SCOPUS 정보 검색 플랫폼

Hastings Center Report

Volumn 6, Issue 4, 1976, Pages 21-30

A REPLY TO RICHARD McCORMICK: The enforcement of morals: nontherapeutic research on children

(1) RAMSEY, PAUL a

a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CHILD; COMPETENCE; ETHICS; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; INFORMED CONSENT; MEDICAL ETHICS; MORALITY; NONTHERAPEUTIC RESEARCH; OBLIGATIONS TO SOCIETY; RISKS AND BENEFITS; UNITED STATES;

COMPETENCE; MORALITY; NONTHERAPEUTIC RESEARCH; OBLIGATIONS TO SOCIETY; PARENTAL CONSENT; RISKS AND BENEFITS;

CHILD; ETHICAL ANALYSIS; ETHICS, MEDICAL; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENTATION; INFORMED CONSENT; MORAL OBLIGATIONS; UNITED STATES;

EID: 0016989851 PISSN: 00930334 EISSN: 1552146X Source Type: Journal
DOI: 10.2307/3560383 Document Type: Article

Times cited : (84)

References (31)

1
- 0016144604
- Proxy Consent in the Experimental Situation
- Page references in parentheses in the text are to this article. McCormick's article was revised and reprinted as a chapter in James T. Johnson and David H. Smith, eds., Love and Society: Essays in the Ethics of Paul Ramsey (Missoula, Montana: Scholars Press, 1974), pp. 209‐27
- (1974) Perspectives in Biology and Medicine , vol.18 , pp. 2-20
- McCormick¹

2
- 0003788092
- New Haven:, Yale University Press,. McCormick quotes this passage on page 8 of his article
- (1970) The Patient as Person , pp. 14
- Ramsey¹

3
- 84980298082
- Proceedings of Conference on Biological Revolution/Theological Impact, sponsored by the Institute for Theological Encounter with Science and Technology, Fordyce House, St. Louis, Missouri
- (1973) “Medical Progress and Canons of Loyalty to Experimental Subjects,” , pp. 51-77

4
- 84980213096
- McCormick's position may be compared with the confidence expressed in the Second Vatican Council's Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World, to the effect that “a true contradiction cannot exist between the divine laws pertaining to the transmission of life and those pertaining to the fostering of authentic conjugal love” (italics added).

5
- 84980255431
- Precisely this statement is to be found only in the revised and refined version of the Perspectives article published in Johnson and Smith, p.

6
- 84980298349
- M.D., review of my The Ethics of Fetal Research, in
- (1975) Linacre Quarterly , vol.42 , pp. 285-286
- Battaglia¹

7
- 84980213102
- These quotations are taken from the discussion following the paper referred to in note 3 above, in which I was drawn into talk about nature and grace, justice, and charity. McCormick may have been mislead to suppose that I only wish to reject co‐opting uncomprehending subjects for charitable service or simply to deny anyone's right to make children martyrs. My formal paper on that occasion contains no suggestion that proxy consent ceases to be valid only in case of supererogatory actions.

8
- 84980230310
- (cf. Perspectives, p. 14)
- Johnson¹ Smith²

9
- 84980283641
- Ibid., p., (cf. Perspectives, p. 15)

10
- 0016125311
- Experimenting on Human Subjects
- (1974) Linacre Quarterly , vol.41 , pp. 238-252
- May¹

11
- 84980244810
- Ibid., p.

12
- 84980283642
- The Patient as Person
- Ramsey¹

13
- 84921593954
- Notes on Moral Theology
- (1975) Theological Studies , vol.36 , pp. 128
- McCormick¹

14
- 84980213047
- May, p.

15
- 84980213067
- Patient as Person, n. 11 (italics added)
- Ramsey¹

16
- 84980298071
- Cf. May, pp.

17
- 84980213090
- Wagner v. International Railway Co., 232 N.Y. 176
- (1921)

18
- 84980299826
- “Notes on Moral Theology,” p.
- McCormick¹

19
- 84980222861
- “Kant's grounds for this imperative (humanity, in oneself or in others, as the source of rational moral self‐legislation) are, of course, quite different from Christian grounds. The latter appeals instead to the wholeness of God's care for the least and the littlest ones and their preciousness to Him. On the point in question, however, these quite different world‐views come to the same issue.

20
- 84980203476
- This question is asked in the Johnson and Smith revision, p., immediately after the foregoing quotations

21
- 84980298090
- Thus McCormick can in no way be held responsible for the fact that the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects in Biomedical and Behavioral Research— on whose deliberations his writings had considerable influence, as also did those of his colleague LeRoy Walters—in its report on fetal research said only “minimum risk.” McCormick's criteria are certainly more limiting than that!.

22
- 84980283634
- “Notes on Moral Theology,” p.
- McCormick¹

23
- 84980306390
- “Proxy Consent,” p.
- McCormick¹

24
- 84980238712
- Note 21 above.

25
- 0016426815
- The Medical Ethics of Bone Marrow Transplantation in Childhood
- M.D.,. In Case I the donor, although only fourteen, had no reservations about his role and clearly gave an understanding consent
- (1975) Journal of Pediatrics , vol.86 , pp. 145-150
- Levine¹

26
- 84980199638
- 445 S.W.2d 145, Ky. App.
- (1969)

27
- 0040594678
- (italics added).
- (1976) The New York Times

28
- 0003788092
- and William J. Curran, “A Problem of Consent: Kidney Transplantation in Minors,” New York University Law Review 34 (May 1959), 891‐98
- The Patient as Person , pp. 167-175
- Ramsey¹

29
- 84980234139
- Helling v. Carey, 519 F.2d 981, Wash.
- (1974)

30
- 84980238725
- Texas & Pac, Ry. v. Behymer, 189 U.S. 468, 470, 23 S.CT. 622, 623, 47 L. Ed. 905
- (1903)

31
- 84980238735
- The T. J. Hopper, 60 F.2nd 737, 740
- (1932)

* 이 정보는 Elsevier사의 SCOPUS DB에서 KISTI가 분석하여 추출한 것입니다.