Experimental and computational simulation of in-flight icing phenomena

Progress in Aerospace Sciences

Volumn 34, Issue 5-6, 1998, Pages 257-345

  Kind, R J ^a   Potapczuk, M G ^b   Feo, A ^c   Golia, C ^d   Shah, A D ^e  

^a CARLETON UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b NASA GLENN RESEARCH CENTER   (United States)

^c INSTITUTO NACIONAL DE TÉCNICA AEROESPACIAL   (Spain)

^d ITALIAN AEROSPACE RESEARCH CENTER   (Italy)

^e BOEING COMPANY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 0001080731     PISSN: 03760421     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0376-0421(98)80001-8     Document Type: Article

References (154)

1. Lynch FT, Khodadoust A. The aerodynamic effects of ice accretion. Prog Aerosp Sci., in preparation.
2. Messinger BL. Equilibrium temperature of an unheated icing surface as a function of air speed. J Aero Sci 1953;20:29-42.
3. Hansman RJ Jr, Turnock SR. Investigation of surface water behavior during glaze ice accretion. J Aircraft 1989;26:140-7.
4. Bilanin AJ. Proposed modifications to ice accretion icing scaling theory. J Aircraft 1991;28:353-9.
5. Hansman RJ Jr, Yamaguchi K, Berkowitz B, Potapczuk M. Modelling of surface roughness effects on glaze ice accretion. J. Thermophys 1991;5:54-60.
6. Hansman RJ, Breuer LS, Hazan D, Reehorst A, Vargas M. Close-up analysis of aircraft ice accretion. NASA TM 105952 and AIAA Paper 93-0029, 1993.
7. Olsen W, Walker E. Experimental evidence for modifying the current physical model for ice accretion on aircraft surfaces. NASA TM-87184, 1986.
8. Yamaguchi K, Hansman RJ Jr. Heat transfer on accreting ice surfaces. J Aircraft 1992;29:108-13.
9. Achenbach E. The effect of surface roughness on the heat transfer from a circular cylinder to the cross flow of air. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 1977;20:359-69.
10. Kirchner RD. Aircraft icing roughness features and its effect on the icing process. AIAA Paper 83-0111, 1983.
11. Bragg MB, Kerho MF, Cummings MJ. Airfoil boundary layer due to large leading-edge roughness. AIAA Paper 95-0536, 1995.
12. Kerho MF, Bragg MB. Airfoil boundary-layer development and transition with large leading-edge roughness. AIAA J 1997;35:75-84.
13. Shin J. Characteristics of surface roughness associated with leading-edge ice accretion. J Aircraft 1996;33(2):316-21.
14. Anderson DN, Shin J. Characterization of ice roughness from simulated icing encounters. AIAA Paper 97-0052, 1997.
15. Bilanin AJ, Anderson DN. Ice accretion with varying surface tension. AIAA Paper 95-0538, 1995.
16. Hansman RJ Jr. Microphysical factors which influence ice accretion. Proceedings of the Ist Bombardier International Workshop: Aircraft Icing, Boundary-Layer Stability and Transition. Ecole Polytechnique de Montreal, Montreal, September 1993:86-103.
17. Langmuir I, Blodgett KB. A mathematical investigation of water droplet trajectories. Army Air Forces Tech. Rept. 5418, Contract W-33-038-ac-9151, 1946.
18. Etkin B. Interaction of precipitation with complex flows. Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Wind Effects on Buildings and Structures, Tokyo, 1971:135-43.
19. Armand C, Charpin F, Fasso G, Leclere G. Techniques and facilities at the ONERA Modane centre for icing tests. Appendix to Paper 6 in AGARD Advisory Report No. 127, 1977, 1977.
20. Bongrand J. Etude theorique et experimentale de l'Influence de divers parametres Sur le Givrage d'un Profil. Paper 10 in AGARD CP 236, 1978.
21. Bragg MB. A similarity analysis of the droplet trajectory equation. AIAA J 1982a;20:1681-6.
22. Stokes GG. On the effect of the internal friction of fluids on the motion of pendulums. Cambridge Philos Trans 1851;9:8-106.
23. Anderson DN. Rime-, mixed- and glaze-Ice evaluations of three scaling laws. AIAA Paper 94-0718, 1994.
24. Kreith F. Principles of heat transfer. 2nd ed. Scranton, PA: International Textbook Co., 1965:550-60.
25. Simpson RL. A generalized correlation of roughness density effects on the turbulent boundary layer. AIAA J 1973;11:242-4.
26. Kind RJ, Lawrysyn MA. Aerodynamic characteristics of hoar frost roughness., AIAA J 1992;30:1703-7.
27. Achenbach E. Total and local heat transfer from a smooth circular cylinder in cross-flow at high Reynolds number. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 1975;18:1387-96.
28. Kind RJ, Gladstone DH, Moizer AD. Convective heat losses from flat-plate solar collectors in turbulent winds. ASME J Solar Energy Eng 1983;105:80-5.
29. Anderson DN. Methods for scaling icing test conditions. AIAA Paper 95-0540, 1995.
30. Anderson DN. Further evaluation of traditional icing scaling methods. AIAA Paper 96-0633, 1996.
31. Anderson DN. Evaluation of constant-Weber-number scaling for icing tests. AIAA Paper 96-0636, 1996.
32. Anderson DN. Private communication at SAE AC9C committee meeting, October 1996, 1996.
33. Reich A. Interface influences upon ice adhesion to airfoil materials. AIAA Paper 94-0714, 1994.
34. Stallabrass JR, Price RD. On the adhesion of ice to various materials. Can Aeronautics Space J 1963;9:199-204.
35. Anderson DN, Reich AD. Tests of the performance of coatings for low ice adhesion. AIAA Paper 97-0303, 1997.
36. Charpin F, Fasso G. Icing testing in the large Modane wind tunnel on full scale and reduced scale models. L'Aeronautique et l'Astronautique, no. 38, English translation published as NASA TM-75373, 1972.
37. Ruff GA. Analysis and verification of the icing scaling equations. Volume 1 Revision (U), Arnold Engineering Development Center AEDC-TR-85-30-V-1-REV, 1986.
38. Kind RJ, Dillon T, Gaydos JA, Oleskiw M. Evidence for importance of scaling viscous effects in the water film in glaze icing tests. AIAA Paper 98-0196, 1998.
39. Olsen W. Survey of aircraft icing simulation test facilities in North America. NASA TM. 81707, 1981.
40. Potapczuk MG, Reinmann JJ. Icing simulation: a survey of computer models and experimental facilities. AGARD CP-496, 1991.
41. Hunt JD. Engine icing measurement capabilities at the AEDC. AGARD CP 236, 1978.
42. Swift RD. Icing test facilities at the national gas turbine establishment, AGARD CP-236, 1978.
43. Bartlett CS. An analytical study of icing similitude for aircraft engine testing. AEDC-TR-86-26 (AD-A 173713) DOT/FAA/CT-86-35, 1986.
44. Reehorst AL, Rictcher PG. New methods and materials for moldings and casting ice formations. NASA TM 100126, 1987.
45. Gulick BG. Effects of simulated ice formation on the aerodynamic characteristics of an airfoil. NACA WRL-292, 1938.
46. Clareus U. Ice simulation: A 2-dimensional wind tunnel investigation of a NACA 652 A2515 wing section with single slotted flap. Report FFA AU-995 Part 2, 1974.
47. Bragg MB. Rime ice accretion and its effect on airfoil performance. NASA CR 165599, 1982.
48. Bragg MB, Coirier WJ. Aerodynamic measurements of an airfoil with simulated glaze ice. AIAA Paper 86-0484, 1986.
49. Khodadoust A, Bragg MB. Measured aerodynamic performance of a swept wing with a simulated ice accretion. AIAA Paper 90-0490, 1990.
50. Bragg MB, Spring SA. An experimental study of the flow field about an airfoil with glaze ice. AIAA Paper 87-0100, 1987.
51. Spring SA. An experimental mapping of the flow field behind a glaze ice shape on a NACA 0012 airfoil. NASA CR 180847, 1988.
52. Bragg MB, Khodadoust A. Effect of simulated glaze ice on a rectangular wing. AIAA Paper 89-0750, 1989.
53. Bragg MB, Khodadoust A, Soltani R, Wells S, Kerho M. Effect of a simulated ice accretion on the aerodynamics of a swept wing. AIAA Paper 91-0442, 1991.
54. Khodadoust A. A flow visualization study of the leading edge separation bubble on a NACA 0012 airfoil with simulated glaze ice. NASA CR 180846,1988.
55. Kerho MF, Bragg MB. Helium bubble visualization of the spanwise separation on a NACA 0012 with simulated ice shape. AIAA Paper 92-0413, 1992.
56. Bragg MB, Khodadoust A. Experimental measurements in a large separation bubble due to a simulated glaze ice accretion. AIAA Paper 88-0116, 1988.
57. Bragg MB, Khodadoust A. Measurements in a leading-edge separation bubble due to a simulated airfoil ice eccretion. AIAA Journal 1992;30:(6).
58. Bragg MB, Kerho MF, Khodadoust A. LDV flowfield measurements on straight and swept wing with a simulated ice accretion. AIAA Paper 93-0300, 1993.
59. Jones R, Williams DH. The effect of surface roughness on the characteristics of airfoils. RAE R & M 1708, 1936.
60. Wickens RH, Nguyen VD. Wind tunnel investigation of wing propeller model performance degradation due to distributed upper surface roughness and leading edge shape modifications. AGARD CP-496, 1991.
61. Ljungstrom BLG. Wind tunnel investigation of simulated hoar frost on a 2-dimensional wing section with and without high lift devices. Report FFA-AU-902, 1972.
62. Boer SN, Van Hengst J. Aerodynamic degradation due to distributed roughness on high lift configuration. AIAA Paper 93-0028, 1993.
63. Valarezo WO, Lynch FT, McGhee RJ. Aerodynamic performance effects due to small leading-edge ice (Roughness) on wings and tails. J Aircraft 1993;30(6).
64. Kind RJ. Lawrysyn MA. Effects of frost on wing aerodynamics and take-off performance. AGARD CP-496, 1991.
65. Orr DJ, Breuer KS, Hansman RJ. Quantitative analysis of ice accretion roughness using spectral and stochastic techniques. AIAA Paper 95-0888, 1995.
66. Bragg MB, Kerho MF, Cummings M. Effect of initial ice roughness on airfoil aerodynamics. AIAA Paper 94-0800, 1994.
67. Van Fossen GJ, Simoneau RJ, Cheng CY. Influence of turbulence parameter, Reynolds number and body shape on stagnation region heat transfer. J Heat Transfer 1995;117:597-603.
68. Van Fossen GJ, Simoneau RJ, Olsen WA, Shaw RJ. Heat transfer distributions around nominal ice accretion shapes formed on a cylinder in the NASA Lewis Icing Research Tunnel. AIAA Paper 84-0017, 1984.
69. Masiulaniec KC, De Witt KJ, Dukhan N, Van Fossen GJ. Experimental technique and assessment for measuring the convective heat transfer from natural ice accretions. AIAA Paper 95-0537, 1995.
70. Dukhan N, Van Forsen GJ, Masiulaniec KC, De Witt KJ. Convective heat transfer coefficients from various types of ice roughened surfaces in parallel and accelerated flow. AIAA Paper 96-0867, 1996.
71. Pais M, Singh SN, Zou L. Determination of the local heat transfer characteristics on glaze accretions on a NACA 0012 airfoil. AIAA Paper 88-0292, 1988.
72. Pais M, Singh SN. Local heat transfer coefficients of simulated smooth glaze ice formations on a cylinder. J Thermophys Heat Transfer 1987;1(2).
73. Arimili RV, Keshok EG. Measurements of local convective heat transfer coefficients on ice accretion shapes. AIAA Paper 84-0018, 1984.
74. Newton JE, Van Fossen GJ, Poinsatte PE, Dewitt KJ. Measurement of local convective heat transfer coefficients from a smooth and roughened NACA-0012 airfoil: Flight Test Data. AIAA Paper 88-0287, 1988.
75. Poinsatte PE, Van Fossen GJ, Dewitt KJ. Convective heat transfer measurement from a NACA 0012 airfoil in flight and in the NASA Lewis Icing Research Tunnel. AIAA Paper 90-0199, 1990.
76. Henry RC, Hansman RJ, and Breuer KS. Measurement of heat transfer variation on surface roughness elements using infrared techniques. AIAA Paper 94-0801, 1994.
77. Bragg MB, Cummings M, Lee S, Henze CB. Layer and heat transfer measurements on an airfoil with simulated ice roughness. AIAA Paper 96-0866, 1996.
78. Yurkanin DJ. Microphysical models for simulating realistic ice accretions. AIAA Paper 93-0025, 1993.
79. Hansman RJ. Droplet size distribution effects on aircraft ice accretion. J Aircraft 1985;22(6).
80. Gelder TF, Smyers WH, von Glahn U. Experimental droplet impingements on several two-dimensional airfoils with thickness ratios of 6 to 16 percent. NACA TN 3839, 1956.
81. Papadakis M, Elangovan R, Freund GA Jr, Bree MD. Experimental water droplet impingement data on two-dimensional airfoils, axisymmetric inlet and Boeing 737-300 engine inlet. AIAA Paper 87-0097, 1987.
82. Papadakis M, Breer M, Craig N, Liu X. Experimental water droplet impingement data on airfoils, simulated ice shapes, an engine inlet and a finite wing. NASA CR 4636, 1994.
83. Bragg MB, Wells SL. Effect of wind tunnel walls on airfoil droplet impingement. J Aircraft 1994;31:1.
84. Saitor JD, Abbott CE. Prediction and measurement of the accelerated motion of water drops in air. J Appl Meteorol 1975;14:232-9.
85. Bilanin AJ, Quackenbush TR, Feo A. Feasibility of predicting performance degradation of airfoils in heavy rain. NASA CR-181842, 1989.
86. Pavarov OA, Shalneu KK, Navarov OI, Shalovasov IA. Collision of droplets with a moving plane surface. Trans. in Soviet Physics-Doklady (USA). 1975;20(11):782-3.
87. Rockenback FA, Alexander DR. An experimental study of angular collisions between drops and mving liquid films. Proceedings of ASME-ANS, Nuclear Reactor Thermal Hydraulic Topical Meeting, Saratoga, New York, 1980.
88. Feo A. Rotating arms applied to studies of single angular drop impacts. AIAA Paper 87-02, 1987.
89. Hastings EC, Weinstein LM. Preliminary indications of water film distribution and thickness on an airfoil in a water spray. NASA TM 85796, 1984.
90. Feo A, Rogles F, Urdiales M. The measurements of water film thickness on airfoils in heavy rain conditions using conductance sensors. AGARD CP 496, 1991.
91. Gabour LA, Lienhard VJH. Wall roughness effects on stagnation-point heat transfer beneath an impinging liquid jet. ASME J Heat Transfer, 1994;116:81-7.
92. Preston GM, Blackman CC. Effect of ice formations on airplane performance in level cruising flight. NACA 1598, 1948.
93. Neel CB Jr, Bright LG. The effect of ice formations on propeller performance. NACA TN 2212, 1950.
94. Gray VH, von Glahn UH. Effects of ice and frost formations on drag of NACA 65-212 airfoil for various modes of thermal ice protection. NACA TN 29, 1953.
95. Gray VH, von Glahn UH. Aerodynamic effects caused by icing of an unswept NACA 65A004 airfoil. NACA TN 4155, 1957.
96. Gray VH. Prediction of aerodynamic penalties caused by ice formation on various airfoils. NACA WRL-292, 1964.
97. Gray VH. Correlations among ice measurements, impingement rates, icing conditions, and drag coefficients for unswept NACA 65A004 airfoil. NACA TN 2962, 1958.
98. Kissling HH, Aircraft engine anti-icing test and evaluation technology. AIAA paper 72-162, 1972.
99. Berg AL, Wolff HE. Aircraft engine icing test techniques and capabilities at the AEDC. AIAA Paper 76-10, 1976.
100. Olsen W, Shaw R, Newton J. Ice shapes and resulting drag increase for a NACA 0012 airfoil. NASA TM 83556, 1984.
101. Potapczuk MG, Berkowitz BM. An experimental investigation of multi-element airfoil ice accretion and resulting performance degradation. NASA TM-101441, 1989.
102. Guffond DP. Icing and de-iing test on a 1/4 scale rotor in the ONERA SIMA wind tunnel. AIAA Paper 86-0480, 1986.
103. Flemming RJ, Bond TH, Britton RK. Results of a sub-scale model rotor icing test. AIAA Paper 91-0660, 1991.
104. Bond TH, Flemming RJ, Britton RL. Icing test of a sub-scale model main rotor. Proceedings of the 46th Annual American Helicopter Society Forum, 1990:267-81.
105. Flemming RJ, Bond TH, Britton RK. Model rotor icing test in the NASA Lewis Icing Research Tunnel. AGARD Specialists Meeting, Effects of Adverse Weather on Aerodynamics, Toulouse, France, AGARD CP 496, 1991.
106. Bond TH, Shin J, Mesander G. Advanced ice protection systems test in the NASA Lewis Icing Research Tunnel. NASA TM 103757, 1991.
107. Personne P. Effect de la Rugosite sur la Croisance du Givre a Faible Vitesse: Resultats Experimentaux et Modelisation. D. Sc. Thesis, L'Universite Blaise-Pascal (Clermont-Ferrand II), 1988.
108. Shin J, Bond TH. Surface roughness due to residual ice in the use of low power deicing systems. NASA TM 105971, 1993.
109. Hansman RJ, Kirby MS. Comparison of wet and dry growth in artificial and flight icing conditions. J Thermophys 1987;1(3).
110. Hansman RJ. Analysis of surface roughness generation in aircraft ice accretion. AIAA Paper 92-0298, 1992.
111. Bilanin AJ. Mechanisms resulting in accreted ice roughness. AIAA Paper 92-0297, 1992.
112. Miller CM. Numerical method for liquid water content prediction in the Air Force flight test center icing spray cloud - towards more effective testing. Proceedings of the Sixth Annual Symposium, Society of Flight Test Engineers, 1975:335-46.
113. Ashenden R, Marwitz JD. A Comparison of the Air Force Water Spray Tanker Artificial Drizzle Cloud Distributions to the Natural Environment. Publication unknown.
114. Belte D. Helicopter icing spray system. Proceedings of the 11th Annual Symposium of the Society of Flight Test Engineers, Atlanta, GA, August 1980.
115. Chambers HW, Adams JY. Summary of artificial and natural icing tests conducted on U.S. army aircraft from 1974 to 1985. DOT/FAA CT- 85/26, TR-85-F-11, 1986.
116. CAA, Advisory Material for Helicopter Limited Icing Clearances. United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority, CAA Paper 96009, 1996.
117. Olsen W, Takeuchi D, Adams K. Experimental comparison of icing cloud instrumentation. NASA TM 83340, AIAA Paper 83-0026, 1983.
118. Hovenac EA. Calibration of droplet sizing and liquid water content instrumentation: survey and analysis. NASA CR 17 5099, 1986.
119. Baumgardner D. An analysis and comparison of five water droplet measuring instruments. J Climate Appl Meteorol. 1983;22.
120. Brun R, Lewis W, Perkins P, Sacrafini J. Impingement of cloud droplets on a cylinder and procedure for measuring liquid water content and droplet sizes in supercooled clouds by rotating cylinder method. NACA Report 1215, 1955.
121. Bachalo WD, Houser MJ. Development of the phase doppler spray analyzer for liquid drop size and velocity characterizations. Proc. AIAA/SAE/ASME 20th Joint Propulsion Conference, Cincinnati, OH, June 1984.
122. Bachalo WD, Houser MJ. Spray drop size and velocity measurements using the phase doppler particle analyzer. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Liquid Atomization and Spray Systems, London, England, July 1985.
123. DOT/FAA. Aircraft icing handbook, vol. 1, 2. DOT/FAA CT-88/8-1 (1991-1993).
124. Smith SO. Ice thickness and particle size from an eddy current deicer. ELECTRIMPACT Inc. 940117, 1994.
125. Shin J, Bond TH, Meesander GA. Result of a low power ice protection system test and a new method of imaging data analysis. NASA TM 105745, 1992.
126. Guffond D, et Brunet L. Validation du programme bidimensional de captation. ONERA, RT no 20/5146 SY, 1985.
127. Gent RW. TRAJICE2 - A combined water droplet and ice accretion prediction code for aerofoils. Royal Aerospace Establishment TR 90054, 1990.
128. Wright WB. Users manual for the improved NASA Lewis ice accretion code LEWICE 1.6. NASA CR-198355, 1995.
129. Brahimi MT, Tran P, Paraschivoiu I. Numerical simulation and thermodynamic analysis of ice accretion on aircraft wings. Centre de Développment Technologique de l'École Polytechnique de Montréal, Final Report C.D.T. Project C159, 1994.
130. Bourgault Y, Habashi WG, Dompierre J, Boutanios Z, Di Bartolomeo W. An Eulerian approach to supercooled droplets impingement calculations. AIAA Paper 97-0176, 1997.
131. Potapczuk MG. LEWICE/E: an Euler based ice accretion code. NASA TM-105389, AIAA Paper 92-0037, 1992.
132. Caruso SC. NEARICE - An unstructured-mesh Navier-Stokes-based ice accretion prediction method. AIAA Paper 94-0606, 1994.
133. Bidwell CS, Mohler SR. Collection efficiency and ice accretion calculations for a sphere, a swept MS(1)-317 wing, a swept NACA 0012 wing tip, an axisymmetric inlet, and a Boeing 737-200 inlet. NASA TM-106831, AIAA Paper 95-0755, 1995.
134. Guffond D, Hedde T. Prediction of ice accretion: comparison between the 2D and 3D codes. La Recherche Aérospatiale 1994;(2):103-15.
135. Wright WB, Bidwell CS. Additional improvements to the NASA Lewis ice accretion code LEWICE. NASA TM-106849, AIAA Paper 95-0752, 1995.
136. Al-Khalil KM, Keith TG, DeWitt KJ, Nathman JK, Dietrich DA. Thermal analysis of engine inlet anti-icing systems. AIAA Paper 88-0759, 1989.
137. Keith TG, DeWitt KJ, Wright WB, Masiulaniec KC. Overview of numerical codes developed for predicting electrothermal de-icing of aircraft blades. AIAA Paper 88-0288, 1988.
138. Wright WB, Keith TG, DeWitt KJ. Numerical simulation of icing, deicing, and shedding. AIAA Paper 91-0665, 1991.
139. Scavuzzo RJ, Chu ML, Olsen WA. Structural properties of impact ices accreted at aircraft surfaces. NASA CR-179580, 1987.
140. Ramamurthy S, Keith TG, DeWitt KJ, Putt JC, Martin CA, Leffel KL. Numerical modeling of an advanced pneumatic impulse ice protection system (PIIP) for aircraft. AIAA Paper 91-0555, 1991.
141. Martin C, Putt J. An advanced pneumatic impulse ice protection system (PIIP) for aircraft. AIAA Paper 90-0492, 1990.
142. Wright WB, Gent RW, Guffond D. DRA/NASA/ONERA collaboration on icing research, part II - prediction of airfoil ice accretion. NASA CR-202349, 1997.
143. Wright WB, Potapczuk MG. Comparison of LEWICE 1.6 and LEWICE/NS with IRT experimental data from modern airfoil tests. AIAA Paper 97-0175, 1997.
144. Velazquez MT, Hansman RJ. Implementation of combined feather and surface normal models in LEWICE/X. AIAA Paper 95-0753, 1995.
145. Roehorst AL. Prediction of accretion on a Swept NACA 0012 airfoil and comparison to flight tests. AIAA Paper 93-0004, 1993.
146. Al-Khalil K, Keith T, Dewitt K. Further Development of an Anti-icing Runback Model. AIAA Paper 91-0266, 1991.
147. Dukhan N, Masiulaniec KC, DeWitt KJ. Experimental technique and assessment for measuring the convective heat transfer from natural ice accretions. AIAA Paper 95-0537, 1995.
148. Ashenden RA. Conducting artificial tailplane icing evaluations at the air force flight test center. AIAA Paper 95-0450, 1995.
149. Addy HE, Miller DR, Ide RF. A study of large droplet ice accretion in the NASA Lewis IRT at near-freezing conditions; part 2. NASA TM 107424, 1996.
150. Brahimi MT, Tran P, Paraschivoiu I, Tezok F. Prediction of ice accretion on supercritical and multi-element airfoils. AIAA Paper 95-0754, 1995.
151. Potapczuk MG, Al-Khalil KM, Velazquez MT. Ice accretion and performance degradation calculations with LEWICE/NS. NASA TM-105972, AIAA Paper 93-0173, 1993.
152. Flemming RJ, Britton RK, Bond TH. Role of wind tunnels and computer codes in the certification and qualification of rotorcraft for flight in forecast icing. NASA TM 106747, October 1994 (also Paper Number 53, proceedings of the Twentieth European Rotorcraft Forum, 4-7 October 1994).
153. Gent RW. A review of icing research at the Royal Aerospace Establishment. AGARD CP 496, 1991.
154. Gent RW, Markiewicz RH, Cansdale JT. Further studies of helicopter rotor ice accretion and protection, Vertica 1987;11(3):473-92.