Risk assessment of EMF on health

IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Magazine

Volumn 15, Issue 4, 1996, Pages 77-86

  Wilson, Richard ^a,b,c  

^a HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

DOSE RESPONSE RELATIONSHIPS; HAZARD IDENTIFICATION;

CARCINOGENS; ELECTRICITY; ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELD EFFECTS; EPIDEMIOLOGY; HEALTH CARE; HEALTH HAZARDS; HEALTH RISKS; MAGNETIC FIELDS; ONCOLOGY; PARAMETER ESTIMATION; RADIOLOGY; RISK ASSESSMENT;

ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS;

CANCER; ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELD; HEALTH HAZARD; HUMAN; RADIATION CARCINOGENESIS; RADIATION HAZARD; REVIEW; RISK ASSESSMENT;

EID: 0030200281     PISSN: 07395175     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1109/51.511986     Document Type: Review

References (83)

1. Thurber JT: Thurber carnival. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster; p. 185; 1982.
2. T. Tenforde in "Handbook of Biological Effects of Electromagnetic Fields" Polk and Postow, Eds., Chemical Rubber Publishing Co (CRC) 1991
3. WF Pickard: (1988) "A model for the Acute Electrosensitivity of Cartaliginous Fishes" IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 35(4): pp243-249
4. Hill AB: (1965): "The environment and diseases: association and causation," Proc. Royal Soc Med., sec. Occup. Med. 58:295-300.
5. P Pott: 1775 "Chirurgical Observations" Hawkes, Clarke and Collins, London. See also HJ. Butler 1892 "Three Lectures on Cancer of the Scotum in Chimney Sweeps and Others" British Medical Journal 11341, 2 pp 1-6, 66-71.
6. P Pott: 1775 "Chirurgical Observations" Hawkes, Clarke and Collins, London. See also HJ. Butler 1892 "Three Lectures on Cancer of the Scotum in Chimney Sweeps and Others" British Medical Journal 11341, 2 pp 1-6, 66-71.
7. Wertheimer N and E Leeper: (1979) "Electric Wiring Configurations and childhood cancer" Am. Journ. Epidemiol. 109-273.
8. Washburn EP, MJ Orza, JA Berlin, WJ Nicholson, AC Todd, H Frumkin, and TC Chalmers: (1994) "Residential Proximity to electricity Transmission and distribution equipment and risk of childhood leukemia, childhood lymphoma, and childhood nervous system tumors: systematic review, evaluation, and meta analysis." Cancer Causes and Control, v 5, pp 299-309.
9. Most of the articles in Spring issue of "Risk Analysis" 1995.
10. JA Ross, SM Davies, JD Porter and LL Robinson: (Year) "Epidemiology of childhood leukemias, with a focus on infants." Epidemiologie Reviews 16(2): pp. 243-272.
11. There are numerous reviews on this subject. We refer in particular to the biannual reports of United Nations Subcommittee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR).
12. AB Hill: loc. cit.
13. Feychting M and A Ahlbom: (1992) "Magnetic fields and cancer in persons living close to high voltage power lines in Sweden" Lakartidningen. Dec 9; 89(50): 4371-4 also Amer J. Epidemiology v138, pp 467-481, (1993) see also, Feychting M. and Ahlbom, A. "Magnetic Fields, Leukemia, and Central Nervous System Tumors in Swedish Adults Residing near High-Voltage Power Lines" Epidemiology 5(5) pp 501-509.
14. Feychting M and A Ahlbom: (1992) "Magnetic fields and cancer in persons living close to high voltage power lines in Sweden" Lakartidningen. Dec 9; 89(50): 4371-4 also Amer J. Epidemiology v138, pp 467-481, (1993) see also, Feychting M. and Ahlbom, A. "Magnetic Fields, Leukemia, and Central Nervous System Tumors in Swedish Adults Residing near High-Voltage Power Lines" Epidemiology 5(5) pp 501-509.
15. Feychting M and A Ahlbom: (1992) "Magnetic fields and cancer in persons living close to high voltage power lines in Sweden" Lakartidningen. Dec 9; 89(50): 4371-4 also Amer J. Epidemiology v138, pp 467-481, (1993) see also, Feychting M. and Ahlbom, A. "Magnetic Fields, Leukemia, and Central Nervous System Tumors in Swedish Adults Residing near High-Voltage Power Lines" Epidemiology 5(5) pp 501-509.
16. Floderus B, Persson T, Stenlund C, Wennberg A, Öst, Å; Knave B: (1993) "Occupational exposure to electromagnetic fields in relation to leukemia and brain tumors: a case-control study in Sweden." Cancer Causes and Control 4: 465.
17. Thériault G, Goldberg M, Miller AB, Armstrong B, Guénel P, Deadman J, Imbernon E, To T, Chevalier A, Cyr D, Wall C: (1994) "Cancer risks associated with occupational exposure to magnetic fields among electric utility workers in Ontario and Quebec, Canada, and France: 1970-1989." Amer. J. Epidemiol. 139: 550.
18. DA Savitz and D Loomis: "Leukemia and Brain Cancer in Electrical Workers" Amer. J. Epidemiology v 141, pp123-134 (1995).
19. YS Loh, R Wilson and AS Shlyakhter: (1995) "A summary and review of the epidemiological data on electromagnetic Fields" 2nd Michelson Conference, Kalispell, August 1995; submitted to Bioelectromagnetics January 1996
20. YS Loh, R Wilson and AS Shlyakhter: (1995) "A summary and review of the epidemiological data on electromagnetic Fields" 2nd Michelson Conference, Kalispell, August 1995; submitted to Bioelectromagnetics January 1996
21. AB Hill: loc. cit.
22. Exact agreement about the proportions is not necessary here, because they may be modified by synergistic factors, and by the different age or gender distributions of the populations.
23. AB Hill: loc. cit.
24. There is a possible exception of vinyl chloride which produces fewer angiosarcomas in Sprague Dawley rats at high doses than at a somewhat lower dose. This seems to be saturation of a metabolic pathway and may not occur in people.
25. RK Adair: "Biological Responses to weak 60 Hz Fields must Vary as the Square of the Field Strength." Proc Nat Acad. Sci. 91: pp 9422-9425 (1994)
26. WR Bennett: "Cancer and Power Lines" Physics Today v 47, pp 23-29 (1994). See also ORAU report pp II-16 - II-20
27. WR Bennett: "Cancer and Power Lines" Physics Today v 47, pp 23-29 (1994). See also ORAU report pp II-16 - II-20
28. Tynes T. et al: (1994), "Leukemia and Brain Tumors in Norwegian Railway Workers, A Nested Case Control Study," Amer. J. Epidemiology, v137:pp645-653
29. Vena JE, Graham S, Hellman R, Swanson M, and Brasure J: "Use of Electric Blankets and Risk of Post Menopausal Breast Cancer" Amer. J. Epidemiology v 134, pp 180-185 (1991)
30. Verrault R, Weiss NS, Hollenbach KA, Starder CH, and Daling JR: "Use of Electric Blankets and risk of Testicular Cancer" Amer. J. Epidemiology v 131, pp759-762, (1990).
31. Cavaignac JF, E Jeenicke, B Vignon, and R Wilson: (1975) "Sensitivity of Organic Scintillators to Magnetic Fields" Nuclear Instruments and Methods v. 126, p 459.
32. AB Hill: loc. cit.
33. Valberg PA: (1994) "Biology and EMF: Biophysical Mecanisms of Interaction," Report to Electric Power Reaserarch Institute, Palo Alto, CA
34. Adair RK: (1992) "Constraints on the Biological Effects of Weak Extremely Low Frequency Electromagnetic Fields" Phys. Rev A 43: pp 1039-1048
35. TS Tenforde: (1993) in Ann Revs Publ. Hlth. 13: pp 173-196
36. Men began to smoke before women did, and the lung cancer incidence increased among men before it increased among women.
37. Arsenic is only carcinogenic in animals at very high doses. The failure to find carcinogenicity in animals delayed for many years the recognition of arsenic as an important carcinogen.
38. A good summary set of articles on this subject can be found in: B Wilson, R. Steven, L Anderson, Ed., (1990) "Extremely Low Frequency Electromagnetic Fields: The question of Cancer" The Batelle Press Columbus, Ohio
39. Bawin SM, and Adey WR: (1976) "Sensitivity of Calcium Binding in cerebral tissue to weak environmental electric fields oscillating at low frequencies" Proc. Natl. Acad. Sciences.v73, pp 999-2003.
40. AB Hill: loc. cit.
41. Block SM: (1992) "Biophysical Principles of Sensory Transduction" Society of General Physiologists Series 47, 1-17.
42. Bialek W: (1987) "Physical Limits to Sensation and Perception" Ann. Rev. Biophys. Chem. 16, 455-478.
43. American Physical Society News, (1995) "Power Line Fields and Public Health," v4 (7) p 2,
44. D Hafemeister: "Background Paper on 'Power Line Fields and Public Health'",report to the Panel on Public Affairs of the American Physical Society, http://www.calpoly.edu/~dhafemei.
45. A Franklin: (1995), "The Appearance and disappearance of the 17 kev neutrino," Reviews of Modern Physics. 67: pp 457-490.
46. M Withey: (1993) "Proving Causation in EMF-based Claims: it's the Method, Not the Madness!" Shepard's Expert and Scientific Evidence Quarterly 181: pp 188-192
47. The present NAS committee is expected to release its report in 1996 at the same time as this book goes to press.
48. "Health Effects of Low Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields," Oak Ridge Associated Universities. ORAU 92/F9.
49. "Electromagnetic Fields and the Risk of Cancer," Report of an Advisory Group on Non-ionizing Radiation, National Radiological Protection Board, No. 3 (1992).
50. There have been several WHO reports, including "Extremely Low Frequency (ELF) Fields" (1984) and "Magnetic Fields" (1987)
51. There have been several WHO reports, including "Extremely Low Frequency (ELF) Fields" (1984) and "Magnetic Fields" (1987)
52. "The Potential Carcinogenicity of Electromagnetic Fields" Draft Report (not for quotation) of the United States Environmental Protection Agency (1990). This draft report should only be read in conjunction with the critical report of the review committee, EPA SAB-RAC-92-013 (1992). The Science Advisory Board stated, inter alia, "some of the epidemiological evidence is suggestive of an association between surrogate measures of magnetic field exposure and certain outcomes...[lack of sufficient data] prevents the inference of cancer causality from these associations at this time."
53. HG Peach, WJ Bonwick, R Scanlan and T Wyse: "Report of the Panel on Electromagnetic Fields and Health to the Victoria Government" (1992).
54. P Guenel and J Lellouch: "Synthesis of the Literature on Health Effects from Very Low Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields," National Institute of Health and Medical Research (INSERM) (France)(1993).
55. JC Roucayrol: "Sur les champs electromagnetiques de tres basse frequence et la sante [Extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields and health]," 177 Bull. Acad. Nat Med. 1031 (1993).
56. Interagency Task Force Studying Electric and Magnetic Fields, "Connecticut 1994 Report on Task Force Activities to Evaluate Health Effects from Electric and Magnetic Fields" (1994).
57. "Biological Effects of 60-Hz Transmission Lines," A Report of the Florida Electric and Magnetic Fields Science Advisory Commission to the State of Florida Department of Environmental Regulation (1985).
58. PA Buffler, PE Burgess, GL Smith, RA Beauchamp, HA Higgins, SH Linder, ME McLain, PL Zweiacker: "Health Effects of Exposure to Powerline-Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields," Public Utility Commission of Texas (1993).
59. "Possible Health Effects of Extremely Low Frequency Electric and Magnetic Field Exposure: A Review," Report to the Illinois State Legislature by the Illinois Department of Public Health in coordination with the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (1992).
60. "Status Report on Potential Human Health Effects Associated With Power Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields," prepared for the Maryland Department of Natural Resources and the Public Service Commission of Maryland, Document PPSE-T-39 (1994).
61. Colorado Universities Consortium on Electromagnetic Fields 1992 "Investigation in Power Line Frequency EMF and Its Risks to Health: A Review of the Scientific Literature" March
62. Committee of the Health Council of the Netherlands, "Extremely Low-Frequency Electromagnetic Fields and Health" Report of April 1992
63. Expert Group on Non-ionizing Radiation, Denmark 1993 "Rapport on risiko for kraeft has born med boosel eksoowerat for 50 Hz manerfeiter fra hoispaendugsaenaeet" Report to the Danish Ministry of Health, May 1993
64. Report to Minister of Energy by Department of Energy, Ireland, July 1992. "Electromagnetic Fields: a review of Recent Developments in Research and Public Attitudes and the Response of Authorities to these Developments"
65. "Risk in Perspective," (Summer 1995), Harvard Center for Risk Analysis.
66. Savitz and Poole: loc. cit.
67. Feychting and Ahlbrom: loc. cit.
68. M. Granger Morgan: Risk Analysis 1994.
69. DA Savitz and D Loomis: loc. cit.
70. Floderus, et al.: loc. cit.
71. Recent studies also suggest an increase of breast cancer.
72. "Cancer Statistics 1995" CA-A Cancer Journal for Clinicians v 45 number 1 page 8.
73. JD Jackson: (1992) "Are the stray 60 Hz electromagnetic fields associated with the distribution and uses of electrical power a significant cause of cancer?" Proc. Natl.Acad.Sci. v 89, pp 3508-3510.
74. Lave L, Seskin E: Health and Air Pollution. Swed. J. Econ. 73: 76-95; 1971.
75. Wilson R, Colome SD, Spengler JD, Wilson D.G: Health effects of fossil fuel burning: assessment and mitigation. Boston, MA: Ballinger Publishing Co.; 1981.
76. Evans J, Ozkaynak H, Wilson R: The use of models in public health risk analysis. J. Energy Env. 1: 1-20; 1982.
77. Crawford M, Evans J, Wilson R: (1996) Low dose linearity: the rule or the exception? Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, in press.
78. Morgan MG: Prudent avoidance, more study of EMF's. Issues Sci. Tech. 6: 18; 1990.
79. D Hafemeister: "The Imprudence of Prudent Avoidance" (1995) Physics and Society 24: p9
80. E Gerjuoy: (1994), "Electromagnetic Fields; Physics, Biology and the Law." Jurimetric Journal 35: p 75 see also E. Guerjoy "Prudent Avoidance: Is it Prudent?" Presentation at symposium of the Atlantic Legal Foundation. Philadelphia, October 1995
81. E Gerjuoy: (1994), "Electromagnetic Fields; Physics, Biology and the Law." Jurimetric Journal 35: p 75 see also E. Guerjoy "Prudent Avoidance: Is it Prudent?" Presentation at symposium of the Atlantic Legal Foundation. Philadelphia, October 1995
82. K Duncan: (1994) In Microwave News March-April, page 5
83. Morgan MG: "Fields from electric power: What are they? What do we know about possible health risks? What can be done? Brochure for Public Information, Carnegie Mellon University, PA (1995).