest Alliance of British Columbia; Personal interview, Vancouver, 14 Sept.
57. Maher, G. (1986), 'Natural Justice as Fairness', in P. Burks and N. MacCormick (eds.), The Legal Mind, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
58. Manin, Bernard (1987), 'On Legitimacy and Political Deliberation', Political Theory, Vol.15, No.3, pp.338-68.
59. Marchak, Patricia (1986), 'The Rise and Fall of the Peripheral State: The Case of British Columbia', in Robert J. Bryn (ed.), Regionalism in Canada, Richmond, Ontario: Irwin, pp.123-59.
60. Marvin Shaffer and Associates (1992), Evaluation Methodology and Data Sources for Social and Economic Impact Assessment of Forest Land Management Options: Background Reports, Victoria: Forestry Canada/British Columbia Ministry of Forests.
61. M'Gonigle, Michael and Ben Parfitt (1994), Forestopia: A Practical Guide to the New Forest Economy, Madeira Park, British Columbia: Harbour Publishing.
62. Ministry of Crown Lands (1989), British Columbia Land Statistics, Victoria: British Columbia Ministry of Crown Lands.
63. Ministry of Forests (1990), Integrated Resource Management on Provincial Forest Lands: Ministry Policy, Victoria: British Columbia Ministry of Forests.
64. Ministry of Forests (1994), Annual Report 1992/93, Victoria: British Columbia Ministry of Forests.
65. Nixon, Bob (1990), 'Principles of Integrated Management Lack Legislative Authority in British Columbia, When Compared with US Forest Law', Forest Planning Canada, Vol.6, No.6, pp.9-14.
66. Ombudsman of British Columbia (1989), Victoria: Province of British Columbia. 1988 Annual Report to the Legislative Assembly, Victoria: Province of British Columbia.
67. Owen, Stephen (1993), 'Participation and Sustainability: the Imperatives of Resource and Environmental Management', in Steven A. Kennet (ed.), Law and Process in Environmental Management, Calgary: Institute of Resources Law, pp.335-66.
68. Owen, Stephen (1994), Commissioner on Resources and Environment; Personal interview, Victoria, 19 Sept.
69. Ozawa, C.P. (1993), 'Improving Citizen Participation in Environmental Decision-Making: The Use of Transformative Mediator Techniques', Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, Vol.11, No.1, pp.103-17.
70. Paehlke, Robert and Douglas Torgerson (eds.) (1990), Managing Leviathan: Environmental Politics and the Administrative State, London: Belhaven Press.
71. Palmer, Vaughn (1995), 'Forest Policy Expected to Make Communities Suffer', Vancouver Sun, 26 January, A18.
72. Price Waterhouse (1995), Analysis of Recent British Columbia Government Forest Policy and Land Use Initiatives, Vancouver: Forest Alliance of British Columbia.
73. Province of British Columbia (1993a), A Protected Aretis Strategy for British Columbia, Victoria: Queen's Printer.
74. Province of British Columbia (1993b), Social and Economic Impact Assessment for Land and Resource Management Planning in British Columbia, Victoria: Queen's Printer.
75. Rayner, Jeremy (1996), 'Implementing Sustainability in West Coast Forests: CORE and FEMAT as Experiments in Process', Journal of Canadian Studies, Vol.31, No.1, pp.82-101.
76. Reardon, Carol (1993), 'Is the CORE Process Fair?', West Coast Environmental Association Newsletter, Vol.17, No.5, p.5.
77. Round Table on the Environment and the Economy (1991), Reaching Agreement. Volume 1: Consensus Processes in British Columbia, Victoria: British Columbia Round Table on the Environment and the Economy.
78. Round Table on the Environment and the Economy (1994), Public Involvement in Government Decision-Making: Choosing the Right Model, Victoria: British Columbia Round Table on the Environment and the Economy.
79. Round Tables on the Environment and the Economy in Canada (1993), Building Consensus for a Sustainable Future, Ottawa: National Round Table on the Environment and the Economy.
80. Royal Commission on Forest Resources (1976), Timber Rights and Forest Policy in British Columbia. Report of the Royal Commission on Forest Resources, Volumes 1 and 2, Victoria: Royal Commission on Forest Resources.
81. Sherrod, Anne (1993a), 'CORE Processes: The Little Known Threat to Existing Parks', unpublished manuscript, New Denver, British Columbia: The Valhalla Society.
82. Sherrod, Anne (1993b), 'Flaws in the CORE Process (as Experienced by the Wilderness Conservation Sector of the Slocan Valley Pilot Project)', unpublished manuscript, New Denver, British Columbia: The Valhalla Society.
83. Sumanik, Ken (1994), Environment and Land Use Director, Mining Association of British Columbia; Personal interview, Vancouver, 16 Sept.
84. Susskind, L. and J. Cruikshank (1987), Breaking the Impasse: Consensus Approaches to Resolving Public Disputes, New York: Basic Books.
85. Tennant, Paul (1990), Aboriginal Peoples and Politics, Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press.
86. Vanagas, Steve (1994), 'Culture of Conflict', British Columbia Report, Vol.5, No.49, pp.18-22.
87. Vance, Joan (1990), Tree Planning: A Guide to Public Involvement in Forest Stewardship, Vancouver: Public Interest Advocacy Centre.
88. Vanderzwagg, David and Linda Duncan (1992), 'Canada and Environmental Protection: Confident Political Faces, Uncertain Legal Hands', in Robert Boardman (ed.), Canadian Environmental Policy: Ecosystems, Politics and Process, Toronto: Oxford University Press, pp.3-23.
89. Wade, William and Christopher, (1994), Administrative Law, Seventh Edition, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
90. Western Canada Wilderness Committee (1993/94), 'A Conservation Vision for Vancouver Island', WCWC Educational Report, Vol.12, No.7.
91. Wilderness Advisory Committee (1986), The Wilderness Mosaic, Victoria: British Columbia: Wilderness Advisory Committee.
92. Williams, Douglas R. (1994), 'Environmental Law and Democratic Legitimacy', Duke Environmental Law and Policy Forum, Vol.4, No.1, pp.1-40.
93. World Commission on Environment and Development (1987), Our Common Future, Oxford: Oxford University Press.