The ambiguous relationship between practice variation and appropriateness of care: An agenda for further research

Health Policy

Volumn 35, Issue 3, 1996, Pages 247-265

  Casparie, Anton F ^a  

^a ERASMUS UNIVERSITY ROTTERDAM   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Appropriateness of care; Practice variation; Quality of care; Small area variation

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION; HUMAN; MEDICAL PRACTICE;

EID: 0030041744     PISSN: 01688510     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/0168-8510(95)00787-3     Document Type: Article

References (49)

1. Lewis, C.E., Variations in the incidence of surgery, New England Journal of Medicine, 281 (1969) 880-885.
2. Welch, W.P., Miller, M.E., Welch, H., Fischer, E.S. and Wennberg, J.E., Geographic variation in expenditures for physicians' services in the United States, New England Journal of Medicine, 328 (1993) 621-627.
3. Welch, H.G., Miller, M.E. and Welch, W.P., Physician profiling. An analysis of inpatients practice patterns in Florida and Oregon, New England Journal of Medicine, 330 (1994) 607-612.
4. Fischer, E.S., Wennberg, J.E., Stukel, T.A. and Sharp, S.M., Hospital readmission rates for cohorts of medical beneficiaries in Boston and New Haven, New England Journal of Medicine, 331 (1994) 989-995.
5. Poses, R.M., Wigton, R.S., Cebul, R.D., Centor, R.M., Collins, M. and Fleischli, G.J., Practice variation in the management of pharyngitis: the importance of variability in patients' clinical characteristics and in physicians' responses to them, Medical Decision Making, 13 (1993) 293-301.
6. Report: Verschillen tussen gezondheidsregio's in gebruik van ziekenhuisvoorzieningen (Differences Between Health Regions in the Use of Hospital Facilities), KNMG, Utrecht, 1989.
7. Casparie, A.F., Post, D., van Harten, W.H. and Gubbels, J.W., Differences in production between medical specialists. An inventory based on claim data to identify potential areas for quality-improvement activities, European Journal of Public Health, 3 (1993) 292-295.
8. Casparie, A.F., Geschiere, R., Post, D. and van Harten, W.H., Verschillen in zorgverlening tussen 11 KNO-maatschappen in 2 ziekenfondsregio's (Differences in provision of health care between 11 ENT-partnerships in two intake areas of obligatory medical insurance organizations), Nederlands Tijdschrift voor Geneeskunde, 135 (1990) 754-758.
9. Diehr, P., Small area statistics: large statistical problems, American Journal of Public Health, 74 (1984) 313-314.
10. Diehr, P., Cain, K., Connell, F. and Volinn, E., What is too much variation? The null hypothesis in small-area analysis, Health Services Research, 24 (1990) 742-771.
11. Diehr, P., Cain, K.C., Kreuter, W. and Rosenkranz, S., Can small-area analysis detect variation in surgery rates? The power of small-area variation analysis, Medical Care, 30 (1992) 484-502.
12. Cain, K.C. and Diehr, P., Testing the null hypothesis in small area analysis, Health Services Research, 27 (1993) 267-294.
13. Shwartz, M., Ash, A.S., Anderson, J., Iezzoni, L.I., Payne, S.M.C. and Restuccia, J.D., Small area variations in hospitalization rates: how much you see depends on how you look, Medical Care, 32 (1994) 189-201.
14. Wolfe, R.A., Griffith, J.R., McMahon, L.F., Tedechi, P.J., Petroni, G.R. and McLaughlin, C.G., Patterns of surgical and nonsurgical hospital use in Michigan communities from 1980 through 1984, Health Services Research, 24 (1989) 67-82.
15. McMahon, L.F., McLaughlin, C.G., Petroni, G.R. and Tedeschi, P.J., Small area analysis of hospital discharges for musculoskeletal diseases in Michigan: the influence of socioeconomic factors, The American Journal of Medicine, 91 (1991) 173-178.
16. Escarce, J.J., Would eliminating differences in physician practice style reduce geographic variations in cataract surgery rates? Medical Care, 31 (1993) 1106-1118.
17. Green, L.A. and Becker, M.P., Physician decision making and variation in hospital admission rates for suspected acute myocardial ischemia. A tale of two towns, Medical Care, 32 (1994) 1086-1097.
18. Bensing, J.M., van den Brink-Muinen, A. and de Bakker, D.H., Gender differences in practice style: a Dutch study of general practitioners, Medical Care, 31 (1993) 219-220.
19. Bertakis, K.D., Helms, L.D., Callahan, E.J., Azati, R. and Robbins, J.A., The influence of gender on physician practice style, Medical Care, 33 (1995) 407-416.
20. Grilli, R., Scorpiglioni, N., Nicolucci, A., Mainini, F., Penna, A., Mari, E., Belfiglio, M. and Liberati, A., Variation in use of breast surgery and characteristics of hospitals' surgical staff, International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 6 (1994) 233-238.
21. Greenfield, S., Nelson, E.C., Zubkoff, M., Manning, W., Rogers, W., Kravitz, R.L., Keller, A., Tarlov, A.R. and Ware, J.E., Variations in resource utilization among medical specialties and systems of care. Results from the Medical Outcome Study, Journal of the American Medical Association, 267 (1992) 1624-1630.
22. Hayward, R.A., Manning, W.G., McMahon, L.F. and Bernard, A.M., Do attending or resident physician practice style account for variations in hospital resource use? Medical Care, 32 (1994) 788-794.
23. Javitt, J.C., Kendix, M., Tielsch, J.M., Steinwachs, D.M., Schein, O.D., Kobb, M.M. and Steinberg, E.P., Geographic variation in utilization of cataract surgery, Medical Care, 33 (1995) 90-105.
24. Chen, E. and Naylor, C.D., Variation in hospital length of stay for acute myocardial infarction in Ontario, Canada, Medical Care, 32 (1994) 420-435.
25. Chassin, M.R., Kosecoff, J., Park, R.E., Winslow, C.M., Kahn, K.L., Merrick, N.J., Keesey, J., Fink, A., Solomon, D.H. and Brook, R.H., Does inappropriate use explain geographic variations in the use of health care services. A study of three procedures, Journal of the American Association, 258 (1987) 2533-2537.
26. Winslow, C.M., Kosecoff, J.B., Chassin, M., Kanouse, D.E. and Brook R.H., The appropriateness of performing coronary artery bypass surgery, Journal of the American Medical Association, 260 (1988) 505-509.
27. Bernstein, S.J., McGlynn, E.A., Sin, A.L., Roth, C.P., Sherwood, M.J., Keesey, J.W., Kosecoff, J., Hicks, N.R. and Brook R.H., The appropriateness of hysterectomy. A comparison of care in seven health plans, Journal of the American Medical Association, 269 (1993) 2398-2402.
28. Bernstein, S.J., Hilborne, L.H., Leape, L.L., Fiske, M.E., Park, R.E., Kamberg, C.J. and Brook, R.H., The appropriateness of use of coronary angiography in New York State, Journal of the American Medical Association, 269 (1993) 766-769.
29. Hilborne, L.H., Leape, L.L., Bernstein, S.J., Park, R.E., Fiske, M.E., Kamberg, C.J., Roth, C.P. and Brook, R.H., The appropriateness of use of percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty in New York State, Journal of the American Medical Association, 269 (1993) 761-765.
30. Leape, L.L., Hilborne, L.H., Park, R.E., Bernstein, S.J., Kamberg, C.J., Sherwood, M. and Brook, R.H., The appropriateness of use of coronary artery bypass graft surgery in New York State, Journal of the American Medical Association, 269 (1993) 753-760.
31. Brook, R.H., Kosecoff, J.B., Park, R.E., Chassin, M.R., Winslow, C.M. and Hampton, J.R., Diagnosis and treatment of coronary disease: comparison of doctors' attitudes in the USA and the UK, Lancet, 1 (1988) 750-753.
32. McGlynn, E.A., Naylor, C.D., Anderson, G.M., Leape, L.L., Park, R.E., Hilborne, L.H., Bernstein, S.J., Goldman, B.S., Armstrong, P.W., Keesey, J.W., McDonald, L., Pinfold, S.P., Damberg, C., Sherwood, M.J. and Brook, R.H., Comparison of the appropriateness of coronary angiography and coronary artery bypass graft surgery between Canada and New York State, Journal of the American Medical Association, 272 (1994) 934-940.
33. Bengtson, A., Herlitz, J., Karlsson, T., Brandrup, G. and Hjalmarson, A., The appropriateness of performing coronary angiography and coronary artery revascularization in a Swedish population, Journal of the American Medical Association, 271 (1994) 1260-1265.
34. Bernstein, S.J., Letter to the Editor: The appropriateness of coronary procedures in Sweden, Journal of the American Medical Association, 272 (1994) 1254-1255.
35. Goldman, R.L., The reliability of peer assessments of quality of care, Journal of the American Medical Association, 267 (1992) 958-960.
36. Hayward, R.A., McMahon, L.F. and Bernard, A.M., Evaluating the care of general medicine inpatients: how good is implicit review? Annals of Internal Medicine, 118 (1993) 550-556.
37. Caplan, R.A., Posner, K.L. and Cheney, F.W., Effect of outcome on physician judgments of appropriateness of care, Journal of the American Medical Association, 265 (1991) 1957-1960.
38. Scott, E.A. and Black, N., Appropriateness of cholecystectomy in the United Kingdom - a consensus panel approach, Gut, 32 (1991) 1066-1070.
39. Fraser, G.M., Pilpel, D., Kosecoff, J. and Brook, R.H., Effect of panel composition on appropriateness ratings, International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 6 (1994) 251-255.
40. Phelps, C.E., The methodologic foundations of studies of the appropriateness of medical care, New England Journal of Medicine, 329 (1993) 1241-1245.
41. Hicks, N.R., Some observations on attempts to measure appropriateness of care, British Medical Journal, 309 (1994) 730-733.
42. Brook, R.H. and Apple, F.H., Quality-of-care assessment: choosing a method for peer review, New England Journal of Medicine, 288 (1973) 1323-1329.
43. Nobrega, F.T., Morrow, G.W., Smoldt, R.K. and Offord, K.P., Quality assessment in hypertension: analysis of process and outcome methods, New England Journal of Medicine, 296 (1977) 145-148.
44. Gray, D., Hampton, J.R., Bernstein, S.J., Kosecoff, J. and Brook, R.H., Audit of coronary angiography and bypass surgery, Lancet, 335 (1990) 1317-1320.
45. Knottnerus, J.A., Joosten, J. and Daams, J., Comparing the quality of referrals of general practitioners with high and average referral rates: an independent panel review, British Journal of General Practice, 40 (1990) 178-181.
46. Fertig, A., Roland, M., King, H. and Moore, T., Understanding variations in rates of referral among general practitioners: are inappropriate referrals important and would guidelines help to reduce rates? British Medical Journal, 307 (1993) 1467-1470.
47. Starfield, B., Powe, N.R., Weiner, J.R., Stuart, M., Steinwachs, D., Scholle, S.H. and Gerstenberger, A., Costs vs. quality in different types of primary care settings, Journal of the American Medical Association, 272 (1994) 1903-1908.
48. Leape, L.L., Park, R.E., Solomon, D.H., Chassin, M.R., Kosecoff, J. and Brook, R.H., Does inappropriate use explain small area variation in the use of health care services?, Journal of the American Medical Association, 263 (1990) 669-672.
49. Davidson, G., Does inappropriate use explain small-area variations in the use of health care services? A critique, Health Services Research, 28 (1993) 389-400.