Placebo defense: Operation desert mirage? The rhetoric of patriot missile accuracy in the 1991 Persian Gulf War

Quarterly Journal of Speech

Volumn 86, Issue 2, 2000, Pages 121-145

  Mitchell, Gordon R ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH   (United States)

Author keywords

Deception; Gulf War; Patriot; Postmoderism; Rhetoric (of science)

Indexed keywords

EID: 0010217686     PISSN: 00335630     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00335630009384286     Document Type: Article

References (90)

1. Anderson, Christopher. "Classification Catch-22." Nature 256 (March 1992): 274.
2. Atkins, Rep. George. Statement. Performance of the Patriot Missile in the Gulf War. 102nd Cong., 2nd sess. House Hearing, Committee on Government Operations. 7 April 1992. Washington: GPO: 214.
3. Baudrillard, Jean. the gulf war did not take place. Bloomington, IN: Indiana UP, 1995.
4. Baudrillard, Jean. "The Reality Gulf: Why the Gulf War Will Not Take Place." Guardian (London) 11 January 1991: 25.
5. Baudrillard, Jean. "Simulacrum and Simulations." In Mark Poster, Ed. Baudrillard: Selected Writings. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1989.
6. Baudrillard, Jean. Simulations. Trans. Foss, Patton and Beitchman. New York: Semiotext[e], 1983.
7. Beinhart, Larry. American Hero. New York: Ballantine, 1993.
8. Bjork, Rebecca. The Strategic Defense Initiative: Symbolic Containment of the Nuclear Threat. New York: SUNY Press, 1992.
9. Bok, Sissella. "The Ethics of Giving Placebos." Scientific American November 1974: 17-23.
10. Bond, David F. "Army Scales Back Assessments of Patriot's Success in Gulf War." Aviation Week and Space Technology 13 April 1992: 64.
11. Broad, William. Teller's War. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1992.
12. Buchanan, Patrick. "Evidence of SDI's Potential." Washington Times 30 January 1991: G2.
13. Bush, George. "Exchange with Reporters in Andover, Massachusetts, on the Iraqi Offer to Withdraw from Kuwait." Public Papers of the Presidents: Administration of George Bush. 15 February 1991. Washington: GPO: 147-148.
14. Bush, George. "Remarks to Raytheon Missile Systems Plant Employees in Andover, Massachusetts." Public Papers of the Presidents: Administration of George Bush. 15 February 1991. Washington: GPO: 148-150.
15. Bush, George. "Remarks Following Discussions With Amir Jabir al-Ahmad al-Jabir Al-Sabah of Kuwait." Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents. 29 September 1990. Washington: GPO.
16. Bush, George. "Address to the People of Iraq on the Persian Gulf Crisis." Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents. 16 September 1990. Washington: GPO.
17. Cabot, R.C. Social Service and the Art of Healing. New York: Moffat, Yard and Co., 1909.
18. Campbell, David. Politics Without Principle: Sovereignty, Ethics and the Narratives of the Gulf War. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 1993.
19. Chandler, David. "No Letup in War of Words." Boston Globe 4 April 1994: 25-28.
20. Chandler, David. "Sorting Out the Claims: Q & A." Boston Globed April 1994: 25+.
21. Charles, Dan. "Critics Home in on Patriot Missile." New Scientist 2 February 1991: 39.
22. Cheney, Richard. Statement. Department of Defense Authorization for Appropriations for Fiscal Years 1992 and 1993. 102nd Cong., 1st sess. Senate Hearing, Committee on Armed Services. 21 February 1991. Washington: GPO: 15.
23. Cockburn, Alexander. "Dumb Bombs." New Statesman and Society 14 June 1991: 17.
24. "Conferences on Therapy: The Use of Placebos in Therapy." New York State Journal of Medicine 46 (1976): 1718-27.
25. Conyers, Hon. John, Jr. Response to letter of Frank Horton. Arms Control Today 23 (January/February 1993): 27-29.
26. Conyers, Hon. John, Jr. "The Patriot Myth: Caveat Emptor." Arms Control Today 22 (November 1992): 3-10.
27. Conyers, Hon. John, Jr. Letter to Defense Secretary Cheney. 28 February 1991. On file w/author.
28. Cooper, Henry. Statement. Hearing Before the Subcommittee on the Department of Defense. 102nd Cong., 1st sess. House Hearing. 17 April 1991. Washington: GPO: 613.
29. Davis, Richard. Statement. Performance of the Patriot Missile in the Gulf War. 102nd Cong., 2nd sess. House Hearing, Committee on Government Operations. 7 April 1992. Washington: GPO: 77-98.
30. Drolet, Robert A. "PEO Air Defense Responds to Patriot Criticisms." Inside the Army 9 December 1991: 5.
31. Farrell, Thomas B., and G. Thomas Goodnight. "Accidental Rhetoric: The Root Metaphors of Three Mile Island." Communication Monographs 48 (December 1981): 270-300.
32. Farrell, Thomas B. Norms of Rhetorical Culture. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1994.
33. Farrell, Thomas B. "Knowledge, Consensus, and Rhetorical Theory." Quarterly Journal of Speech 62 (February 1976): 1-14.
34. Feuerwerger, Marvin. "Defense Against Missiles: Patriot Lessons." Orbis 36 (Fall 1992): 581-588.
35. Fialka John J. Hotel Warriors: Covering the Gulf War. Washington, D.C.: Woodrow Wilson Center Press, 1991.
36. Fisher, Walter R. Human Communication as Narration: Toward a Philosophy of Reason, Value and Action. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 1987.
37. Fisk, Robert. "The Bad Taste of Dying Men." Independent (London) 24 February 1991: 19.
38. "Get Smarter on Smart Weapons." New York Times 11 July 1996: A22.
39. Goodnight, G Thomas. "Controversy." In Donn Marson, Ed. Argument in Controversy: Proceedings of the Seventh SCA/AFA conference on Argumentation. Annandale, VA: SCA, 1992: 1-13.
40. Gordon, Michael R. and General Bernard E. Trainor. The General's War. Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1995.
41. Gugiotta, Guy and Caryle Murphy. "Warplanes Roar Off in Darkness in 'Desert Storm.'" Washington Post 17 January 1991: A27.
42. Herman, Edward S. and Noam Chomsky. Manufacturing Consent. New York: Pantheon, 1988.
43. Hildreth, Steven. "Evaluation of U.S. Army Assessment of Patriot Antitactical Missile Effectiveness in the War Against Iraq." Report. Performance of the Patriot Missile in the Gulf War. 102nd Cong., 2nd sess. House Hearing, Committee on Government Operations. 7 April 1992. Washington: GPO: 22-76.
44. Horton, Hon. Frank. Performance of the Patriot Missile in the Gulf War. 102nd Cong., 2nd sess. House Hearing, Committee on Government Operations. 7 April 1992. Washington: GPO: 5-8.
45. Hughes, David. "Tracking Software Error Likely Reason Patriot Battery Failed to Engage Scud." Aviation Week and Space Technology 10 June 1991: 26-27.
46. Hughes, David. "Success of Patriot System Shapes Debate on Future Antimissile Weapons." Aviation Week and Space Technology 22 April 1991: 90-91.
47. Hughes, David. "Saudi Order to Keep Patriot Line Open As Performance in Israel is Questioned." Aviation Week and Space Technology 25 November 1991: 38.
48. Kellner, Douglas. The Persian Gulf TV War. Boulder, CO: Westview, 1992.
49. Kiernan, Vincent. "Beyond the Patriot." Discover June 1991: 80-82.
50. Kuttler, Hillel. "U.S., Israel Sign Defense Pact." Israel Line 29 April 1996. Consulate of Israel, New York. Online. Lexis/Nexis.
51. Lyotard, Jean Francois. The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge. Trans. G. Bennington and B. Massumi. (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1984).
52. MacFarland, Margo. "Congressional Investigators Charge Army Data Doesn't Back Patriot Success." Inside the Army 9 March 1992: 1.
53. Mahan, Grant. "Hawk Publisher Bombs Dove Editor." Washington Journalism Review 13 (April 1991): 14-15.
54. Marshall, Eliot. "Fatal Error: How Patriot Overlooked a Scud." Science 13 March 1992: 1347.
55. McBride, James. War, Battering and Other Sports. New Jersey: Humanities Press, 1995.
56. McLauchlan, Gregory, and Gregory Hooks. "Last of the Dinosaurs? Big Weapons, Big Science, and the American State from Hiroshima to the End of the Cold War." Sociological Quarterly 36 (1995): 749-776.
57. Mitchell, Gordon. "Another Strategic Deception Initiative." Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 53 (March/April 1997): 22-23.
58. Morgan, Dan, and George Lardner Jr. "Scud Damage Suggests Patriot Needs Refinement: U.S. Missiles Sometimes Fail to Destroy Iraqi Warheads in Midair Interceptions." Washington Post 21 February 1991: A27.
59. Morrison, David C. "Patriot Games." National Journal 25 April 1992: 1028.
60. Naureckas, Jim. "Gulf War Coverage: The Worst Censorship Was at Home." Naureckas, Jim and Janine Jackson, Eds. The FAIR Reader: An EXTRA! Review of Press and Politics in the '90s. Boulder, CO: Westview. 1996: 28-42.
61. Neal, Rep. Stephen. Statement. Performance of the Patriot Missile in the Gulf War. 102nd Cong., 2nd sess. House Hearing, Committee on Government Operations. 7 April 1992. Washington: GPO: 96.
62. Pedatzur, Reuven. Statement. Performance of the Patriot Missile in the Gulf War. 102nd Cong., 2nd sess. House Hearing, Committee on Government Operations. 7 April 1992. Washington: GPO: 118-121.
63. Pike, John. "Star Wars: Clever Politics in the Service of Bad Policy." F.A.S. Public Interest Report 49 (September/ October 1996): 1-14.
64. Points, Kari. "Reporting Conventions Mask Sexual Politics." Media and Values 56 (Fall 1991): 19.
65. Postol, Theodore A. Personal interview with the author. 10 May 1995. Cambridge, MA. Manuscript on file w/author.
66. Postol, Theodore A. "Reply to letter of Robert Stein." International Security 17 (Summer 1992): 225-240.
67. Postol, Theodore A. "Optical Evidence Indicating Patriot High Miss Rates During the Gulf War." Performance of the Patriot Missile in the Gulf War. 102nd Cong., 2nd sess. House Hearing, Committee on Government Operations. 7 April 1992. Washington: GPO: 131-149.
68. Postol, Theodore A. "Improper Use of the Classification System to Suppress Public Debate on the Gulf War Performance of the Patriot Air Defense System." Government Secrecy After the Cold War. U.S. 102nd Cong., 2nd sess. House Hearing, Committee on Government Operations. 18 March 1992. Washington: GPO: 38-62.
69. Postol, Theodore A. "Lessons of the Gulf War Experience with Patriot." International Security 16 (Winter 1991/1992): 119-171.
70. "Raytheon Awarded Deal to Sell Taiwan Patriot Antimissiles." Wall Street Journal 1 July 1994: B4.
71. Reiss, Edward. The Strategic Defense Initiative. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1992.
72. "Representative Conyers Wants Cheney to Probe Army Claims Regarding Patriot's Success." Inside the Pentagon 12 March 1992: 14.
73. Romm, Joseph. "Pseudo Science and SDI." Arms Control Today 19 (1989): 15-21.
74. Rudge, David. "Lubrani: Real Test Will be Accord's Implementation." Israel Line 29 April 1996. Consulate of Israel, New York. Online. Lexis/Nexis.
75. Ryan, Randoloph. "Patriot Propaganda." Boston Globe 21 March 1992: 9.
76. Sanger, David E. "North Korea Warns U.S. on Patriot Missiles." New York Times 30 January 1994: 4.
77. Schonauer, Klaus. Semiotic Foundations of Drug Therapy: The Placebo Problem in a New Perspective. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter, 1994.
78. Shapiro, Arthur K. "A Historic and Heuristic Definition of the Placebo." Psychiatry 27 (1964): 52-58.
79. Shenon, Philip. "Allied Fliers Jubilantly Tell of Early Control of the Skies as Iraq Planes Fled." New York Times 18 January 1991: A10.
80. Shukman, David. Tomorrow's War. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1996.
81. Spring, Baker. Congress Bickered Over Weapons Now Proving Themselves in the Gulf. Backgrounder #808. 8 February 1991. Washington: Heritage Foundation.
82. Stein, Robert. Letter to the Editor. International Security 17 (Summer 1992): 199-225.
83. Stein, Robert. "Patriot ATBM Experience in the Gulf War." Letter to International Security subscribers. 8 January 1991. Copy on file with the author.
84. United States. General Accounting Office. Operation Desert Storm: Data Does Not Exist to Conclusively Say How Well Patriot Performed. Report to Congressional Requesters. NSIAD-92-340. September 1992. Washington: GPO.
85. United States. General Accounting Office. Operation Desert Storm: Evaluation of the Air War. PEMD-96-10. July 1996. Washington: GPO.
86. Wark, McKenzie. "Gulfest." Australian Left Review February 1991: 7.
87. Weiner, Tim. "Army Squelches Article - After it's Published." Philadelphia Inquirer 19 March 1992: 1+.
88. Woodruff, Letter to Kenneth Withers. 6 February 1985. Copy on file with the author.
89. Woodward, Bob. The Commanders. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1991.
90. Woolley, Benjamin. Virtual Worlds. Cambridge, MA: Oxford, 1992.