Taxonomy and the personal equation: The historical fates of Charles Girard and Louis Agassiz

Journal of the History of Biology

Volumn 32, Issue 3, 1999, Pages 509-555

  Jackson, James R ^a   Kimllr, William C ^a  

^a NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Charles Girard; Ichthyology; Louis Agassiz; Museum of Comparative Zoology; Reputation; Smithsonian Institution; Spencer Baird; Taxonomy

Indexed keywords

EID: 0002700921     PISSN: 00225010     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1023/A:1004784904703     Document Type: Article

References (105)

1. Abbott, Charles C. 1860. "Descriptions of New Species of American Fresh-Water Fishes." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 12: 325-328.
2. L'Académie des Sciences. 1861. Comptes rendus hebdomadaires des séances de l'Académie des Sciences 52: 594-596.
3. Agassiz, Louis. 1850a. Lake Superior: Its Physical Character, Vegetation, and Animals, Compared with Those of Other and Similar Regions. By Louis Agassiz. With a Narrative of the Tour, by J. Elliot Cabot. And Contributions by Other Scientific Gentlemen. Boston: Gould, Kendall and Lincoln.
4. _1850b. "Remarks on Species Belonging to the Genus Lepidosteus." Proc. Boston Soc. Nat. Hist. 3: 182.
5. _1854a. "Additional Notes on the Holoconoti." Amer. J. Sci. Arts 17: 365-369.
6. _1854b. "Notice of a Collection of Fishes from the Southern Bend of the Tennessee River, in the State of Alabama." Amer. J. Sci. Arts 17: 297-308, 353-365.
7. _1854c. "The Primitive Diversity and Number of Animals in Geological Times." Amer. J. Sci. Arts 17: 308-324.
8. _1855. "Synopsis of the Ichthyological Fauna of the Pacific Slope of North America, Chiefly from the Collections made by the U.S. Expl. Exped. Under the Command of Capt. C. Wilkes, with Recent Additions and Comparisons with Eastern Types." Amer. J. Sci. Arts 19: 71-99, 215-231.
9. _1857. "Essay on Classification." In Contributions to the Natural History of the United States, Vol 1. Boston: Little, Brown.
10. _1857-1862. Contributions to the Natural History of the United States. Boston: Little, Brown.
11. _1860. "Individuality and Specific Differences Among Acalephs." Amer. J. Sci. Arts 30: 142-154.
12. _1874. "Evolution and Permanence of Type." Atlantic Monthly 33: 92-101.
13. Allard, Dean Conrad, Jr. 1878. Spencer Fullerton Baird and the U.S. Fish Commission. New York: Arno.
14. American Association for the Advancement of Science. 1850. Membership list. Proc. Amer. Ass. Ad. Sci. 2: xiii.
15. Bailey, Reeve M. and Uyeno, Teruya. 1964. "Nomenclature of the Blue Chub and the Tui Chub, Cyprinid Fishes from Western United States." Copeia 1964: 238-239.
16. Baird, Spencer Fullerton. 1857. Reports of Explorations and Surveys to Ascertain the Most Practicable and Economical Route for a Railroad from the Mississippi River to the Pacific Ocean. Volume 8. Mammals. Washington, D.C.: Nicholson.
17. _1858. Reports of Explorations and Surveys to Ascertain the Most Practicable and Economical Route for a Railroad from the Mississippi River to the Pacific Ocean. Volume 9. Birds. Washington, D.C.: Nicholson.
18. Baird, Spencer Fullerton and Girard, Charles Frederic. 1853a. "Descriptions of New Species of Fishes Collected by Mr. John H. Clark, on the U.S. and Mexican Boundary Survey, under Lt. Col. Jas. D. Graham." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 6: 387-390.
19. _1853b. "Descriptions of New Species of Fishes, Collected by Captains R.B. Marcy, and Geo. B. M'Clellun, in Arkansas." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 6: 390-392.
20. _1854. "Descriptions of New Species of Fishes Collected in Texas, New Mexico and Sonora, by Mr. John H. Clark, on the U.S. and Mexican Boundary Survey, and in Texas by Capt. Stewart Van Vliet, U.S.A." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 7: 24-29.
21. Barlow, George F. 1961. "Causes and Significance of Morphological Variation in Fishes." Sys. Zool. 10: 105-117.
22. Bleeker, Pieter. 1860. De visschen van den Indischen Archipel breschreven en toegelicht. Deel II. Cyprini. In Ichthyologiae Archipelagi Indici prodomus. Batavia: Lange.
23. Briggs, John C. 1986. "Introduction to the Zoogeography of North American Fishes." In The Zoogeography of North American Freshwater Fishes, ed. Charles H. Hocutt and E.O. Wiley, pp. 1-16. New York: Wiley.
24. Bruce, Robert V. 1987. The Launching of Modern American Science 1846-1876. New York: Knopf.
25. Burr, Brooks M. 1980. "Campostoma anomalum (Rafinesque) - Stoneroller." In Atlas of North American Freshwater Fishes, ed. David S. Lee et al., p. 143. Raleigh: North Carolina State Museum of Natural History.
26. Clay, William M. 1975. The Fishes of Kentucky. Frankfort: Kentucky Department of Fish and Wildlife Resources.
27. Cooper, Lane. 1945. Louis Agassiz as a Teacher: Illustrative Extracts on his Method of Instruction. Ithaca: Comstock.
28. Cope, Edward Drinker. 1869. "On the Distribution of Freshwater Fishes in the Allegheny Region of Southwestern Virginia." J. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 6: 207-248.
29. Dall, William Healy. 1915. Spencer Fullerton Baird: A Biography. Philadelphia: Lippincott.
30. DeKay, James Ellsworth. 1842. Zoology of New York. Part IV. Fishes. Albany, New York: White and Visschen.
31. Dexter, Ralph W. 1964. "Some Remarks on Nomenclature by Scudder, Haldeman, Gray, and Baird (1868-1869)." Sys. Zool. 13: 96-97.
32. _1970. "Historical Aspects of F.W. Putnam's Studies of Fishes." J. Hist. Biol. 3: 131-135.
33. Eschmeyer, William N. 1990. Catalog of the Genera of Recent Fishes. San Francisco: California Academy of Sciences.
34. Forman, Paul. 1991. "Independence, Not Transcendence, for the Historian of Science." Isis 82: 71-86.
35. Gibbons, William P. 1854a. "Description of Four New Species of Viviparous Fishes from Sacramento River, and the Bay of San Francisco." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 7: 105-106.
36. _1854b. "Description of New Species of Viviparous Marine and Fresh-Water Fishes, from the Bay of San Francisco, and from the River and Lagoons of the Sacramento." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 7: 122-126.
37. Gill, Theodore Nicholas. 1862. "Catalogue of the fishes of Lower California, in the Smithsonian Institution, collected by Mr. J. Xantus." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 14: 80-88.
38. Girard, Charles Frederic. Papers, circa 1846-1860, and undated, Record Unit 7190, Collection Division 1: Manuscripts, speeches, correspondence, notes, and related materials, 1846-1854, and undated. Box 1, Folder 5: Copies of correspondence and statements by Girard regarding a dispute with Louis Agassiz, 1852. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Archives.
39. _1851. "An Essay on the Classification of Nemertes and Planariæ: Preceded by Some General Considerations on the Primary Divisions of the Animal Kingdom." Amer. J. Sci. Arts 11: 41-53.
40. _1852a. "Contributions to the Natural History of the Fresh-Water Fishes of North America. I. Monograph of Cottoids." Smithsonian Contrib. Knowl. 3.
41. _1852b. "On the Classification of Mammalia." Proc. Amer. Ass. Ad. Sci. 4: 319-334.
42. _1854. "Descriptions of New Fishes, Collected by Dr. A.L. Heermann, Naturalist Attached to the Survey of the Pacific Railroad Route, under Lieut. R.S. Williamson, U.S.A." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 7: 129-140.
43. _1856. "Researches upon the Cyprinoid Fishes Inhabiting the Fresh Waters of the United States of America, West of the Mississippi Valley, from Specimens in the Museum of the Smithsonian Institution." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 8: 165-213.
44. _1858. Reports of Explorations and Surveys to Ascertain the Most Practicable and Economical Route for a Railroad from the Mississippi River to the Pacific Ocean. Volume 10. Fishes. Washington, D.C.: Nicholson.
45. _1859. Report on the United States and Mexican Boundary Survey; Made under the Direction of the Secretary of the Interior. Volume 2, Part 2. Fishes. Washington, D.C.: Cornelius Wendell.
46. Girard, Charles Frederic and Baird, Spencer Fullerton. 1853. Catalogue of North American Reptiles in the Museum of the Smithsonian Institution. Part I. Serpents. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.
47. Goetzmann, William H. 1959. Army Exploration in the American West 1803-1863. New Haven: Yale University Press.
48. Goode, George Browne. 1883. "Bibliographies of American Naturalists: The Published Writings of Spencer Fullerton Baird, 1843-1882." Bull. U.S. Nat. Mus. 20: 255-269.
49. _1891. "Bibliographies of American Naturalists: The Published Writings of Dr. Charles Girard." Bull. U.S. Nat. Mus. 41: i-vi, 1-141.
50. Gould, Stephen Jay. 1977. Ontogeny and Phylogeny. Cambridge: Belknap Press at Harvard University Press.
51. Herber, Elmer Charles. 1963. Correspondence between Spencer Fullerton Baird and Louis Agassiz - Two Pioneer American Naturalists. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.
52. Holbrook, John Edwards. 1855. "An Account of Several Species of Fish Observed in Florida, Georgia, & c." J. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 3: 47-58.
53. Hoole, William Stanley. 1962. Introduction to A Visit to the Confederate States of America in 1863: Memoir Addressed to His Majesty Napoleon III, by Charles Frederic Girard. Tuscaloosa, Alabama: Confederate Publishing Company, Inc.
54. Hubbs, Carl Leavitt. 1930. "Materials for the Revision of the Catostomid Fishes of Eastern North America." Miscell. Publ. Mus. Zool. Univ. Michigan 20: 1-47.
55. _1961. "Isolating Mechanisms in the Speciation of Fishes." In Vertebrate Speciation, ed W.F. Blair, pp. 5-23. Austin: University of Texas Press.
56. _1964a. "David Starr Jordan." Sys. Zool. 13: 195-200.
57. _1964b. "History of Ichthyology in the United States after 1850." Copeia 1964: 42-60.
58. Hubbs, Carl Leavitt and Ortenburger, A. I. 1929. "Further Notes on the Fishes of Oklahoma with Descriptions of New Species of Cyprinidae." Publ. Univ. Oklahoma Biol. Sur. 1(2): 17-43.
59. Hull, David L. 1965. "The Effect of Essentialism on Taxonomy - Two Thousand Years of Stasis (I & II)." Brit. J. Phil. Sci. 15: 314-326;
60. Hull, David L. Brit. J. Phil. Sci. 16: 1-18.
61. _1979. "In Defense of Presentism." Hist. Theory 18: 1-15.
62. Jordan, David Starr. 1885. "Identification of the species of Cyprinidae and Catostomidae, Described by Dr. Charles Girard, in the Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia for 1856." Proc. U.S. Nat. Mus. 8: 118-127.
63. _1896. Science Sketches. Chicago: McClung.
64. _1902. "The History of Ichthyology." Science 16: 241-258.
65. _1923. "Spencer Fullerton Baird and the United States Fish Commission." Sci. Monthly 17: 97-107.
66. Jordan, David Starr and Evermann, Barton Warren. 1896. "The Fishes of North and Middle America: A Descriptive Catalogue of the Species of Fish-Like Vertebrates Found in the Waters of North America, North of the Isthmus of Panama." In Bull. U.S. Nat. Mus. No. 47. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
67. Jordan, David Starr and Gilbert, Charles Henry. 1877. "On the Genera of North American Fresh-Water Fishes." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 29: 83-104.
68. Kirtland, Jared Potter. 1840-1845. "Descriptions of the Fishes of the Ohio River and Its Tributaries." Boston J. Nat. Hist. 3: 338-352, 469-482;
69. Kirtland, Jared Potter. Boston J. Nat. Hist. 4: 16-26;
70. Kirtland, Jared Potter. Boston J. Nat. Hist. 4: 303-308;
71. Kirtland, Jared Potter. Boston J. Nat. Hist. 5: 21-32.
72. _1842-1846. "Descriptions of the Fishes of Lake Erie, the Ohio River and Their Tributaries." Boston J. Nat. Hist. 4: 231-240;
73. Boston J. Nat. Hist. 5: 265-276;
74. Boston J. Nat. Hist. 5: 330-344.
75. Kohlstedt, Sally Gregory. 1976. The Formation of the American Scientific Community: The American Association for the Advancement of Science 1848-1860. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
76. Lurie, Edward. 1960. Louis Agassiz: A Life in Science. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
77. Marcou, Jules. 1895. Life, Letters, and Works of Louis Agassiz. New York: MacMillan.
78. Mayden, Richard L. (ed.). 1992. Systematics, Historical Ecology, and North American Freshwater Fishes. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
79. Mayden, Richard L. and Gilbert, Carter R. 1989. "Notropis ludibundus (Girard) and Notropis tristis (Girard), Replacement Names for N. stramineus (Cope) and N. topeka (Gilbert) (Teleostei: Cypriniformes)." Copeia 1989: 1084-1089.
80. Mayden, Richard L., Matson, R. H. and Hillis, D. M. 1992. "Speciation in the North American Genus Dionda." In Systematics, Historical Ecology, and North American Freshwater Fishes, ed. Richard L. Mayden. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
81. Mayr, Ernst. 1959. "Agassiz, Darwin, and Evolution." Harvard Lib. Bull. 13: 165-194.
82. _1991. One Long Argument: Charles Darwin and the Genesis of Modern Evolutionary Thought. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
83. Myers, George S. 1964. "A Brief Sketch of the History of Ichthyology in America to the Year 1850." Copeia 1964: 33-41.
84. Orosz, Joel J. 1970. "Disloyalty, Dismissal, and a Deal: The Development of the National Museum at the Smithsonian Institution." Mus. Stud. J. 2: 22-33.
85. _1990. Curators and Culture: The Museum Movement in America, 1740-1870. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.
86. Poey y Aloy, Felipe. 1854 [1851-1858]. Memorias sobre la historia natural de la isla de Cuba: acompañadas de sumarios latinos y extractos en francés. Havana: Barcina.
87. Purcell, Rosamund Wolff and Gould, Stephen Jay. 1992. Finders, Keepers: Treasures and Oddities of Natural History. New York: Norton.
88. Putnam, Frederic Ward. 1863. "List of Fishes Sent by the Museum to Different Institutions, in the Exchange for other Specimens, with Annotations." Bull. Mus. Compar. Zool. 1: 1-16.
89. Reingold, Nathan. 1964. Science in Nineteenth-Century America: A Documentary History. New York: Hill and Wang.
90. Rieppel, Olivier. 1988. "Louis Agassiz (1807-1873) and the Reality of Natural Groups." Biol. Phil. 3: 29-47.
91. Rivinus, E. F. and Youssef, E. M. 1992. Spencer Baird of the Smithsonian. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.
92. Robins, C. Richard. 1961. "Two New Cottid Fishes from the Fresh Waters of the Eastern United States." Copeia 196: 305-315.
93. Robins, C. Richard et al. 1991. A List of Common and Scientific Names of Fishes from the United States and Canada, 5th edn. Bethesda, Maryland: American Fisheries Society.
94. Smith-Vaniz, William F. and McCracken Peck, Robert. 1991. "Contributions of Henry Weed Fowler (1878-1965), with a Brief Early History of Ichthyology at the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia." Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Phila. 143: 173-191.
95. Smithsonian Institution. 1862. Annual Report of the Board of Regents of the Smithsonian Institution for 1861. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
96. Storer, David Humphries. 1855. "A History of the Fishes of Massachusetts." Mem. Amer. Acad. Arts and Sci. 5: 49-92, 122-168, 257-296.
97. Storer, Horatio Robinson. 1850. "Observations on the Fishes of Nova Scotia and Labrador, with Descriptions of New Species." Boston J. Nat. Hist. 6: 247-270.
98. Trautman, Milton B. 1981. The Fishes of Ohio, rev. edn. Columbus: Ohio State University Press.
99. Wall, B. R., Jr. and Gilbert, Carter R. 1980. "Erimyzon sucetta (Lacepede), Lake Chubsucker." In Atlas of North American Freshwater Fishes, ed. David S. Lee et al. p. 399. Raleigh: North Carolina State Museum of Natural History.
100. Washburn, Wilcomb E. 1965. "The Museum and Joseph Henry." Curator 8: 35-54.
101. Watson, George E. 1985. "Vertebrate Collections: Lost Opportunities." In Magnificent Voyagers: The U.S. Exploring Expedition, 1838-1842, ed. Herman J. Viola and Carolyn Margolis, pp. 43-69. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.
102. Wiley, E. O. 1976. "The Phylogeny and Biogeography of Fossil and Recent Gars (Actinopterygii: Lepisosteidae)." Miscellaneous Publications of the Museum of Natural History of the University of Kansas 64.
103. Winsor, Mary Pickard. 1979. "Louis Agassiz and the Species Question." Stud. Hist. of Biol. 3: 89-117.
104. _1990. Reading the Shape of Nature: Comparative Zoology at the Agassiz Museum. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
105. _1994. "The Lessons of History." In Models in Phylogeny Reconstruction, ed. Robert W. Scotland, Darrell J. Siebert and David M. Williams, pp. 1-9. Systematics Association Special Volume No. 52. Oxford: Clarendon Press for the Systematics Association.