Women's Work in Agriculture: Divergent Trends in England and America, 1800 to 1930

Comparative Studies in Society and History

Volumn 34, Issue 2, 1992, Pages 248-270

  McMurry, Sally ^a  

^a PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

AGRICULTURAL WORKERS; CHEESEMAKING INDUSTRY; COMPARATIVE STUDIES; HISTORICAL STUDIES; LABOUR DIVISION; NINETEENTH CENTURY; SOCIAL TRANSFORMATION; WOMEN'S WORK;

NORTH AMERICA; UK, ENGLAND;

EID: 0027036162     PISSN: 00104175     EISSN: 14752999     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1017/S0010417500017680     Document Type: Article

References (204)

1. Ivy Pinchbeck, Women Workers and the Industrial Revolution (1930; reprint, London: Virago Books, 1981), 7–42;
2. Alice Clark, Working Life of Women in Seventeenth Century (London: George Routledge, 1919);
3. Mary Bouquet, Family, Servants, and Visitors: The Farm Household in 19th and 20th Century Devon (Norwich: Geo Books, 1985);
4. Bridget Hill, Women, Work, and Sexual Politics in 18th Century England (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1989), 24, 46;
5. Judith Bennett, Women in the Medieval English Countryside (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987), 5–17;
6. Barbara Hanawalt, ed., Women and Work in Preindustrial Europe (Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press, 1986);
7. Joan Thirsk, ed., Agrarian History, 1640–1750, 406, 486–9, 501;
8. W. Thwaites, “Women in the Market Place: Oxfordshire, c. 1690–1800,” Midland History, 9 (1984), 23–43;
9. Davidoff, “The Role of Gender,” 205.
10. Olwen Hufton's review essay in Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 14 (August 1988), 223–8.
11. Maxine Berg, “Women's Work, Mechanization, and the Early Phases of Industrialization in England,” in Patrick Joyce, ed., The Historical Meanings of Work (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 64–97;
12. Janet Thomas, “Women and Capitalism: Oppression or Emancipation?,” Comparative Studies in Society and History, 30:3 (1988), 534–548;
13. Lindsey Charles and Lorna Duffin, eds., Women and Work in Pre–Industrial England (Croom Helm, 1985).
14. Joan Thirsk, ed., Regional Farming Systems, Vol. 1 of The Agrarian History of England and Wales, 1640–1750 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984), chs. 4
15. Eric Kerridge, The Agricultural Revolution (B. Batsford, 1967), 86, 123–128;
16. P. R. Edwards, “The Development of Dairying on the North Shropshire Plain in the 17th Century,” Midland History, 4 (Autumn 1978), 175–191;
17. J. D. Chambers and G. Mingay, The Agricultural Revolution (B. Batsford, 1966), 35–39, 110;
18. G. Mingay, ed., The Agrarian History of England and Wales, 1750–1850, vol. 6 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989), ch. 2;
19. Joseph Harding, “Recent Improvements in Dairy Practice,” Journal of the Royal Agricultural Society of England (JRASE), 21 (1860), 82–92;
20. “Cheese–Making,” Farmer's Magazine (Edinburgh) (FM) (1862), 522–524;
21. “Cheese—Its Manufacture and Quality,” FM (1859), 322–323;
22. J. R. Bond, “Derbyshire Farming—Past and Present,” JRASE, 93 (1932), 169;
23. David Taylor, “The Development of English Dairy Farming, c. 1860–1930” (D. Phil. thesis, Oxford University, 1971);
24. David Taylor, “Growth and Structural Change in the English Dairy Industry, 1860–1930,” Agricultural History Review, 35 (1987), 47–65;
25. G. E. Fussell, The English Dairy Farmer, 1500–1900 (Frank Cass and Co., 1966);
26. William Palin, “On the Farming of Cheshire,” JRASE, 5 (1845), 87–88;
27. Leonore Davidoff, “The Role of Gender in the ‘First Industrial Nation’: Agriculture in 1780–1850,” in Rosemary Crompton and Michael Mann, eds., Gender and Stratification (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1986), 190–214;
28. K. D. M. Snell, “Agricultural Seasonal Unemployment, the Standard of Living and Women's Work in the South and East, 1690–1860,” Economic History Review, 34 (1981), 421–423;
29. Ann Kussmaul, Servants in Husbandry in Early Modern England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981).
30. C. S. Orwin and E. H. Whetham, History of British Agriculture 1846–1914 (Longman, Green, and Co., 1964), 144;
31. Frederick Law Olmsted, Walks and Talks of an American Farmer in England (1859 ; reprint, Ann Arbor, Michigan, n.d.), 128;
32. Taylor, “ English Dairy Farming,” 190–198 ;
33. Elihu Burritt, A Walk from London to Land's End and Back (Sampson Low, Son and Marston, 1865), 171–175;
34. The Dairy (Charles Knight, 1843), 47;
35. Thomas Acland and William Sturge, The Farming of Somersetshire (John Murray, 1851), 52;
36. William Livesay, “On Cheese–Making,” FM (1842), 40–41;
37. J. H. Burton, “The Letting of Dairies—A West Country Custom,” Journal of the British Dairy Farmers Association (JBDFA), 26 (1912), 28–35 ;
38. George Cooke, Topographical and Statistical Description of the County of Somerset (Sherwood, Neely, and Jones, 1820), 35;
39. Thomas Rudge, General View of the Agriculture of the County of Gloucester (Richard Phillips, 1807), 328–329;
40. Joan Thirsk, ed., Agrarian Change, vol. 2 of The Agrarian History of England and Wales, 1640–1750 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985), ch. 17.
41. William Marshall, The Rural Economy of Gloucestershire (G. Nichol, 1796), 1, 272;
42. Acland and Sturge, Somersetshire, 133;
43. Rudge, Gloucester, 328–329;
44. William Howitt, The Rural Life of England (Longman, Orme, Brown, Green, and Longman, 1838), 152;
45. Cuthbert W. Johnson, The Modern Dairy and Cowkeeper (J. Ridgway, 1850), 8;
46. G. E. Andrews, Modern Husbandry (Nathaniel Cooke, 1853), 389–390;
47. Parliamentary Commission on the Employment of Children, Young Persons, and Women in Agriculture, First Report, 1867–68 (P.P. 1867–68, 17), 10, 41, 115, 122, 123;
48. “British and American Agriculture,” Genesee Farmer, June 1853 (Rochester, New York), 178–179;
49. Thomas Wedge, General View of the Agriculture of the County Palatine of Chester (C. Macrae, 1794), 60;
50. Susan Amussen, An Ordered Society (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1988), 68–69.
51. Marshall, Gloucestershire, 2, 156–159;
52. Parliamentary Commission on the Employment of Women and Children in Agriculture, Report, 1843 (P.P. 12), 5, 60
53. Parliamentary Commission on the Employment of Children, Young Persons, and Women, 1867, Second Report (1868–69, P.P. XIII), 4, 136, 250, 491–2, 494;
54. James Caird, English Agriculture in 1850 and 1851 (Longman, Brown, Green, and Longmans, 1852), 252;
55. Howitt, Rural Life, 1, 151–152;
56. William Marshall, The Rural Economy of the West of England (G. Nichols, 1796), 1, 107;
57. William Youatt, The Complete Grazier (Cradock and Co., 1846), 144;
58. Acland and Sturge, Somersetshire, 52;
59. W. Carrington, “On Dairy–Farming,” JRASE, 2nd ser., 1 (1865), 363;
60. George Beesley, A Report on the State of Agriculture in Lancashire (Preston: Dobson and Son, 1849), 28.
61. “Cheese–Making,” Genesee Farmer, August 1854 (Rochester, New York), 277–80.
62. Wedge, Chester, 57;
63. Parliamentary Report,1843, 5, 67 ;
64. Marshall, Gloucestershire, 1, 265;
65. Acland and Sturge Somersetshire, 53.
66. Chris Howell, Memories of Cheddar (Chilcompton, Chris Howell, 1984), 89.
67. Cooke, Somerset, 35;
68. Burton, “Letting of Dairies,” 35;
69. Hayward, quoted in the Genesee Farmer, August 1854 (Rochester, New York), 277–280;
70. Rudge, Gloucester, 285;
71. Agnes Scott, Dairy Management, 2nd ed. (Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons, 1861), 5–15;
72. Howitt, Rural Life, 133;
73. Marshall, Gloucestershire, 2, 96, 105;
74. Farmer's Herald (Chester) (FH), 1 (October 1854), 75;
75. FH, 1 (December 1854), 90–91.
76. Josiah Twamley, Dairying Exemplified (Warwick: J. Sharp, 1784), 9–11, 16–17.
77. Marshall, Gloucestershire, 2, 184–185;
78. Youatt, The Complete Grazier, 137;
79. Olmstead, Walks and Talks, 127;
80. Henry White, “A Detailed Account of the Making of Cheshire Cheese,” JRASE, 6 (1845–6), 107, 111.
81. “Cheese–Making,” FM (1862), 523;
82. Rudge, Gloucester, 297;
83. Wedge, Chester, 51–57;
84. John Bravendar, “Farming of Gloucestershire,” JRASE, 11 (1860), 153.
85. “Cheese–Making,” FM (1862), 524.
86. Marshall, Gloucestershire, 2, 185;
87. J. Burke, Farming for Ladies (John Murray, 1844), 408;
88. Matthew Milbum, The Cow: Dairy Husbandry and Cattle Breeding (William S. Orr, 1851), 77–79;
89. “Cheshire Farming—its Present Aspect and Future Prospects,” FH, 11 (May 1864), 36–37.
90. Davidoff, “Role of Gender,” 204;
91. Val Cheke, The Story of Cheesemaking in Britain (Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1959), 1–8.
92. W. B. Mercer, “Two Centuries of Cheshire Cheese Farming,” JRASE, 98 (1937), 75;
93. Howitt, Rural Life, 248–9.
94. Mercer, “Two Centuries,” 85;
95. David Underdown, “The Taming of the Scold,” in Anthony Fletcher and John Stevenson, eds., Order and Disorder in Early Modern England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985), 116–137;
96. Acland and Sturge, Somersetshire, 52;
97. Caird, English Agriculture, 252; “Devon and Cornwall Conference,” JDBFA, 13 (1898), 71.
98. Susan Amussen, in An Ordered Society, argues that yeomen in pastoral villages more often appointed their wives sole executors of their wills than did farmers in arable areas (p. 84).
99. Utica [New York] Weekly Herald, August 26, 1873;
100. Black River Herald, May 21, 1863, (Boonville, New York);
101. Moses Eames, “Plan for a Cheese House,” Transactions of the New York State Agricultural Society, 11 (1851), 264.
102. Census of Great Britain (1861); Sally McMurry, “Culture and Agriculture in Central New York: The Industrialization of Cheesemaking, 1826–85” (manuscript in progress).
103. M. B. Bateham, column in the Ohio Cultivator, 4 (1848), 111–2.
104. Ralph Andreano, ed., The Economic Impact of the American Civil War, 2nd ed. (Cambridge, MA: Shenkman, 1967), 14–15 ;
105. David Gilchrist and W. David Lewis, eds., Economic Change in the Civil War Era (Greenville, Delaware: Eleutherian Mills–Hagley Foundation, 1964), 62–68;
106. Taylor, “English Dairy Farming,” 100.
107. Eric Brunger, “Changes in the New York State Dairying Industry, 1850–1900” (Ph.D. thesis, Syracuse University, 1954), 90;
108. Eric Lampard, The Rise of the Dairy Industry in Wisconsin (Madison: State Historical Society of Wisconsin, 1963).
109. Transactions, New York State Agricultural Society, 24 (1864), 242;
110. American Agriculturist, 27 (February 1868), 58;
111. Reports of the New York State Cheese Manufacturers Association (1864), 227.
112. Willard Cochrane, The Development of American Agriculture: A Historical Analysis (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1979), 240–57.
113. “Is Cheese or Butter Most Profitable?,” American Agriculturist, 37 (July 1878), 258;
114. T. R. Pirtle, History of the Dairy Industry (Chicago: Mojonnier, 1926), 139–140;
115. Moore's Rural New Yorker, 15 (October 1, 1864), 318
116. Taylor, “English Dairy Farming.”
117. P. A. Graham, The Revival of English Agriculture (Jarrold and Sons, 1899), 98;
118. H. Rider Haggard, Rural England (New York: Longman, Green, and Co., 1902), 2, 252, 254, 335.
119. Taylor, “English Dairy Farming,” Orwin and Whetham, History of British Agriculture;
120. P. J. Perry, British Farming in the Great Depression 1870–1914 (Newton Abbott: David and Charles, 1974);
121. Bond, “Derbyshire,” 165–189;
122. E. F. G. Walker, “Dairy Farming: Fifty Years Ago and Now,” Journal of Bath and West of England Society, 5th ser., 2 (1907–08), 86–101;
123. George Gibbons, “Report on Cheesemaking in Derbyshire,” JRASE, 2nd ser., 17 (1881), 503–42.
124. Marjorie Cohen, “The Decline of Women in Canadian Dairying,” Histoire Sociale—Social History, 17 (November 1984), 307–334;
125. Jefferies's remarks are found in Hodge and His Masters (Smith, Elder and Co., 1880), 183, 203–18, 227–33.
126. Section 7 (Food, Drink and Tobacco, published 1931), 106;
127. James Caird, “General View of British Agriculture,” JRASE, 14 (1878), 279–294;
128. William Goodwin, “Agricultural Production,” JBDFA, 31 (1917), 49–58
129. R. Mullock, “The Cheshire Cheese Industry,” JBDFA, 24 (1910), 63–69;
130. T. A. Holbom, “Lancashire Cheese–Making,” JBDFA, 24 (1910), 21–23;
131. Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries, Agricultural Output of England and Wales for 1925 (Parliamentary Accounts and Papers, 1927, 25), 61–68;
132. Census of Production for 1907, Section 7 (Food, Drink, and Tobacco), 462–509;
133. Census of Production for 1924, 103–117;
134. Census of Production for 1930, Part 3 (published 1934), 109–125
135. Census of Production for 1935, Part 3 (published 1940), 114–131;
136. Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries, Committee on Distribution and Prices of Agricultural Produce, Interim Report on Milk and Milk Products (1923, Cmd. 1854), 65–71.
137. Taylor, “English Dairy Farming,” 151, 156.
138. H. M. Jenkins, “On the American System of Associated Dairies,” Milk Journal, 1 (January 1871), 13, 15–16;
139. “Landlords and the Cheese Factory System,” Milk Journal, 1 (March 1, 1871), 43;
140. “The Cheese Factory Question in Cheshire,” Milk Journal, 1 (April 1, 1871), 82;
141. Report on the Derby Cheese Factory, Milk Journal, 1 (August 1, 1871), 184.
142. J. P. Sheldon, Dairy Farming (Cassell, Petten, Galpin, and Co., n.d., circa 1880), 267–270;
143. H. M. Jenkins, quoted in JRASE, 2nd ser., 14 (1878), 680;
144. “Cheshire Dairy Conference,” JBDFA, 2 (1886), 75, 111.
145. James Long, The Dairy Farm (W. H. Allen, 1889), 34, 68;
146. James Sadler, “Small Holdings and Dairy Farming,” JBDFA, 25 (1911), 7–12;
147. A. D. Hall, A. Pilgrimage of British Farming 1910–1912 (John Murray, 1913), 24;
148. Haggard, Rural England, 2, 249–250
149. “Report on the System of Cheesemaking Practised on the Four Dairy Farms,” JRASE, 2nd ser., 14 (1878), 37–42;
150. J. C. Morton, “Dairy Farm Prize Competition,” JRASE, 2nd ser., 22 (1886), 127–151;
151. “Farm Prize Competition of 1890,” JRASE, 3rd ser., 1 (1890), 776–821;
152. T. J. Young, “Agriculture in the County of Chester,” JRASE, 85 (1924), 175;
153. Jelfrey Adams, transcribed interview with Mary Gryspeerdt, no. 122
154. H. M. Jenkins, “Report on the Cheese Factory System,” JRASE, 2nd ser., 6 (1870), 201–2.
155. Robert McAdam, Crewe, to the Chester Chronicle, dated December 5, 1867
156. Joseph Harding, “The Factory System of Cheesemaking,” FH, 15 (April 1868), 25–26;
157. B. Angkarloo, “Agriculture and Women's Work: Directions of Change in the West, 1700–1900,” Journal of Family History 5 (Summer 1979), 111–120;
158. Michael Anderson, Family Structure in 19th Century Lancashire (Cambridge University Press, 1971), 79–86.
159. J. C. Morton, “On Cheese–Making in Home Dairies and in Factories,” JRASE, 2nd ser., 11 (1875), 264, 266, 269;
160. Aubrey White, transcribed interview with Mary Gryspeerdt, no. 139, Somerset Rural Life Museum;
161. James Sadler, “Dairy Farming in Cheshire, 1883–1908,” B and W, 5th ser., 3 (1908–09), 182.
162. P. A. Graham, Revival, 98.
163. Sheldon, quoted in Morton, “On Cheese–Making,” 285;
164. F. M. L. Thompson, “Agriculture Since 1870,” in Elizabeth Crittall, ed., A History of Wiltshire, 4 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1959), 92–115;
165. Ruth Winnington, “Memoir,” Shropshire Farm Records Collection, SAL 8 2 1
166. Mercer, “Two Centuries,” Walter Baber, transcribed interview no. 109
167. A. P. Donajgrodzki, in “Twentieth Century Rural England, A Case for Peasant Studies,” Journal of Peasant Studies, 16 (April 1989), 425–43
168. J. H. Burton, “Caerphilly Cheese in Somerset,” JBDFA, 22 (1908);
169. Ministry of Agriculture, Interim Report, 1923, 65–70;
170. Hall, Pilgrimage, 212;
171. M. Blackshaw, “The Cheshire Cheese Industry,” JBDFA, 23 (1909), 70–72;
172. William Livesey, “Cheesemaking in Lancashire,” JBDFA, 10 (1895), 61–94.
173. Cheke, Story of Cheesemaking, 159–71, 201–7;
174. K. Bond Hills, “Cheesemaking—From a Farmhouse Craft to an Industry,” JRASE, 121 (1960), 102–108;
175. Joseph Harding, speech transcribed in FH, 15 (May 1868), 36.
176. Taylor, “English Dairy Farming,” 153;
177. Graham, Revival, 173–175;
178. Miles Benson, “Practical Dairy Education and the Work of the British Dairy Institute,” JBDFA, 18 (1903), 50–53;
179. “Devon and Cornwall Conference,” JBDFA, 13 (1898), 75.
180. Lena Sommestad, “From Dairymaids to Dairymen” (unpublished paper, 1990 Berkshire Conference)
181. “Lancashire Dairy Conference,” JBDFA, 10 (1895), 40–54;
182. reports on education in the JBDFA, 14 (1899), 289, and 15 (1900), 52–54;
183. James Long, “Education in Dairy Farming,” Transactions, Highland and Agricultural Society, 4th ser., 20 (1888), 1–106;
184. Thomas Plowman, “The Society's Dairy Schools,” B and W, 4th ser., 5 (1894–95), 83–89;
185. J. P. Sheldon, British Dairying (Crosby, Lockwood, and Son, 1893), 152;
186. Vera Baber, transcribed interview no. 170
187. Aubrey White, transcribed interview no. 139
188. Jeffrey Adams, transcribed interview no. 122
189. Duckett, interview no. 13
190. The collaboration of Lloyd and Cannon is described in Cheke, Story of Cheesemaking, 215, 192–5.
191. Margaret Knowles, “Use of the Acidometer in Cheese–Making,” JBDFA, 15 (1900), 37–40.
192. Richard Mullock, “The Cheshire Cheese Industry,” JBDFA, 24 (1910), 63–66;
193. Sidney White, transcribed interview with Mary Gryspeerdt, no. 136
194. Sheldon, Dairy Farming, 196.
195. Taylor, “English Dairy Farming,” 146–153;
196. B. L. Smith and H. Whitby, “Milk Marketing Before and After Organization” (University of Oxford Agricultural Economics Institute, 1937);
197. James Macintosh, “Dairy Farming and Dairy Work,” JRASE, 99 (1938), 250–279;
198. M. A. Dockery, “Developments in the Farmhouse Cheese–making Industry in England and Wales,” Geography, 68 (1983), 263–5.
199. Marjorie Cohen's article, “Decline of Women in Canadian Dairying,” and also her book, Women's Work, Markets, and Economic Development in Nineteenth–Century Ontario (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1988)
200. Joanna Bourke, “Dairywomen and Affectionate Wives: Women in the Irish Dairy Industry, 1890–1914,” Agricultural History Review, 38:Pt. 2 (1990), 149–65.
201. Angkarloo, “Women's Work,” 114–6.
202. K. D. M. Snell, Annals of the Labouring Poor (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985);
203. Davidoff, “Role of Gender”
204. S. G. Kendall, Farming Memories of a West Country Yeoman (Faber and Faber, 1944), 15.